Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
303
. . .' RECEIVED J IJ 6 ~ ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS ~RT 111977 TOWN OF WAPPINGER EUINE H. SNOWDEI ACTION ON APPEAL Appeal No. ..........~.l.i.~................ Dated ..J'iax.....~l.,.....lS.7..7. Appellant ..~~~g~~.~.L...~~~.~~~:.~..J...(~~.~....$..~~.~.~.~.~~.)......... Address...........+..?....~E~.+..~.:J....~9...::::~~................... ....~~~~~.!~.P..!!~.".....~!'!...X~!~.......J?:~9.J............................................. .......... .... . ......... .......................................................................... At a meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals on ....................................h.~y.....l".~.........................................., 19...7..:7...., Appeal No...~g.~............... was considered and the following action on the request for: .&J A VARIANCE, o A SPECIAL USE PERMIT, 0 AN INTERPRETATION OF THE ZONING ORDINANCE, o AN APPEAL AS AN AGGRIEVED PERSON(S), was taken: r. VARIANCE: By resolution ()If the Board, it was determined that strict application of the Ordinance o would 0 would not produce undue hardship for these reasons: a. The property in question 0 would 0 would not yield a reasonable return if limited to the use permitted under the Ordinance, because: .................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. b. The hardship created 0 is 0 is not unique and 0 would 0 would not be shared by all properties alike in the vicinity of the property and in the same use district, because:' .................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .....n........................................................................................................................................................................................................................... c. The variance 0 wauld 0 would not change the character of the district, because: ..................... ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Therefore, it was further determined that the requested variancetJ be gra:nted Bbe-eeniedand that the previous decision of the Enforcement Officer~-mmtmted ~ be reversed. * PLEASE is!!: ~ A T'l'ACl'D:U) ~J::iJ:l;!:.. T . 2. SPECIAL USE PERMIT: By resolution of the Board it was determined that the request for a Special Use Permit 0 be granted 0 be denied, pursuant to article ........................, section or subsection ....................., paragraph .................................... of the Zoning Ordinance and, therefore, the decision of the En- forcement Officer 0 be reversed 0 be confirmed, because: ................................................................................................ ............................................................................................................ ...................................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 1. INTERPRETATION: The Board adopted the following resolution which stated its interpretation of the Zoning Ordinance as requested in your appeal: ............................................................................................................ .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... ..,..........................................................................................................................,....."........,..................................................................................................... 4. AGGRIEVED PERSON(S): By resolution of the Board, the following decision was made on your a.ppeal: .................................................... ............................................... .............. ........ ......... .............................................................................", ............. ...........................................................................................,...........................................,...... .....,.............................................................................................. ........................................................................................................................,........................................................................................................................... .............~....(,...~.~.~~. ........................................ o c(~ainnan, Z~:;h:;~ Appeals J; /~ ,':, Appeal . 303 May 11th. 1977 '1'he us. variance 1. g:r:ard:414 "'j~ t.o t.la8 Appellan't.. coaplyiD.9 wi~ t.h4I CIOft41t.l.. st.1P'll.,*, in t.he PlanniAg Board.'. resolut.ion dat.ed AU9U8t. 28t.h.. 1175 w1:th the tollowill, ....daent., 5. ........ trtacks.hall be __ed/park.. in.i.. t.he !Ml11d1ft4g aft8 houa 01 opel"at.1oa. 6. ft. woven. ..1ft 11nk f.... surrounding the property 1.. to be aacepbbl. for ...-iA9 pupo.... ('- :~i ' -.i!t$mi';'';,:l'~)' .~~ .. ..." .'"11.".... ~,' 1,,."'.'. '. l ,1,-,. "'N ,- ' .. ~ , T ,.~~ PLANNING BOARD TOWN OF WAPPINGER TOWN HALL WAPPINGER5 FALLS. NEW YORK 12590 TEL. 297-6257 Report 'ro: Sylvia J. Anderson, zoning Adl'T\inistrator From: Town of Wappinger Planning Board Date: August 26th, 1975 Subject: Application of N. & G. Sanitation for si.te plan Approval At the August 18th, 1975 meeting, the Town of Wappinger Planning Board adopted the follo'tling resolution: :BE I'r RESOLVED THi\'r the ~rm'm of \l1r1ppinger ?lannin;j 3o"'lrd h8reby gl~ants fin;",l site plcm Clpproval to Hr. Hichael Schwall for site plan entitled "site Plan. Lands of H & G Sanitation, Hughsonvill(~ - Hopc~\.velJ Eo?d1 TmV11 of H2ppint)er, Dutcho~)s Cotmt.y I rT:>:,/ -'{ark", prepo.:Led by J.\nthony T. ROWC1D, ?E. &. L.S., and dat:ed 7\p,' :'.1 30th, 1975 and revised ',ugust 18th, 1975 and subj ect to the follo,,;.,ing conditions: 1. Final disposition of the drainage from this property must be indicated and approved by the Engineer to the Town or in the case water discharg(~s onto Hop2',.;ell Road approval of the Dutchess County Department of Wo~ks shall be obtained. 2. Approval of the Dutchess County Department of Health shall be. obtained if a ne;", well or sewage dispoSC'l.l facilit:iE-~s c\J.:-e to be installed. 3. Size and location of any signs on the premisesrnust be approved by the Zoning Adminis.trator. 4. premises are to be used for the storage and repair of the vehicles. No garbage or other wastes are to be stored on the premises. , '- 5. Garbage trucks shall be stored inside the building. <4' J " ~ , . '<.- ,- . PLANNING BOARD TOWN OF WAPPINGER TOWN HALL. WAPPINGERS FALLS, NEW YORK 12590 TEL.. 297.6257' M. & G. Sanitation -2- August 26t.h, 1975 6. The ~1l0Vdn chain link fence surrounding the propl:!1:'ty is acceptable for screening purposes. 7. Hours of operation shall be 4:00 a.m. til 6:00 p.m. 8. Maintenance work shall be conducted during the hours of 7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. 9. provisions for orainage oJ: residue and rodent control nmst: Iv.;'! ~)cceptable .to the :-.>utchess County D(~p~u~tment of: lIe a.l.tl1 . br cc: OiOltr:.::h:::SB County Dep"lrtJ:-:i.'mt of Health Dutch(~ss,. County Department of Public Works Bruno Hermans, Building Inspector Hughsonville Fire Company R'Llc101ph E. Lapar, Eng ine,~r to the Town An)f~rt p. Roberts, Applicant I s Attorney .Anthony T. Rowan, ?E. & L.S. Nich:u~l Schwall, Applicant Elaine H. Sno\<lden, Town Clerk . "', .,,_f II . ~,w i' " ,., jI II ,I il !i I' il 'I I, '. I! :1 iI ..Ij I! 11 Ii 'I " I' I! II 'I " II II I I , I , II II II I, I .j 'I I , I I! II ,I I l: 'i I I I I II i I II I I d ..,,'~ L, E ,- O'l,CH \, f.,;- , ',t Y ,A; A,V", I A.,{ " .. . '.....!tf- I " l : .' f',.) ,'~ At a Special Tenl of the Sup:!.'er::c.' Court of the St2.t>~ o[ XC\\' York, l)('l:.l i nil !II! r 0 r t; It' C (l \ i; 1 t\' c f JJUrChC5S, 8.t the COUi't:io'l~e, in the' City 0: l'ou~'hkeepsic, ;\('\.; York, on the 23rd Jay of Augllst, 1070. P R L S J: \ T !IU\;. JOS!:P!i JIU]llCE,' Justice STATL or \U,; YO!,K ~;UPRE~lE COlil,'!' : Cl1U\TY or lliJTClILSS .. _ _ _ _ _........ _...... _ _.. -- __.... -.... -.. - -.. - -.... u -.. - - - - --x In thl~ i-,liltler or '.i & G SA\ 11'.\'1' Ilf'J, J.':L:. ~lJl cl '.1 I CHAJ:L S Ciil\':\ L L , ORDl: E Index No. 1975i4237 Calendar ;':0. 43 Petitioners, -ag3jnst- CIL\RLLS 1\. COlnrr.l.li\O, VICTOR Fi\\tJLl.1~, .Josrp!I E. L\\!lt)LFI, IIO\',':\lZJ) PRAC;El~ and C:\R(iL \\'.\DDLJ:, consti tlltin~; the nOiinl of :::oning'\pJw:l.L of the l'V,..llOJ \\~:lppjngcr, J~CSpOIll1clltS . .. _ - .. -- - - .. - ... .. .. .. .. - .. ,.. - .. .. .. .. -" ..........-................ - .. .. .. x Upon reading :lnd filing the I'-:oticc of Supplemcilt~I.1 Pl'titiC1Tl of p.~,tLtionl'J, ill & G ~ilrliL!tion~ Inc. emd ~;lil'ha,,~l :-; dli'; a 11, \,b t c..J t 11 L' .:~) tit Ll; l;: 0 r ,J ~ lit (', 197 h, SUP!) 0 r t e d by tit c 1" c tit ion 0 r ;> I c; (; :-; :l nit: L t ion, 1 n L' . and ;- lie hac 1 S c h \\ a 11 ~ YC'rificd '''-. the 1st da\' of .July, l~)~'CI, \~ith Lxltibits thereto attached, the affidad.t or ~\lichael Scll\-'~LlI, S\\Ot'1l to the ]st day of July, 19ft), ~llld tlll' afrida\'l t or Albert, P. -l~ob('rts, S\\'OUl to the lq' d a v 0 [ .J III y, 1 ~l "7 () ins up p (\ r t t h (' reo r, the sup pIe m t: II tal (l n s \': C r 0 f II II ",. Hl'S~,l.. \ l. ....l >, CH I."" ~ ...~ ~.. .~ I,; I- ."1 : t....~ ~ .oif.. f P,. . l r J>~ ~ Ny! .':ot.. "\ i: jl till' :~l\<pl)ni.L.':'l:t. ., ' ( :1:: r I : ( . I. 'J l' t i \ 1 1 i! i j, \.! (_~ t (._~ 1 ~ J ' ~ t ! 'll t ('. '1- c \ ~ ,J()-.:.cph i!'".;lrl~ ;';.,!-:,'j 'llU (':1I'l'l ....I,:,::l', con'"titlitill!-' 1'L(; ,! 1... L~iL,,:(-" 1. I 1 Ii I :\ 1.0:1 ]',~ ') I Ii \I ;1 :i d II " ..\})j)'~.;, I ~ .'~ f,~ 11 I I! ~: (J t' . J II l\', :) 0 t II \.1:1\' ','; (, o ~'\ II :2 the lith d:'!\" .. ~,' L the ; I t' L' i d : I \ i t . i ails \: ',' r , I, II 11 II il II ,I Ii 1'1 I II II iI 1i II II II 'I II !I Ii '1 Ii Ii II Ii li Ii il' I' II " I' II I I. II August, 107c1, , a iJ l~ ti:c ,: J the l.~til d:l\' of ;\:i:::'l~~t, supplcl'1,'nt:11 i.nl:~hC';', the H:snulldc'T1t EO:Il'll , I ] t il (];l" 0 f '::<." , 011 t:1C' Ii co it r...1 0 f :: c) n j n g :\1' pC'; il s t 11_. ')'.''.'.!1 oC ~'.:q1pi;~~'.c'l', \'eriCic'd t>:e l :, :1 rei 1"~'; 1 t 1 G:1 Adams) ;1 ff i rr:lcd ci ,; ,)!l I. !" 1:1 :":'drp0i~t (~ f , , ~:1 _1 (t s"ppl...:ml'nt~l 4- ~,. _ l L-} ,\; ill to the 12t.h cbv J'u:;:-:, 5\''-C'1'11 ; ,~:l\'l t 01 ,TO-;CP;l L Landol [i, 5\".01'1\ t' 1 : - ('. 1", t 1 III rthc r i Ii S uppor to f the t L:~ 'i: ~lns\...~-ri pt" of Proceedings t~kcn 11...' t"Jr:, 0;' :~( .in,' .\]l1'c'a13 c ;:- 1lt c TOhn of \\'appi F;';C!" ! :' "c' t 1 t" lic't i on and llcci sian of to" d~1..:C.J :Jth Jay of June, 19;n, t;, .... 4.L...... t]:.C ]~ecord 0 C Proceed i n;'s Le' fc ;'l' tL.(' Boanl of Zonin!2 Appc;l1s of th,,' 'fc)\1'n of \';appin~'.~r, the ;iC:'j~i:l\'it of Alb(~rt P. Ibbcrts, s\-{nrn to tile ") ll"1 t. J" ,1.1\' ('j J' '\1' (" ,; l' .... 1 \,.1 '_. "" l . '~, . . , 1.;1\\ ~tlh:'!i t led 11\' tIt. )"[1 this (":<\11't, d:ltc'll t::c ::1:Ittc1') the cle,:-isic-:1 ('.' r . ~ (\, In rc])1y thc'reto, the !\!emc)]':md;J oC f 1 '.' :- lH'!'t. t ;) , IIp on 1 h..' prc\' i Oll'~ OrdC";' of 1 1 t! .11" 0 C .\pri.1, J~176 re!~arding this tl-. J!cn. .-;(-,.~l:pll .Ji udice, Just ice Supn=>f11L.' 1 :)'.-7, \\'hich samc' deli dE'J (ourt, d;lted t:1C ::.\t11-1:\\' ~~c ,J:u;r;:"r::, tIlt:' L(\ t i Ull :i 11 J . . , ( ~ !_~' C. -1 .--; I t" r 1 i. of the To\'.n of ~ \" ~~ 1) P 1 n~: c' r , t!-t('H'snor.Jent Fo;,'rd of Zoninrr. ,\npeal:: j ." l. i' ; ,~~ltcd the 9th da;. 1 0 7 () , III 'I ';1' T .. -,. ~- }...., ," of JUlie, IS notsupporteJ by evidence ;JnJ a use vari i"l11CC' to 1'l' t i ti (,: ~'r s a11 the 11Ipers onl1 1'ro- is arbitrary and C:lpl'ici('~:~, ;l!IJ llnon ccedillgs !lc'rCl'Jrol",' '!I:IJ h..'rcln; :\0\\' , nil ':0 t 1(.1) 1'::1 it j Oller';', f () r t: 1 e r. r 1:lJ'~:<lLL r. ,\LlllUCIl, rSQ., attorney i 1 i :' ') "l h:; , \.. t., A~. C'P:CH j,. ; ; ( .; ~ ~ . f ,.,' /,! ,.,::' VV . (,J...'.. ".1.'" ! , ,.' ~ " l' f. t'..., ;: (,.)_~ d (' Jl t \~j,:j)!;!d:j), th:Lt the n\(1( i Oil :lnd dcc:i~; i on () r till' n'~' 1>)'11',1 nr -'Ul1il1,\~ '\l~ ;)(,:! J~; 0 r tile l~ :! t (' <l rl'spondcllt r,o:lnl or ,::oning :\],1>l,:t1< (if the :)th LS herch\' ;1 :, Ii .1 Ii II ,I II Board ur Ii II !\ o f :1 II S l' d:! \' o I' .11l1~(', I ~ I ~' (, , j (l\',Jl cr l\::lppiJ1!:~'r, i ; I I' i p l' p annulled, and i t dCEvi Ii:', :1 tl~~ (' \, ;i1'! aIlCl' to lY<." 1 i t i n::c r:'~ (J I,,: i) 1: I ~ 1: J) , 1.11:11 1S 1'1: r t ;',,' l~ :: U II i Jl!; ,\]' p (' : I j:; \1 i \':1 n :11l CC \";llCjl t L c:' ;:!:I t t l.' r ish ere [, \' rcmitt~:'d tn the IlpUll tIle j 0 \. n I) r h': ! p:) i n g c r ! I 5 s U ~I:l C2 ! I r Ii fort he t (' 1'111 S ;1. ~I L1 cO:H:i t i OilS as the ~; 8 i Ii t h '_' '[ m:n O .t' ),''IT''' i '1 "C l' n ( . '1 J ;..,.l. r :; 1; Ii dCC'l:lS :lppropri:ltc :llld :t,: :I1'C pL'r),!i:~sihl(: under th,", Lu,-. I' I' II i: I, Ii II !I Ii I' I, (lnk-l' sll',llec1 ;It Ch:lilJ!)('I'~~, II J'OU1;hl.',l']1~;il', :\c\: York, II this d:t\ of l\'hJ'tl:lry, II I. II [I II II I! II II !I I I, II J I .\ i 1 ~ l'~ ! ,~. osf."i-)Tl'-:rlLldTC-c-:-:ru;T1 \.'i'- -S-tlP rEme i Court I i i ]l);'i. . '- ;- ,. .::~;~~<~,._<2 c~r.;..-<~~ CJ~'~ f~~>:':::_~ S t'......~ ':~~' '~~\f;'"{ C.~;' ~-'Ji. :';,'Ci ~:,:~-,:;~:, YC:;::;4~ -----------------.------------------- " ~r-i t;"':~ ~<C:.~ te-r G~~ X & G S~KITA'~Ir~, ::~C_ ~~~-~ ,-~ "" - -'. .. ". - -:- ,,) I -' _ _ " ~~... .J. t , .:.:::J!:::;': NO, 197J/lf?37 :? ~.~' .J.~ ::_. ~ I ,~.. C ~-" !:~. -~' :..-; ,IO~ DATE: 8/23/76 ,'J ~ ,1 J ~'l.. ~ CAL~XJA:'l NO. 113 C::;".~\~.JE'S J+\. CQ:\r~lI~:_J~'.!=I'.~()) 'II<~r=' "-t' ;-. :'~ l)::~ T t.T .:; :3 ~~ ,;:'- ~-.i ~. ~_" ;'\ .'; :) c:' .- , . .,. -~.. - ~ :.,.,. t. ,: '" ~ .~ ~.~ -:) (.~i:. C1 CI,,;~OL t', l'~~; ;...'- _._: ~,'J , co;.. ~ .~~ 5. t'. l~ : ~ r .....,,,.J ,- ,-., ','J,'-; :""".:" i.> 0:.. ~" (~f_: ':--.:' ~'.' ::~~ d,__ :.~ O T~ 'J t ~. ..... ',-'\,',':.; l ;'~, ;. t ~ ! " >' ',~ ." ~ .. ( . . ) i ~,(-; ::. ri c, r~ (1 r:.. r: ~-' => __ ____ _ _~_____ _ __ r.-_'____..__" ._. ._____ ------ '-- ,- _... .-.----.-- ---...... - -.....- v U J ,., ,. V "-', t) . .l'hi:.; . " ..l,,' (~;1 !ir1ticlp '7 I', /0 J'()'::C'_:(;i~;l; :i:~ Hr.'Len the petitionerc) s.t.! t7 }: to ann ,ll ,.... n(:'; ct. 1 d. ~)ct 2..:~; 1(1,:; C!.. C1 ..~ c :e fn :: rl c} ~ i 0 r1 .p' .c-" OJ. "ne Zoning Board or ;~:.., ~=i f~ C.l..1 s ():'"' t }'"lC rll () \~,r 11 () j ~',: (It' :. :, :-l L:: (j "") 0 Ci .I ~, Iv.l. 4.. i~_: .~' (I ~ ~1 ci t}-~1(.11; it act(~d arbi- ~'~~~ri~:; ~l~d capr)icl.o'~s~_:! ~-. ..'~ , (..1.". '-, ........', --1_. U ~ 1'-_ V .Ltc, "", ,..-. ~:- ':.' C.." \.~ \...' L) CQr~stittlted an abu<;e of (i~;c:cret::'o;-. . By pr~o~ o~d0r of t~:2 Ccur~ d~ted April 14th, 1975, ":':.:'~e proceed~.rlt:::: ;- ~~Pt:i:l.:-l ~'.i.~,"lC l",_~;..',~_ e(\ to tl"le re~:;:JO~1 nt ZoninG Board ../:~t::~ =-:istru.c.olc~Lon.;) to c:~):--i.c"l~c~t, ~ll~._~',~':c::l p~,~~,;l'Lc i~eal~~,r...~~': arId to nl~11\c: ~'::-~dj,~-:.~::) of f'd.et.- ;]::'1(1 ~.~t:(-:.::' ::"'~;:i~' (1:'; t.o ~~;t~r)~~i~~'~~'Jt; it~~ di:,).lcel"linl11rt,tiOt1. '- r\ ::)ubll_c l'1(~art~:.r~;3 ":;QL) ;-1::::1(1 c':: :.la:: 1.1.~:;~, }J76, [Lt .,,;i-li.er1 tilne t.flstilr.orlY ~.:a~:3 i~J\rcr~ 1rl ~.)l<-i~'!c)r)t c':\ t}.r~.. }-q-)~_,.it ~-):'i\~11..~' ~.t!!t)lic:_~,tj"~i~l for an illtc~r)l'e- r:.~ior~ (;:i'" ~;10 Z()~~.:~r1. o ~2d ',: r~~.. 'r~ C. t:, rL ~_; r t: C:1:1 ~ lL'),0 r~e r'[:'i '1_ t arld a use V tt ~r") -~_ a~. r-. .-'") I~ 'J d-(~ c .1. ~~, ~l. t) 1'1 > c:, (! l~:. 8th, " ~,r,. ,. ...~y i G ) the :".' ;~pondcnt L-- 0 [1 !1o~J: Clc,:'.er-;. ~;'lecl that t}jf~ 1.1:'; 'c.) '1r~t0r~(~;..1 b:l "l..;.I_: 1)ctit~I(}rler8 '~:,~t~) not PC1";',-:tt- 0' ' ,_~, ~.~'.! ,r' '.J ..... 'fl.!.. ' , " ~ " " -<---..t ;_~ .'') e ~-, c: :r J ;;-i ,:, L 'J:.( .~.~.: ~ (I lC' , t. ," .. --... "t': ,~i::, }'..' '-' ;. '-,) i '1 ,~, ") " . ..l (~~ <j ~, ,1 ,..... I i ~ ,- J. l,.; ;':);' f~ ';~l'? ~! (:l t i ~~;:' 1.0 r:~' r' _, .> . " "_ \_.l.".,.... , ;' ;; '(~. ...; 1'1 t') ~', ;,,~ : .," l, \ l:i ,.;,....,... ;..,il : ~ I... .. .;:~'r o :~ ~)Ci~-:.~ 7: ~l ":.:. ~L Orl - '" V _:.. '-.-'.. " ..... ~ rae: L...., C;1 r-:2 -'. c~ (1 :~ n t. j " J' 0... i-J.e a.~''-: T"l,:,., ~l ;:.,; r.- ~'.r..~.,. '~) ", ,--l..l. U.. l. '_' __', .... ',- ,-:. \'1 e l~~ (:~ (~ C \r e ~i 0 I:' c'~ c1 . .' ~ i",~ I,A..... ,.L (l .~. rl: ::\ (,' 1"::1:..... ~: L:'" ! ~. ~;'" d,j 1.. ',( }. ~-~ i:~ Tn;','"'"' 4-~ 1.. .....\ lr L " \~ L,u-j . , ...~, , ;'~.l-~ (1 ~ :. r) l...; t ~ .t_ :~ r) 11.1 .~ :' .Sit~~l~e in tl E: ~ia:~l(~t o~ , -, " -, l'.O:.:. '1. "I: t~' \.... " '-'-' ~ ~.} I.."l. ..."'-'; " ...' ,~' of ~, 1. :.> ~ O'~ I _~ (. [~ ~. '" , (". ;.'1. .1. ~ ' ,- :'. .~" ..) ..' C) :.~ , ~,,,.... ;..,...._1.; l~ ~~ :'1 ~ '~. _t l. ~.l ~ -, " " ~. \, ...... . .~: ',_~J 31ori:, \r :-1. 1 ' .' {J 'l ,~ . () ~ ~ -1 , . l.J; . ~ ,- ')l,.~.r'S~2 0:"" 0~.~.~: ('i'~ ~3CL~~;~"' n~':.~,: ': :_j ::~ .:lil (1, t: ~ '.} Ct !': 1~-' 0:- ';r,-,:d /...i'ltc..:.' l'i__lr;_'\ ~. . l. .. .. L ()!1:1- r'l ;_~.. :) Xl ,.::. t'~ a.rJ. e i:.: .-, " \,......... atLrJ a ~:'~) e r:I': I...'~ c) r. 6~ i~~rl':~ ell ~>) ~1 t: l"i ~_ ;:' ~'l ~ "r-,..-.. ,.' ,. . '- , .~) : L.~ S C~ v ,_~ ~ - j :1 C I,;,,} . ~~~ c:-} \',' L~ ~~~; -' ~ ~ t i". t~.' C >::-" e r c;~. c~ P :.J.l") C (11 t't i~: 1. L:1 ':: 'D~}'!,\ ~_:; : .:_~ r: :~L t a.r~ }'} .; '" c' c ;: - I" ,;:'; C -1- >. ,'\ 1 J ~ i t..... C '.) tl !")() l~ (~- . +- -' C()-j".)et r..~: ~ e ()(~er . . , ..'.._1 () l J. C i: "(; ~:. ,~, i 1 Li (_~ S ~~. : ~ ;,} ~~: ;...: }~'ro::. L' ..-'\ l")~Ci)l)d ..\ , ; ;C; Ct~"!l troVi=..rsy f' C~2 t ~; :~; 1..~~;:' r 0 ~~ n.-1 ~:_ LA t~ t :-! 1. ~) ~ ;'~~;llc(l ..:~() Ll-.e TH~':~ ~ ~;~~rlf}l'") in j'J}l."'c;'~, '\"-- .\... ,~. ",J ___ '-,', - L ' , I .. '...'. C':~i r '; :~~ t..~ - r~ ~ () \'..' :'"~ of' ~,\'~-,.;:r::.:-"l[-e:". . I,) -"- ~ " t " t ~:_t }'-,; !)u,rc(~.l ..., ." tJ ,', lanel ~'~ c q u :,~ .:-l\-. c: a, !':I:,,~or:'vl11e' cirl tY~e ::~C)ll" 1~.L ~)].d(~ of 0::,c1 ~':, C (; l;.-j :cccl Tjli() 1 f'Cl~'l ;~. :"' t =/ t;..,_, ro](~ ~\., 1 J (: { , tI.:; ~ 1~1") L () r' \r c: : ~.~ c _'- .; S u ,: c: d . ],1". t}-:e , "-'," _'_ ~ .1....... Ti' t. " 1::;~ : \ r'i(: t: .~1 -..1'1 or. e r' ll~(i '--i r 'i r' (', ,J. ~"l ::~ c ~ 1i.' '.' c: f j ,-- ,d t: ,', (, _{"I .-' J_ I_l! () ...; rl ''-'..'~t r'::J:i 11 r~e r" 2.:--.d ~.~ ~l i ~, e (:i .1,-; o~ t;--i'~ :--it:~l~r~.e (}f l~~:.s ..~. r~ ~'/ ~'; \'j ,:L:3 tv :_,(, ~ J':' ~ ~ .. ,'.' ~.:. .' t .~l (,--'-.:.... ,:. , , ~., .L l.l, , '- (' ;-. ;;. ~.. ~~ > t:1C ;)E~~,itloneT' Schwall ""~.1.~lC~:'.~':~~~~~(4 ti~e :pl1oI)eL)~~'t~"r fO~"f ~~,~~E ,OCj'J. 00 c~ (: :.:.:) 1 ~. ..~ ; j, ~.: 11 C f):<: ;'3 t . ,.. :'.. r," .\.~. . ....., ~. ~) -..~.L .l (1 ~~ r1 ~ ~) t (;~1('t[...-, fur.') t ;~':' .' .. \ .:~, :,' ;"l ~L C c ..~, '-':: '-, .~ (". .':.,-' ,-', ". . . t: _:~ L. .. : ':) ]1 : ~ j 4 ......) ,'C;,_ ~'.' ,-... .,. j. \,J.l \,.. ... ,(;. ::: 4..1 ~,~; J C:: 'j lie tr-,el~ea,:.ter d(_'tf~l~;d.l rH~ll 11C ;-~~: l" ,.~..~ :., l.~t"l:;.', c. i t:l(: 'j..":':"c,pcr't;/ ~'~rl(j COil::,: t': ~'UC t ~:;-1d L<i.lilt,c'~l~lnce of tIle \t (: II j C ~~.. (; ~) and ;. ~i YI " .l. ~~,j. .J '.. ")l"-, ,--; (,.....1....-1. ~3 i,te f: 1 tlri ,j. \,; 8 ~ ~ ~.) 1'")(< ~-. ;;l.,_~J,:~', <,] \',:r" ~,ri ~;l'. Pl~i.:'!Ltrl[: l~t)('!'l. l. Uz~ :'. ,--t '.. ~"~.j ~ J ., 0,:;...... "1 ___ '.J V 4..1 , r' ....~ (1 \"' :)- C .~'? ~.~ (; ',-~' C~ '" ... t.t:~L i n.~": ;),J (-~ ~ I"..{ ~~ :~ t2 ~) -.L- ,:1.:1 .,?-'l'.... r'l 1-' .~ v, J Un r ......,._.-., L- 'J t-. ~ ! ~ "~ - LI ~1. l', Cl~J r; L n "e ~') l=-- e '":' 1 -:: :L rJ ~-A ;:) X" to ? : (~;. ~ rl _~. t~ 21~ I':' o,~ ~:) c~ . ;> ::. . (: ;j '2 r' ~,; y , ~/ 1-- "..; -L.' .' L . ~ '..:._' '\- ,'"', "~;. ; 1 ~ . ~ ..J'-', , I. _} \_~ l ~-, .:. ~ . ':'j 1.: Lt t-_) S ';,1 (~ , , :-1,'. ~' ..... c'~ ;'H"~.~ ~~-. ~'~ ,~ :.. ,':.'-' l, ':;~lb el' 1...) j I;. 1 ~~ : ~ L>~~ ;. ~ ,Cl c (; ~ii:~c;C~ :.~ C (~ C t) :1 ~~, -~ ":")l~.... ~l.ll ~..") ~"; :,,: :': _ v ~ ~ () :l ; ~ ~.~ l~ ( l C ~:. <: <-~ )', ,'j '," J..l ,J (J,. ~.:) ::-'[1 ():-' ci 1: ~i Cd: ~ ..:. ():.:~ .t.. '"'' _ v;.. I~; \ '..--' ~ ~ ~ '- --'.... ",) - - a::..:J l~:~ ::~ ():.'""' ::i :')~) _~'l 0 x.-: : i~'J.. .j~ (:.1 y c- ~,~. ~' ), "CO ::.;:!~: ~~:L~;e CU.L(~ Ci._:!ri~jt'~,'G.(;~:..LC 'j'h(~ ',--:~V d('.'11C1,') .1. v ; 'l-" j su:ri ~1. '\:' ~ .~ (J .:.') () l' l} ~ t (-'~ .~ ~~ : .~: ~:'. 11 ~~.: 1) '':',' I1 : : ~l l: .:,. '. ~ ,~ ,-' .j L.-L.J t L:lt: L! In (-:'XCL1;; ,.J ,~ r'" ) ~..~ n D:'"o ">(, ': .r.:. ,.. 4 ,--, ;' 1-.1 f~i Ct b (? ':~ ;~ ~ rlC.) [) 'C. 0 ;~: () ,.: ~,: i.. :. ,'I";" ,:; C. .~~} 1 9 ;) ::-/ ()"l .:, ~) .L 0 ~1 .L~ ~.~ <: :. ) ~: ~1 () :=~ ~). ~ L .~J ;"'l :'i C ~.~ r . ".1 , ti .'~e ZO~'l :.~~i.l-"le 0; ill .. .~: fo]~ '.( ~.' ':{~ > . ~. ~ .. p',: ..; 1..:.lt: (~ 3. ~ ". t:-j('-' tt ;;',__"1 -) C 11 ~.. '[' c: ;", :., () :~ () C e ~~ :").~.'l c. ,'~ . " ~.. '..1 /\ '...iii. ... l~.. l' '.' : --I 11 ,~) ._.'. t.' (j ~.~ i: d 4__ ; 1 :': rl til' Y"i ():~. I -,...., '..L-';' L c:. . ~~' .t. -\ . ~ lJ --......-... \..) ...;. ..L '.' " ~.. ., '., ^" '. ,.... .! I .. -......; ,,( .'1',") '. , , -' , . .\.. . .~~ "--; (' , . . .~:. '.' ,/ ~~ ,.'. (. ....- ." t; .. ~ _ ..... , . ~ ., '..4. ....,~ o ~' (;u: ..,".-';...-:: (;":l c '- .::.,'~ ri.-"': (_ .~~ . " -' ) ~. ) :' - '.") \,.~. - :. (',~.: :-: Ci~... -; '''::. ~' ..t -. , l ~..~'.'~ -... .-:>?~~~ ar1d att:.orrlf?~/) -~ .' ~i-ieret 0) . t roo:,,: r:~ f ~"r. "'" L- approved tIIO , - ."-. ~ f.J- ";'...1"__'" .lC'i.,.;or of Lie fi ~~~ to 4- r~~'o l/ ~ ,,-- all ()'~.J v. .f,:-: :';C: :::'l': ., . d Z:~~ -: (lOrlZe the uy (I. --:; :-.-~ ~) =- ~ ;: ~ C'D :J regrttded tl-:e .'''1 .: ...'" l- ,.-., _..... ,....;...J 2. contract ~.: i t [1 ::' ~ 1 2~ Ii ~>- !1 g :: 11 trl(~ -....-. ".... ...-.....:._..J .~;~..r"l.:"'.l. ;_~e1::vel..C{1 to .. -, L.:; '-::' r ":: ':: ~- t ion iC: r h 3. (3 :1 n - ..>. .- ,'."" - c.':"'..:. .... .~..._ ;.; (1 :':;ttJ)el"- by the: . :_ . _ .:. C1 -L~, " -::ctor the trl8. t - ~ ~ ,~~ r., 1'- _; '--l.Li 1sT" on 1975, ,,0'" f:.1r r; (\ 2 :.:~ ~ -J .' - ,_,,- undc'r the use \.-.. .......:'....., 7 -- ~- -...... ~ Or5inance. .~. ~ .. '-_.J:- _ C ....: .:.> :;. i , tl-!f} ?l":tlnjnr~ :... () '..; : 1 i\. ~. :: 0 :' :'i (: :/ aJ1cg('dl:r }.';U c: ~.. ~ I-~;i . eouId t:lr.. prcn,ise:::; .-- j. or heal'i n ,'; the ,_~ \,-) ;.~ l~ ..~. .:~. .', > ':3ti ~., -'~,-:.>I' cc'ul'~ not It ~ " . .~. subj..'ct prop('r~:y ~ ( , " ~'l ~ (, t. ~~ l-l~!J ~:~ ct 1.' r'.(j~) C l' ~:, ~/ ~l . . "' ..1-.0 C (:1. 1~ (~(: .-.v. G.L i. _~ ...-,),.~ .~ t: v,'~ 0 l- ~_ ."- U -./.:.. ...L '_' L- ," ,.;....) c C:' _~ :", : ~ n ~~: e ,~ I~~ .:. u ~'-l ~ ;:? ~~~ () f ,-"! C II '~:' :L n e~ () Xl c1 i r~::1. ~~i. ':~~ C' r~) - t }~ e rJ.' 0 ~S (~ 0 l~ .:) '-'- r4 :~.1'-: l' . ~_:C~ G t ~~1')~. I ')) t (_ J , llrld,-~r") r,cl">rnittccl !)2~j.rlc"L:)~-:.} use~:. lr1 an T D LJ....I ..-., .: oj .<~ r ~:_ c t , k) t LL t 8 ~ ~ : :J'(. l,'l ;:) to!' '.' '--' ; ;L C 1 c ~-:a.les, r0~~~air and se~v~ce \ : . ,) ~::. -1 Ii C J L~ll L :l.'~ ._' O';,.~.i t~C of' l..J :,,~~'d,:c d C (1 i~' ~J ()}-.. tJ. L~ to r'";c: :-': .:. 1. (' n '" Y' 1- ',) " t.-"Cl.. J d. . f~\rl i ~3 "''''1-'l''''"l+- l...,'....'........ '..... doc~, not G1~)D_r=rl2e \.~7_~_t}-1 t~l;::: :-:'c~~:,~)011d.(~:--1t t s (letc,r'- ~'~.'~ :.~ 3. t.t 0:-1 t l) 8. t i) (: t }. t. -: () r 1 c~ l' y ~.) :).L)i.)r)c,~c,d.. ~l:JC " ('" .L \-) riot :;.['r:-:~ltted Uit(lc.r\ trlC f..J \', :'l ~'- tJ.~; ~)l')Ct l n. ~.l. :"1 c e, 1:1.:, '?l. 7: D l"t(.~ ;,2 ;'t:1. c1 .. f:i 1 t i'l G (,l . zonlr~ ordinances are jn ,~~('\:.Cli..;.,t"vl()!l (iil t,';jt.'} .~o~.ril[iOrl lr:.'.'l ~tr~.l, t.:!l(~;,~!v.Co.;,~'(-?) ..:\.,~_J'.f l.c f)tr~j.cl~1y CClY1- s ~~ r~Jt:ci, Ci ~~ () :-1 J_ r: ~~'.; i'}, iJ ,~l :l (i ():f.' J '. ~. > :"~i t.~' . ' . ............. 1'1 ('1. ~~ r' c ~~ ~.~ () rl ct.l.J 1-:.; ~. ;_~ t 1 t 'J. fj (; in the :.:-J. '0 c: ~'.r:1 j'~,::: t ("1 t ~~ \.1 i , 0""" .~ ,+., , , .;_ \..1 ~ 1 Ol'l~J~: r'~ (l:'~ C C (Cor)t e~rl v. '70'1 c .... -:-J r.," .p f "1 . " ,...to.' ~)o(n U 01 \PF'('Cl...~." ";0 :l.J. 2(i J:.54 (19'(il)). :3C\C~-,.:C)li 4~~3 e)F t,:te ZC)~-.~Ll.e; (jr(linarlCf~ ()f tllc ?C~':~l of ~app~_11~er must be read 1 rl :L t~) () tl jc, '_lp e't :l ... r ~.' U give effect to ',:' ~12 . 4 :~ L:: ':~) d 1 V' i ~'_~ ~~ C1:1 JI..< : J'J t; () ~-. " ~ : ~ ~l ~J Co :.ll-I t (1 i-' ~..',~ e ;~; l' ~ .. t h (1 11 e S .P ,:.j r-.. den t ' ~~ ~. :-.. : ~~,: J'~) l~ ':~ t. '=1.. t :t en. 0 f t }."1 (~ 1;~(~ t1r~ .:.1"1.0', ~.).rl':i 1 r. l~ !.~~ (' r, .(" U.l. t r! ~i, 3 see t J 0 Yl . l~l ti-.at '1 ( , ~..~. ~_1 (i .:, (1 r ~ -c :l e :') ~ 0 :~ . .. ~ ' J.. rl ci -1_' C ~l:~ (; :) t: ,~l '~-, (; 11 pC L');;i}, t.~;:.; d c C:-.~~l~e 1" C 1 a 1 1.':'3(;3 ": : ~ '_' l'~ (~ ~ l"tl ,.1 ~.~, 11 ~i.ll ','; '1 ~'l ,- (.,.:1 . tl ~ t 1..1 i ~ '. -~ !.' (. j 'l '.)'t'~j 0: 1;01 "; ;~~ <.~ L "V -:_ (: (~:,-; ;:. thereby exclLdinr ,~. :~ -: -c 1 Cl r~ .,,1., .., ~~)~.) () }'l C l:" l:': (..~ t. ~ :~; t.:} .J_ ~ .I.: I~"''',; ....~, l. ~. '." .~ ,'''' 1.... li ~.. 1 ~ ~ :.,' ~ ~ .~.) j~'~.' ~;,;1 t . (': 1., ,-,: I C V). :.~ :./ ~)r,l(~'lc:::~n t fJ(' :.',(:::.' l.:,,r . '- -..... I ~.~, .I.., ,,~ J. j.: G 1 C:-; lJI t " . l ;"~ P 1 J. (' " ~ t ,l ~- \ 1:1, 1 \. : 'I '. '" .j tJ (; C _;... Ll.L U;,JC: pcr'r:;],;~. r~IIl(:~ J-._:.;ll(~ Jr1 t}:J~~~ C~l:,~(~ -' rl()~':C\"...~.':., }.~') \':~e~~11~:';i" tll(~ r~'~~'.':r)on{'lf'nt :::~';.~l)O~,:,;~.,~Ly (:,~ll11c(1 IJet::.t::.(}j.,,~l"~: ~~.:j;)l1.c~lti.~-:,r_ for a u.se val....io.:".cc bc[~-;('d .......{'.I", \.-4.i \.11i ~~ ~ .~ '.') t~ t ~ '~.-. -j ""l-t', '-. , :t'I"~' (: () r" c1 ~ I": pt", .1. ~'i . ,;1"" .} J. ..it... '- ' 1.-' I' ~ {.1 1:,'\ ;~'.. (1 ~. ~'"l L.': . e ~~~ ~'., e .:' l~ t";-t loIL:~ "r.a ..c.....') 1r. . ~ l.'! 1. ~~ 1 !.c: -: ;~ ;; 1 i.-l n C I? o f l~.~ j~' "~l:,l5 :lr.ce~: r)~;,.j t: d. ~~r,I;J~~ 1.4. ~ 1 i, l ~.~ ,". I : . .' i 1 . \: "" .', l) (.cf' f: : j "l ;'l t 4l~ (! r-o r ..~ \ /j. Otto v. ~tflj.rdl:t ll-el-- _11- 22,2 .." '\, J.'~ . i . r,. ..... iJ.. ~:1~;2~~1)) Xld .',,~ ''': 1:. (;~. 0.:.' .~'~.~l' ~: ',_-~ ~'~...-)~: [:~; c~; v. i=taynol'> 22 ~: " y" ? cl i; 1 7 (j ~; :-: ,:; ) . .~.r~ t:">-.' 'Iv~~'C CC1.=~<:, __:~',-. '~()-'l:-,t 0."[' P1.p;')>-::;al~ St-~-:: '" do'..:;; a r:Lg~ tcs ~.:.: ,~. . ,": r, .~, oJ .. i ..L. \.... , 1 ,,_~, . ~. .J._ i. l...A.':'~ v ~'e .._ ~ ";:",.L. :...L v ~ -~ '..... '-' t".; .....- ~,~~:.... ::y 1:, .:'"'" e cran-cin;:; of a i_l.._~ t=: \i ;lr ~L an c ,-!' . /.: 11'1 t~: (~\) :, ~ r t ,.t... .1 >..J ;~, :..... '.' "_.. :" \J ~ ~.:'J '..: :.: : fl ~:-:)'0 f' (j II.,; . . C il(~ '::i ':'~:") C.1 :~.,'.l~/ L':-:. ~._,~~ l;S d:scretlon a LJ '..i i~ ~-) ;~~ rl :~: a "f/ Lt.r~:.. ('::. "'~ C (: l t ;,,_ () -(~ ~.. ~ . -.,......... ;~~rl~; '.:. ~-.. c1 (J.f :..~ D- !-l,.:..~t~.\.;~j~l~.'Y }~;-I..~~'\l.~liI:), t:....~_# llt''.;(,~/.~~ :!l'~~~~~ ~~;lCj':; tIlclt (J_) t,~-l'-:': L~LtlG -11 C::"~c:.,~t1c~~ C~~~F'~i'~'):~ :,~lel::-l n :r.'e(l:)OY"l- ab l~:: l~(:}~~, ~tI':1 ':.C 1J:;c'(i (){1J.'/ .fer' 2. 'pl1r;:,i:,..=).cJ a="l()~.',.c~cl Ln t :l,~l'=~ Z 0 j-t c: .~ . (')' \ .-- J t~: ,".r:. L ~.:. ~.: ,.,' ~; ~:" ~ ;-'~r-. ~~ (jf t~~~?' o\';ner _~ :.., (jdt.~ tc) t:ll :'::.tlU"' (~].l"C~L:i:.'t-;__:.\." . r~~'~i.d r~c)t: t'J the 1':~'\rl\'i':.t.1 ('i,.}!l<l.~ t~i.UI:'~' "ill ~,,:..~ ~-." '. " .. ...t. .: .:' ;:~, ~." :. i C'C:<~ \.;: il en rfl~lY ~(:fJect t }le 1Jri"1""(: (1~) C~'"..[i.L: ~,~;-:: ,) .." c:.... t:~e zoning Ol)C~~'1:j,r~2e l~.'~~~eJ_f"; Ll,~~ci (3) ~,::~~~'...~ t:-:(}, ~.J(~: to be .:.l u t~: r~ () :t I ~~_ :_', (; (-1 1) ~/ ~..... ! 1 t..,' '/ LL ~c ~L ~;,. (~ ~ ,__: ;,.-.:,-:; El.l tel.' the E.}~) ~~ (~l'l t :.1. Ct 1 C 1"1 (11' ("1 C t (; .r' 0 ~~. t ~'~ (: =- c ;~'.-_1~. t~ :l . It SU~)::.;cquent to U,r; ~)t.~:(i C::;,:",C; > (),::c~r.' CO'J.rtr3 in thts state have modified and te:ffipered the: requirc:~ents depending on the facts ::.. i'l (<tell ca.:..;C? . Clcal"1y, t}~l" t (;~'.I-' (1:' '\.: . \ (' .;--. ,. ,'- :.' \,.",-",1 c: ':: c L,; ion 11 'J. S been tC~:~f)e:i.""ed by t:..C Cour't () :C , " J ~ :') ;.~i l,: (.~ ~, : . " ' ""'."-1.. ,", '::- .~).. t..7 ~:.~: rl e E:) t ~l t C ~~ v. :\ ~lY :-~ ():' .) s l.~pr'~3.. J udt~e r:e Cl t i r"t {-~: , -,.0,..4.--.! ",' " 1. .-L. t." .J- . ~ :~O~, t:':e Court, indicated l:.:J.;1~_~ .~\'l"jil(~ (jr1(~ (10C~; t1()t :;"It~~'~l:':_:;:"'tt': \rc>:.;:~.c.'.".. ~')~~;~zlt3 lr~l l'cli6.rl~e on "a .' ", .. }-.I..I S U.L.3 e(l 1.1 t~~ {i '~_:.1:/ 'l :.1 J.. ~i. (i ,:.\. -l."' , , i. .' f' !-"~G 0.. :' ,::: ~,:-;. ':'ce~. t should 'ue ;3uf- :'.~C-Li.;tlt to (:'ic,::.:~1 \\Jj,~::l "'v~~'_~';:';-.,'c,i;_~.c.~~'r rj1i"1 .:,~ CO II I' t, ci c:" J\..I (~ r1 r:i ~ ~"l (:: (1 : ."-..: . "Clrit:: t:loe~,~ l'1(.:t aC\i~..l:~l--'t.) 'l(~~j~(:".. ';11 )'"'t~.:, ".t}'jC:i'e one l'ilLld~~ :in l'("i'L(iiC,' or: ;lll :n"/.1id pe:'~"lt (rviattcr ()l' 13 (< C~ C()~l~~t. C;\)}i1'l. v. ~.~ r_'~'-.,.: of j\~)t)eals of \/11. 0 r j~ 1:::1 ~",. ~1 V 11 ]. t~} :; ~J 9 : ,; . ~~.. ? ..~, ~~' ; .' ~ 8. r. C l.l~; v. \Til1at:l' ()f ;'''I'~4!;l:1-I'C':'!\':c:-~) :"P3 ::...~. 3:-?5)'. ~'~Llt ~~t. :t~.~ bi:""'," -:;,:'1 i,'"~:~ cx,i .":'.)~ ... ~"~) ('J:" ~I..-,.:(l hit1J[itj'or1 tC;'.8;1,:..' , . , L ...~ 'J, .1 L..1 ' . ;"1- '.J ~"'..~' cr.;'.:::'"'. c: .... .... "~ ',' - \.,.., ',.f......; ...._ :r(~d on 0,;' :)} :~. \.',:'~ .."~ ~ :. v:' . . . L l~. .~,'i C. c; c Y,'; ~ .r.'~ '2"-' t. :-1 e ~> l"\.) r)C l-,t ~l ()~h:1C<." ~1~1~; ~iCi_,~...\ .:.:1 C~C(j(j f'(tl~~,:". (:....1.-:. t{1t~:r't.~ )[,; 110 rlea~;c 'L(11)le l)a..;)~;~.' to C}:(11~C"-: r"~-:.::1 ~.;it:-.i C011~Jtl~uctive "")~~"'"'' C.Jl)~~ci ;-1 'J ~_, L (._~ t.' . t; ..t.~ ... , ' l ',' . ~ .,,,-, . ..!.......... . '-' '.; '...,' ,-) :1 '. " ':t..' !L:~L;~" .~~, ~'j ~~) n. ~. ~ ~L l~ l: ~" ',=> ~; L: ,.'~ C . f:' ....t..; .t . .~ ,', L..: ': .. .:..... 1: 0 J ::'. ~> 'i.: (~) II .) Ii ~ .. ' . , , , ~ .',\. . i. _:i~ i'-..l i'~ '--", ~ ~ L. ," : -,,":,' ,f , I \' ."; ~') J : 1 l...): ~ .i) '~:.l' ;-~ ~J ~" f' ell' :'1 .L r. ~ t~ 0 ::) e (; C~ c ~~ t ,) - 'J E. ~L ::) :: ,:; <:'1 -C~ ex.:L3t~~r~.~ Pl:', ~ ' ," .:. ...; It'':l ;1 L. -.~ ,-, "'- u- ~ .. ',_~ '... t.t-r........ .' .. -;... '.' .. (; :'::L .:: -- ZCtl:~.~-,;r ~l _\.. \-' ~.I '0 C~ "-,' '-.<. ~) ~~ ~~.._ c ~:" ',~ 1: ..~ ~: (I 1. :: -i I-I 1 .: /.'~ .. { -. -, ~, v I ;,"1 \' :~~ i 1 ~ II 1 ;:,',-~ 11 } ~o: fr:a~l 11u'(';; '1 ~ .' '-..... ., " ; :;- ~ '. r' ~ " )\ I,\.!-, :],1"'U S 1.1';)(;:::.:"> .:,~:- '-~:' :~. z() n ::-.1:!~ v. '1" ' ~. . 1', ,~~;. .;..: ~L ~..! : ~ >'la t -c e l"l lIe J.-'~:;:i fl ;:..U:[ \.,; " (1i..__31:'l ~~ ,~..;. i"i C l..~. .. ',-" .... '\f(. r. -'-"0-->;_ ,f.. :~. I. ,11' V l C '.~' ~ ~ c c. . . 1..-' . ~ :::-. ("~ j~ y _l !1 i ;.~ ~; ~cA_ i rl C~ , ('1 " .'j' :-:l,': ":'_~, l o~. >~ ~l. d ,.."t:::~: ~; ;.^/!1f2 rl'~ '_~,:. ~~; .t ~.. ~.i t, o -:.......~-:")_. "\l>:'; ~,~ Y"~) (: U i.l-;.. ~,. j~: rr -',. (~~-l~~ ~'l'C'd -, r'l~"::-),-:'--);-~ lJ to C' =.: J'j t:; 1-~ c;_ .~~ \~) '.~ ':.... .:'.; rl ~'" ;_, I. ,^.~ c 0 :1 t 1. n ~: ,~} .f :1 r (,~ r't' -,: :, j "Ll ~~ c l' I l .~ . ~ . C) ~ ~j : , ~ l! OJ I " '.', :: ()L~~ }'(; a:j 'x~ 1./ eLl, :-: .' ! "''''~ ~ i (j L . :'.' ~-,; .,.. <~... ",': t~'I', ~ {__, "I'.-:."}" tki'" : ) 1: :" ], : 1 :L r 1 :-.'" ': 1 , ,-' L':':' \ ]. :"Ll'~ cr ~J!::: ~ c; :--~ ~~I ::':L r~ c t~, ~~t ~. yc ~_-~. C :~1, . ;_~ i, " L~(: . .~,') t) '.' ,.,; :,[ . .' I.._;_-:-J ~..lc: t..c... r' :;'.' (; O"T../ :~: .(7 :~i .[> () T: f.~:' --;,-, ~.. ~./ .;:....- .......) ... ......'.... 2. .-.: . (:~ t-:: l'~ ~', "1 ("I. ":" J. C~ ~'-4 (~ ~~- ~ . i ".. ~ . ~J ~ ~ I,: _';: ' ., . ~. 1...: :~l...l '-.:: '1- t.~ }: =- ~-.; "C ~. -:-. - '1 i~' .1 i~ ,-A.. }-" (\.1._ J,. .'.' 'J CJ J.:-, E- :: ~~ ': 0 t :-:e l.~ ~~ ,~: '.. , ~. ..;... _,_ J.. ~l...', <': 3. , elf'.. ,~~ t~r'~ c :..'.' . .... .., "'-::l. J, ~ .. ... . ::.:. rL lr~Il ~.: '.::~ . .) ',-: ) i :1. (:<.1 ;"~ C" 0 ~.'. i r~:L:L t ~1 ,~ "~'i 1~;r:: t~ (.\ ~)l'obl(;~:~.. ~ ,~ '.: ()'I' d ( . :' \ J :' ; 0 1"1 ;.~, " -) ') tiy ~) '1 (:, .^~, .. t :; :) ;.[ '.J ~:' t c ';: . ') ~.: 'I L ,-, ;"'('] -, (",. 'j I, I' i r . t ) [) crr' ~',~ ~.l t t (. ~p 0 f 4.-- .( -, '~.... __ ",-' .. J ,- ......., -- .. ;-.', ~j- -' --:. ~~. ;-1 c~ e:-:- '..----,_.._ ~ L.L... ,~)._; ......... '.,....J, c.. -.' , ....... '1 ~ 0 r.l. .;.. :-~ C .) ::_;,~cor:- i.- ':; 8;-10:;.1(1 e. I .... " ,'. ;-:r c':'" vi.... r) :--: """ ~.,~-~ t. i .' '.1'_, (if C~..'_..::~~.riO:: v. (' ". '.. r '- ---'- ----'- :.- o..l~) 3D.l. :.~," (~C),; I.i~l.~~,t;~:~) of . ~ . y . ;:.: .. ~ , C 3?; :) :.:. L" .,; .:: (~ :;('[jer:nC'l'[,Orn, 2''1 l....J' :'.-,~ 572)." ~, (..' \'".-:,.-, ". ..J , JlC] ~~tat~E y .....i. r, " \ / ~ i c_~ _4 t!. -:.. ...' (' D ,l.i. 0.:-0 t r~') () :,;. f} ... ~ ~ ~'. c' rl]~\ r) <~ t ,~~l-L, :;.. 0:1 0 :~ ~', ,':' 1'-' n: :~. T, :j riL.r'; .L_'_ I.:, : ;;:.."n,(;. '::.\ 1 ~ t.' (_: ;; ~ ' ';.: f ,\ r'~ ;:~, ~ " of :l! ','.1,,,,- 1_ J '~\lok:-~'il , ; tL't ('li'Cl .." l.~ ~,-', C:i t~ "v (;:. ..... ~~ l:' Q ~.. .-. 1,,,-) COI'~i~) ..1.', \,;'1 t }-1 , l. y, ..l'.",," . :-( , il n :-:: ():r'(; ~'~~'ln.C(~. ~.'.- . ~ _ ., .L (l (1 C. t.,) r '-':'i ,,~ r'L~ l ~) I;;' r -. \"~,"l~ ~.~L ~.'. ~" i 1 .' " ...'} -~ . ~ 1 II J. '-...4.' ~ ' ;' \ , ..' '-'-,)..-'-.6- (-:' .' ,. ~ 1 '--' ':'::,'.lc1.-::: <:.cLf~~erl ) l)y an'l} ::0 (~ ~ ~i ~~ 0 r'(: .~"- ..'.-......,- Cl ...., i~ ,... ......J. oJ...: ';,c::: ~ - ',.,U .; ..,-' ..../,.. Cijer~- t: t P:~ j'l-i (;ii. 1\:'\. e;' ",.,2 r)E'~~iti~-~-1er;., . '- . . _.Cl;i b:1 "'r""". -,. . A ,:,"'.... ".' ...... t ~ C) a=".nG :-. f-'~ 1 r u .... ,....~. ~.. '-..1 V a s c in t: .l. } 1 a 0 f '.-.. t}..(, 'J... p,:!_':'t, ( .... ..' 1 )'i, . ~ . ~..(~~. (i.l~(} -,' '."i ~l..,., d. l~,)e \~c.:..;:"iLil1ce. ~' L'! _' . d '~. : . ~~ ~ t ~ V .~. ~ t I_;~ ~ -. y~ ~.: : i ,_; " :: ~ f) .~_ ...;. l, t ',.4 11()r , < {:...___ lor' " ::'''1 ~~'~ C <} ~ " '-, . . ~ '.4. ,~ I...: :,~ ~', ~ I :; ....,... <\/=~~:l"~ UUo..) t..J Ii," ,~~ .. ' ~ ~ I 1 ' .: ~, () :"} ,0~-;.. .. \.~ ,-;. :1 ,~.l'~-' \.~ ~ ',' :;, -^~... c c~.. . Irl :~""~l-,~r..~-/ 1')',.:~; l)C C ~~':) t~. G :~.~. r'1:' 3 ""c~, a oiC i ";/ e 0 :~ r i c ~~ CJ. ~ ~.; :.~\ r:; :.~ :... t .-.... O~l e l-'~) ,_, il i,.) t :/1) e 0 ,:~'t .f d tl ',-, ~y::~ .~ .' \..~I ~,' ~.: () v. t~' ~ .) .... ~':"") [1 .... ...~ .L ~ ! /~CC;):!.'d':.~li~'! ,Y ~~ () t: ~ ': e ;~ ("l. C :; ,:. b e i,' 0 r. e ~ ~ J " .t 1, _L L.> "C l ('j :':(:.::") D l": ci \rt~ :I~t..: t L:.L.. C 1 'C '~.. _1.. :lf~? ::.. " . . . ue Cl~') i 0:1 ".\ra~ not S L~ 1) I) () l' ",:, c' (1 ". ,,; " '-- .~, 1") 1 '.~: ~~~:J l.~ ,'; u C~ "'1' -i. .I..,l..) '-' l~;iO c...~ ;. \..::;, e =~3~Ci,tE:~.~ "- - - :-~:() ,:<..1 .J:'l,......." .1_'" ...( .:. 1...'... ::,: c y' .~~ ~ : ~ ~ ()~"':;:1~) . . rlel")C}l~'i. . j\ C C () l."J (i J ! 1/: ], Y :1 ., ,-L v \..~' ~ e :.';~ ~-l t t' i ,') ~ : :.._ ;~l 0[' t,rie <:' ~ - .. -.:~':)..... '- ~ (1 C' :'-1 y ~i 11,; :: ~t. l~ ~> e ", "1 L~. .. ~-' / l.~' 'u ,..) ~~ t: ~A . 1 t .~ >1. ~~ . , L'\t 1 U ,~'. I J C t,~~ . :.L; i(~ ....llle ;~l:-~~--,ter~ l,~~; :Je::...~.::-"": l,..;..:'" j -\,-',' ,.... .... \.../.\.... ~'c;..) ~)f ., . 1"3.. I) pOi. ~'1 f':t.:~ ~-I :. e ..c;::....~ ~l ~~ d ~'J , ". c:c:.~d~ t~LOli~'; ::L c.t ~:) '-...~.li:i../,. ~..~ ,3 l ~ 1 (: ; ~:1 !,J '.::.~ t}: p ., ~.,.' +. I.._'\---t 01'\:1.," ,) '"", ,- ."', -'--..". _ '..J " "', C ~_~\;~1~.. tile .LF~':: j';", ,. J...1........ lJ .:.. ~'2 ;__~ e t f-:~-' (' f" ,,) ,. ;j C~ . :'~, ~ ~ 1. " ~.1 l'~ ~~: :'qt,)~} I:: C~ t. 1_. : 1 ("},-. ... 1 .j. 1,: j . :.. ()..-: ;:1 (~ r.l r~: 3.. {) {.1 } ~ C~) ~l :' ~~ Co 1_' (~ :.:/ ,,-., of :,':aL"::Jil1f~C':r- th1'0Ugil i t~) -'.~_:"l~~t.. _.~~...:.-)"c.;~l:-:<)~_-:- \^l111cIl (~;'-tu;:;ed t!l(~ '1 ~. f! ... "-.'. 1._, ,',J.. l ~.. (~\' .j i', ' , -,:~:~()~... - r,:-.. v.. '_ " ., C' '_:' ::: o:,~; e:':p ~3. t eel by tLe Co i;;:'\: .../ ..' (][.-,r') _.:' -) ~ . '7, '1 .... ;~l:; (\ 1:.t:/I of ti1'1:, ;:~tat;-' ~./ >~ c cpiLion tile pc'" that ~"4::::~C:C~) 2nc. t})rit tI--'iC re[)rIC'l~d'e~, ~"'>2 (: , arbitrary" and J., ,3 ",-,..(. J'._~ ~~t I. (.; I' d f: t p rlni.11 (~:J tr"!c: r, ...-. ~~i .1 .j. c (1 , I 1{l. ~j been rilet ,~ .. .JJ', ._.:.1.';' (.! :--. t: llC 1~ :: i [) Court thnt .~. '-, of of t ~ ~ ri'o '~}J n .t..' e . .;t_:~ ~:ior1ers is net S11r'1:orted '-- ~l : . {. t~ :.. i. (} i,~ . L0~:~C Do~rd of Appeals of ." \',. "ia.nce ~.i 1 \ '9 r'. ..{.;\.. upon :.' :.:cl1 \,.: ,~:::c ~:~s ',~ 1)r'C;[)rl<1 t f,~ ar!cl [l~; are 1:;......:_. :~ ;-\ r.~' =: ~~) t: 1 -~ ~: 2lt' :/ I, ' "-r'~ 11 1~) '{ 7 ~-\ / /:f --~\ I. \.~" ~;;)./Jf / \ f / ,. -- cr..J-.r s... //, .., '/ ,,---r V" - -" " / J /'" ...-/- I ---..---.-.-- -~_. .----.-.-.-.-- .~~- ......--- ._-----.;.....-~,-_._-....__.~-_.._--- ,J. :::;. c. ..I,.JU':, ......Jl..~ "4. /'t :.!i,~.<I\.--~~.., :.~.;.)t~. 1\ ~.i t~, ,j ~-". t..' "l'r' ~.-::-.'")~~ -l '::.~LU:~~,-:l").,-; 21 ~--" u" ...... ,-' ..\ "!,/ t;.l ;ll~ '.; ?O\~~,:-L~^:..?,,~:~.3:e, ~',"C'.'.~ YO:")~{ 126~=j3 \.', , ~ T \ r".'l ' in .~; _, ';~~~l. t( ;.~ ;'\.1' :.l 1 11,'. '/ i-': ;\') 1..: ;-~ ~~ :'~; .~ (l '~. ~ ~ J ) : / ,: ;"1 .' V) ",I.l .1 ~ ',_: .. ) 0 rlJ C ~-~ .~.; ~" .- L.~. '..J ~ '" . .:. :-J ]':. :3 t~ .L"I '.~' \ ' t ".., :..' '-~ .. 1 . ~.; ,"' .).L. ~ '" I:'.' .~~: "'{ c)'~ "I ~': 1 :~~ (~; .J .1, , \..... - ~~-- " -:..\,..... -.. ", ~ ,....,... , :' .~. -. ." r... '.'') ~,:. ~ ',.... ~. .;:;. . ,_.,,:.n) ...'....." - ; \/.< \: ',-.~ ~ .. ;,j i ~ i ' ..~ ".' "', ' 1." .. ;',,) :-.! '. ... ,'~ '- L' ..J () i 1 f' ::_ c ~~ ;:::\. '.~ :.; , , ~ . t.: 1 . :-/ :"'; .'~ <- .,- l..t..l " , . ,~" I.. ; LJ.i :,'je: C),i',";, .:._' L,. l.l. . '.....! .~.~ l~ :, {'1 (j ":, ~~ '- ~ l-} r)~) 1.... 0,., c: ;.: """1.. ;'.;' \j....),_.. _. J..";_ .. .......... '-..-.. -:.-' =- -..:: ~A..- t...1 : . '~_' : J ;-.~ }:e ~",...L .. r, .. ,-,;j ....., \... \.A... ~ t. ~ \- l..' n .,' , ) " .J \..' l~' " .....1....; ,L , J i ,'V,l' J; C '.~ j:-; ~:l ~~~ t. t: ~~ (,::-' ";/.:1 ;') : -, "'1 (: 4,') ~I. C. l:,,: l' I:) ". n lr:' '.'~ . " '- - '..... ".' -, -,-, \...-.. -'- . ". , , .. , ~'.. C:~' .. ~-:~-~.::. =: t.=: _~ - I: '- ) "';'-0 " l ~. ;\ ,,' ... , , (;,_. ... a " ,....... . .' .- '. .. ..... ~ .....-. ;. .. '.' ....~. ',; '--' . ' . " ~: - \.... (... '0 ,. ::""0".,,- ., .f... t..l>,: (~ >, i~ ~ , '.. ) ;J (' . , '\' ":;_r;.~l "'~"'-, ~1 ;~"'-'C ~.',. ;'.: r~[ i~ ,~~ y- t J1:.'\)U ~~ t ~5 '-'-" C;'" US (' I) ~- 1, 10), 'v, I ,(: :-1 h '( ,,' ..} 1. roC: ee) i~':,'t :.....,',i C' ,~; l:; D. t ,', 4.' _~ \dl; I t 'h <~1 t t ~.~ C: t) c' ,(_~:o .. " ,. "c l'ic: roe ~~, j" ollc1.e,.' 8;':JJ. trar:r all (] <._'1L. '. v. , jet e rrni ;-lj,~:~, t~ ~..! e ',) 'y- r; ;') ee ri ~nt~.l t :j Jr ~_\l.'t Lil'I,L tr'lC , , r..\) '",':: 0 [' ~ .!- l~.l r-10 t 'l;r-~ ()rl~_:c(l "- " ':.::'.,';1 (', {' JJ. () ~.~ 1\ P I) (; ::i] ~j anc\~ UJ':Clll ~;,: 'il '-, .... ~'.. :'i~ (1 t ,~~ (;J. L. (1 r, ~: (t. ~.'" (~