Loading...
1995 @ New York Telephone A NVNEX Company 1095 Avenue of the Americas New York, New York 10036 May 31, 1995 TOWN CLERK: Re: New York Telephone Tentative Special Franchise Assessment for 711 Towns and 43 Cities - Certificate Dated: April 24, 1995 Enclosed is a copy of a Complaint for the Tentative Special Franchise Assessment for the 1995 Tax Roll, filed with the Office of Real Property Services, dated May 25, 1995. This Petition was filed with State Board on May 26, 1995. The hearing on this matter is scheduled for June 6, 1995. If you have any questions, please call me collect at (212) 395-6121. Very truly yours, , Y-LJ\1l- \, Enclosure ~~ . 1 .. 1 STATE OF NEW YORK STATE BOARD OF REAL PROPERTY SERVICES i ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~i< ts1 .. ------------------------------------------x IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPLAINT UNDER SECTION 610 OF THE REAL PROPERTY TAX LAW OF NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY. ------------------------------------------x TENTATIVE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS ISSUED April 24, 1995 FOR 1995 TOWNS AND CITIES HEARING DATE: June 6, 1995 RECEIVED JUN 05 1995 CULLEN AND DYKMAN Attorneys for Complainant NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY Office and P.O. Address 177 Montague Street Brooklyn, New York 11201 (718) 855-9000 ELAINf ANOWDEN IOWN CLERK STATE OF NEW YORK STATE BOARD OF REAL PROPERTY SERVICES ------------------------------------------x NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY. TENTATIVE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS ISSUED April 24, 1995 (711 Towns and 43 cities - 1995 Roll) COMPLAINT IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPLAINT UNDER SECTION 610 OF THE REAL PROPERTY TAX LAW OF ------------------------------------------x TO: THE STATE BOARD OF REAL PROPERTY SERVICES: NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY, a domestic corporation, having its principal office at 1095 Avenue of the Americas, New York, New York 10036, having received written notice" of the action dated April 24, 1995 of the State Board of Real Property Services" ("State Board") in making tentative assessments of its special franchise property in the several municipalities, assessing units and taxing districts as set forth in Appendix A attached hereto, and New York Telephone Company ("Complainant"), being aggrieved thereby, complains of and objects to these determinations as being unlawful, excessive and unequal and alleges upon information and belief as follows: 1. The State Board's tentative assessments set forth in the amounts indicated in the column "Tentative Assessment" of Appendix A, are excessive and erroneous by reason of overvaluation, illegality and inequality. The assessments are discriminatory in that they are made at a higher rate than other similarly situated · Although the notice of tentative assessments is addressed to NYNEX - New York, the owner of the property continues to be New York Telephone Company and therefore this complaint is made in the name of New York Telephone Company .. This agency was formerly known as State Board of Equalization and Assessment .. special franchise propertYi and they are, in certain instances, misclassified. 2. The full value of Complainant's special franchise property on the tax status date in each of the respective municipalities, assessing units and taxing districts was not in excess of the amount shown in the column "Claimed Full Value" of Appendix Ai and Complainant submits that the tentative valuations should be reduced to no more than these amounts. 3. Complainant is aggrieved, is and will be injured by the state Board's determination of the tentative valuations in that Complainant will be required to pay a far greater amount of taxes based upon the equalized assessments derived therefrom than it would be compelled to pay had these determinations been made justly and properly, and far more than its just proportion of the aggregate taxes to be levied upon real property, including special franchise property situated in the respective municipalities, assessing units and taxing districts for the fiscal year in which the taxes are based upon the assessments. 4. The state Board has incorrectly and inaccurately employed in connection therewith, its method or rule of valuation. The state Board's use of Complainant's regulatory gross investment for developing a reproduction cost is inappropriate as it results in overvaluation. The state Board has sought to value bookkeeping entries rather than property, and in so doing it has valued costs which are unrelated to special franchise or real property. 5. The state Board's application of the reproduction cost - 2 - methodology in valuing Complainant's special franchise property is incorrect in numerous respects. The state Board fails to apply adequate depreciation including physical depreciation and economic and functional obsolescence to Complainant's property. The physical depreciation applied to Complainant's property is inadequate because the state Board employs service lives and salvage percentages in valuing Complainant's property which are inaccurate and not in accord with those currently recognized by the FCC and PSC. Further, due to the time gap between the last survey valuation date and the annual assessment date of special franchise property, and the state Board's position in assessing property added by Complainant subsequent to the last survey valuation date, recent property additions have been assessed without making any depreciation adjustment. 6. The state Board also fails to account for the considerable economic obsolescence resulting from the heavy regulation on the Complainant, including the limitations placed upon Complainant's earnings by the Public Service commission and the highly competitive communications arena in which Complainant operates. In response to a proposed rulemaking concerning economic obsolescence, Complainant submitted materials on December 30, 1987, objecting to the State Board's Rules and reasserts those arguments here because the Rules fail to allow a special franchise owner to demonstrate the existence and impact of economic obsolescence on its property in contravention of judicial precedent and established appraisal practice. - 3 - 7. The state Board also fails to reflect in its application of the reproduction cost method appropriate amounts for the technological or functional obsolescence of much of Complainant's equipment still in service. Much of Complainant's physical plant which is assessed by the state Board is no longer used or usable and the state Board should recognize this by employing a suitable functional obsolescence factor in assessing Complainant's property. On November 10, 1993, representatives of Complainant met with senior state Board Staff and submitted a detailed written application for functional obsolescence which application complied with the State Board's rules. The application provided extensive evidence of the functional obsolescence of Complainant's special franchise property including information as to present and projected needs, present and anticipated demand and present and anticipated capacity. The application also contained a suggestion of the manner by which the allowance should be calculated. At this November 10, 1993 meeting, Complainant's representatives explained the functional obsolescence application in great detail and requested that a functional obsolescence factor be applied by the State Board in assessing Complainant's special franchise property. Since the initial November 1993 meeting, Complainant's representatives have met numerous times and corresponded continuously with the State Board staff to explain and support the application and, as part of this effort, have provided state Board staff with the voluminous underlying documentation which forms the basis for the application. To date, however, the State Board has - 4 - failed to apply functional obsolescence in valuing complainant's property. 8. The Rules fail to consider the use of a "replacement cost" or "unit cost" valuation of Complainant's property. 9. In each municipality, assessing unit and taxing district, the assessment rolls upon which the assessments are directed to be entered pursuant to RPTL ~616 are unlawful, null and void in that all property is not assessed by class at uniform percentages of full value as required by the RPTL. 10. The state Board annually determines the assessment of all special franchise property subject to assessment, valued as of the "rate valuation date". For the assessments in 1995, the particular calendar day and month of the year which is the rate valuation date is not set forth in the statute, nor is the date determinable with any degree of certainty under the provisions of the statute. Complainant believes the state Board is using the incorrect rate valuation date. 11. The state Board's application of the reproduction cost methodology fails to account for measurable factors which affect the value of Complainant's special franchise property and no adjustment has been made for the piecemeal construction of the existing property or for new construction of Complainant's property which is necessitated by government mandated rehabilitation, relocations or replacements, as well as, by deregulation, the connection of new telecommunications providers, and providing failsafe redundancy in the network. In this regard, the state - 5 - Board has failed to adjust the capi tal costs associated with Complainant's investment in technologically dated plant which was required by the PSC to respond to subscriber complaints, which investment does not increase the capability or capacity of Complainant's system or increase its value. 12. The state Board ignores any accurate reproduction cost information and replacement cost information and instead applies cost trending indices in valuing Complainant's property which results in an overvaluation of Complainant's special franchise property. 13. The state Board, in determining the tentative special franchise assessments of Complainant's special franchise property, erroneously, improperly and illegally adopted and included in the "tangible" element of each valuation an amount for construction work in progress, which included construction costs of tangible property not yet completed nor in use. 14. The assessment of Complainant's special franchise property is erroneous by reason of inequality, in that each of the assessments has been made at a higher proportionate valuation than (i) the assessment of all other special franchise property and (ii) the assessment of all other real property on the same tax roll in each of the assessing units (SBRPS assessments by statute have the same effect as assessments made by local assessors). Specifically, while complainant's property is assessed at more than double its true full value, the average assessment of all other class three property and all other real property in each of the assessing units - 6 - does not exceed the amount of its full value. As examples of inequality, complainant specifies the assessments of i) all other real property and ii) all utility owned real property and iii) all special franchise property in each of the assessing units assessed upon the same assessment roll and each and every parcel thereof. 15. Complainant's special franchise property is being placed on the local assessment rolls at a fraction of the state Board's determination as to the full market value thereof, which fraction differs from those fractions applied to (i) all other property in the same class designation and (ii) all other real property in each of the assessing units, all relating to property on the same tax roll for the same year. The utilization of different fractions of full value of special franchise property is contrary to the requirement of uniformity set forth in RPTL S305, and is prima facie evidence of inequality in the assessments. 16. The state Board has applied the "latest" state equalization rate in fixing the assessments pursuant to RPTL S606. For those assessments where a rate in excess of 100% has been applied, the assessment is void on its face as an assessment at more than the full value of the property in violation of the prohibition in the New York state Constitution. 17. Complainant further claims that the aforesaid determinations fixing the tentative valuations are illegal and void in that they do and will result in confiscation of complainant's property, do and will result in denying to Complainant the equal protection of the laws, do and will deprive the Complainant of its - 7 - property without due process of law, do and will result in taking Complainant's property for public use without rendering just compensation therefor in violation of the laws of the state of New York and of sections 6 and 11 of Article I of the Constitution of the state of New York and in violation of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution of the united states. WHEREFORE, NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY, respectfully demands that: a. The determination of the tentative assessments of Complainant's special franchise property in the several municipalities, assessing units and taxing districts as set forth in Appendix A be annulled, cancelled and withdrawn by the state Board. b. In the alternative, that the full valuation of these properties be reduced to the amounts set forth in the column "Claimed Full Value" of Appendix A, and the tentative assessments be reduced to the amounts set forth in the column "Claimed Assessment" of Appendix A. - 8 - STATEMENT PURSUANT TO RPTL I certify that all statements made on this application are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief and I understand that the making of any willful false statement of material fact herein will subject me to the provisions of the penal law relevant to the making and filing of false instruments. Dated: New York, New York MayZ 6"., 1995 NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY By: (\ ) \~ up Cullen and Dykman Attorneys for Complainant Office and P.O. Address 177 Montague street Brooklyn, New York 11201 (718) 855-9000 - 9 - STATE OF NEW YORK ss. : COUNTY OF NEW YORK ) 1~1uJ&}:L 0- MUfo , being deposes and says: that he/s~~x~ J)(J/SJ$jIT1/Li~JUrLkl7. duly sworn, of NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY, the Complainant herein; that he/she has read the foregoing complaint including Appendix A and knows the contents thereof and that the facts stated therein are true to the best of his/her knowledge, information and belief. \~ ~ \\- b t Sworn to before me this .1- >-i-I) .~~) d~y of May, 1995 'i I U,'::;A r.kKI~,LEY Nollar)' Publi::. S~;:.~a of New York No 01MC::J31875 Qualified In King. CounlJ ( Commission Expires; /' 'd1;;Jf~ - 10 - APPENDIX A NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS Page 1 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:======= = === = = = ======:= = = == === =:= === == == === === == =:= = === = = = =:== = == = ===:===== == ==:=== === ==== COUNTY OF ALBANY 63190- 101002 C OF ALBANY $2,343,499 F 0.0772 $30,356,205 $13,660,292 $16,695,913 $1,054,575 $1,288,924 63190- 103002 C OF COHOES $123,159 F 0.0529 $2,328,147 $1,047,666 $1,280,481 $55,422 $67,737 63190- 11 8002 C OF WA TERVLlET $132,079 F 0.0553 $2,366,409 $1,074,784 $1,313,625 $59,436 $72,643 63190- 120 T OF BERNE $30,458 T 0.0186 $1,637,527 $736,887 $900,640 $13,706 $16,752 63190- 122 T OF BETHLEHEM $6,624,449 F 1.0942 $6,054,148 $2,724,367 $3,329,782 $2,724,367 $3,900,082 63190- 124 T OF COEYMANS $21,780 F 0.0512 $425,391 $191,426 $233,965 $9,801 $11,979 63190 - 126 T OF COLONIE $21,631,511 S 1.0000 $21,631,511 $9,734,180 $11,897,331 $9,734,180 $11,897,331 63190- 128 T OF GREEN ISLAND $49,851 F 0.1076 $463,299 $208,485 $254,815 $22,433 $27,418 63190- 130 T OF GUILDERLAND $7,310,618 F 1.0207 $7,162,357 $3,223,061 $3,939,296 $3,223,061 $4,087,557 63190- 132 T OF KNOX . $22,055 T 0.0230 $958,913 $431,511 $527,402 $9,925 $12,130 63190- 134 T OF NEW SCOTLAND $2,093,448 F 1.6897 $1,921,123 $864,505 $1,056,618 $864,505 $1,228,943 63190- 136 T OF RENSSELAEFWlLLE $25,784 F 0.0204 $1,263,922 $568,765 $695,157 $11,603 $14,181 63190- 138 T OF WESTERLO i $23,119 F 0.0166 $1,392,711 $626,720 $765,991 $10,404 $12,715 COUNTY OF ALLEGANY 63190- 220 T OF ALFRED $112,423 F 1.081 B $103,922 $46,765 $57,157 $46,765 $65,658 63190- 222 T OF ALLEN $2,369 F 0.0608 $38,964 $17,534 $21,430 $1,066 $1,303 63190- 224 T OF ALMA $225,192 F 1 .2238 $184,010 $82,805 $101,206 $82,805 $142,387 63190- 226 T OF ALMOND $113,387 F 0.9367 $121,049 $54,472 $66,577 $51,024 $62,363 63190- 228 T OF AMITY $693,957 F 1.0927 $635,085 $285,788 $349,297 $285,788 $408,169 63190- 230 T OF ANDOVER $29,134 S 1.0000 $29,134 $13,110 $16,024 $13,110 $16.024 63190- 232 T OF ANGELICA $246,850 F 1.1329 $217.892 $98,051 $119,841 $98,051 $148,799 63190- 234 T OF BELFAST $431,327 S 1.0000 $431.327 $194,097 $237,230 $194,097 $237.230 63190- 236 T OF BIRDSALL $60,287 S 1.0000 $60,287 $27,129 $33,158 $27.129 $33,158 63190- 238 T OF BOLIVAR " $529,832 F 0.9052 $585,320 $263,394 $321,926 $238,424 $291,408 63190- 240 T OF BURNS $323,990 F 1.0790 $300,269 $135,121 $165,148 $135,121 $188,869 63190- 242 T OF CANEADEA $185,627 S 1.0000 $185,627 $83,532 $102.095 $83,532 $102,095 63190- .244 T OF CENTERVILLE $411 F 0.0560 $7,339 $3,303 $4,037 $185 $226 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 2 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = = = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = = = 63190- 246 T OF CLARKSVILLE $51,423 F 0.2068 $248,661 $111,897 $136,763 $23,140 $28,283 63190- 248 T OF CUBA $863,572 F 0.9069 $952,224 $428,501 $523,723 $388,607 $474,965 63190- 250 T OF FRIENDSHIP $254,733 F 0.8147 $312,671 $140,702 $171,969 $114,630 $140,103 63190- 252 T OF GENESEE $288,913 S 1.0000 $288,913 $130,011 $158,902 $130,011 $158,902 63190- 256 T OF GROVE $55,329 F 0.9023 $61,320 $27,594 $33,726 $24,898 $30,431 63190- 260 T OF INDEPENDENCE $26,543 F 1 .0417 $25,480 $11,466 $14,014 $11,466 $15,077 63190- 262 T OF NEW HUDSON $112,134 F 1 .1 220 $99,941 $44,974 $54,968 $44,974 $67,160 63190- 264. T OF RUSHFORD $437,869 S 1.0000 $437,869 $197,041 $240,828 $197,041 $240,828 63190- 266 T OF SCIO $496,656 S 1 .0000 $496,656 $223,495 $273,161 $223,495 $273,161 63190- 268 T OF WARD $54,261 S 1 .0000 $54,261 $24,417 $29,844 $24,417 $29,844 63190 - 270 T OF WELLSVILLE $1,956,986 S 1.0000 $1,956,986 $880,644 $1,076,342 $880,644 $1,076,342 63190- 272 T OF WEST ALMOND $62,213 S 1.0000 $62,213 $27,996 $34,217 $27,996 $34,217 63190- 274 'T OF WILLING $247,485 F 0.9624 $257,154 $115,719 $141,435 $111,368 $136,117 63190 - 276 T OF WIRT $30,959 F 0.1207 $256,495 $115,423 $141,072 $13,932 $17,027 COUNTY OF BROOME 63190- 302002 C OF BINGHAMTON $11,314,589 F 1.0159 $11,137,503 $5,011,876 $6,125,626 $5,011,876 $6,302,713 63190 - 320 T OF BARKER $66,654 F 1 .0826 $61,568 $27,706 $33,863 $27,706 $38,948 63190- 322 T OF BINGHAMTON $815,808 F 1.0632 $767,314 $345,291 $422,023 $345,291 $470,517 63190- 324 T OF CHENANGO $1,056,027 F 1 .0202 $1,035,118 $465,803 $569,315 $465,803 $590,224 63190- 326 T OF COLESVILLE $7,727 F 0.1006 $76,809 $34,564 $42,245 $3,477 $4,250 63190- 328 T OF CONKLIN $1,786,948 F 1.0535 $1,696,201 $763,291 $932,911 $763,291 $1,023,657 63190- 330 T OF DICKINSON $1,841,199 F 0.9973 $1,846,184 $830,783 $1,015,401 $828,540 $1,012,659 63190- 332 T OF FENTON $816,900 F 0.9920 $823,488 $370,570 $452,918 $367,605 $449,295 63190- 334 T OF KIRKWOOD $3,500,769 F 1.0578 $3,309,481 $1,489,266 $1,820,215 $1,489,266 $2,011,503 63190- 336 T OF LISLE $1,914 F 1 .1 027 $1 ,736 $781 $955 $781 $1,133 63190- 338 T OF MAINE $1,021,237 F 1.1074 $922,193 $414,987 $507,206 $414,987 $606,250 63190- 340 T OF NANTICOKE $111,386 F 1.0689 $104,206 $46,893 $57,313 $46,893 $64,493 63190- 346 T OF UNION $1,171,997 F 0.0725 $16,165,476 $7,274,464 $8,891,012 $527,399 $644,598 63190- 348 T OF VESTAL $375,122 F 0.0628 $5,973,280 $2,687,976 $3,285,304 $168,805 $206,317 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 3 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment :::::::: = =:==:::: ==== == == = ==:::: == = = =:=:::: = == = = = =:= = == = = == = =:::: == = = = =:= = == == == == == =:= == = == == == == =:= == == == == == == =:= = = == == == = == 63190- 350 T OF WINDSOR $801,326 F 1.0607 $755,469 $339,961 $415,508 $339,961 $461,365 COUNTY OF CATTARAUGUS 63190- 412002 C OF OLEAN $516,587 T 0.1240 $4,166,024 $1,874,711 $2,291,313 $232,464 $284,123 63190- 416002 C OF SALAMANCA $1,662,680 S 1.0000 $1,662,680 $748,206 $914,474 $748,206 $914,474 63190 - 420 T OF ALLEGANY $1,008,703 F 0.5516 $1,828,686 $822,909 $1,005,777 $453,916 $554,787 63190- 422 T OF ASHFORD $120,374 F 0.9239 $130,289 $58,630 $71,659 $54,168 $66,206 63190- 424 T OF CARROLL TON $568,387 F 0.8167 $695,956 $313,180 $382,776 $255,774 $312,613 63190- 426 T OF COLD SPRING $13,257 F 0.7823 $16,946 $7,626 $9,320 $5,966 $7,291 63190 - 428 T OF CONEWANGO $19,818 F 0.8764 $22,613 $10,176 $12,437 $8,918 $10,900 63190- 430 T OF DAYTON $48,742 F 0.0907 $537,398 $241,829 $295,569 $21,934 $26,808 63190- 432 i OF EAST OTTO $98,282 F 0.9256 $106,182 $47,782 $58,400 $44,227 $54,055 63190 - 436 T OF ELLlCOTTVILLE $763,941 F 0.7537 $1,013,588 $456,114 $557,473 $343,773 $420,168 63190- 438 T OF FARMERSVILLE $165,277 S 1.0000 $165,277 $74,375 $90,902 $74,375 $90,902 63190- 440 T OF FRANKLlNVILLE $152,510 F 0.2322 $656,804 $295,562 $361,242 $68,630 $83,881 63190- 442 T OF FREEDOM $51, 158 F 0.0826 $619,346 $278,706 $340,640 $23,021 $28,137 63190- 444 T OF GREAT VALLEY $26,317 F 0.0443 $594,063 $267,328 $326,735 $11,843 $14,474 63190- 446 T OF HINSDALE $76,711 F 0.1438 $533,456 $240,055 $293,401 $34,520 $42,191 63190- 448 T OF HUMPHREY $4,687 F 0.0385 $121,740 $54,783 $66,957 $2,109 $2,578 63190- 450 T OF ISCHUA $41,625 F 0.1649 $252,426 $113,592 $138,834 $18,731 $22,894 63190- 452 T OF LEON $10,512 F 0.0715 $147,021 $66,159 $80,862 $4,730 $5,782 63190- 454 T OF LITTLE VALLEY $653,249 S 1.0000 $653,249 $293,962 $359,287 $293,962 $359,287 63190- 456 T OF LYNDON $17,722 F 0.1017 $174,258 $78,416 $95,842 $7,975 $9,747 63190- 458 T OF MACHIAS $418,379 F 0.8504 $491,979 $221,391 $270,588 $188,271 $230,108 63190- 460 T OF MANSFIELD $346,820 F 0.9146 $379,204 $170,642 $208,562 $156,069 $190,751 63190- 462 T OF NAPOU $162,918 T 0.7816 $208,442 $93,799 $114,643 $73,313 $89,605 63190- 464 T OF NEW ALBION $47,015 F 0.0701 $670,685 $301,808 $368,877 $21,157 $25,858 63190- 466 T OF OLEAN $37,459 F 0.0537 $697,561 $313,902 $383,658 $16,857 $20,602 63190- 468 T OF OTTO $175,805 F 0.8687 $202,377 $91,070 $111,307 $79,112 $96,693 63190- 470 T OF PERRYSBURG $68,872 F 0.0967 $712,223 $320,501 $391,723 $30,992 $37,880 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 4 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = ==== = = == = = = = === = =:= = = == = = = =:= = == = = == = = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = == 63190 - 472 T OF PERSIA $598,489 T 1.0100 $592,563 $266,654 $325,910 $266,654 $331,835 63190 - 474 T OF PORTVILLE $661,843 F 0.9248 $715,661 $322,047 $393,613 $297,829 $364,014 63190- 480 T OF SALAMANCA $89,030 T 0.3958 $224,937 $101,222 $123,715 $40,064 $48,967 63190- 484 T OF YORKSHIRE $213,826 F 0.3375 $633,559 $285,101 $348,457 $96,222 $117,604 COUNTY OF CAYUGA 63190- 520 T OF AURELIUS $92,848 F 0.0800 $1,160,600 $522,270 $638,330 $41,782 $51,066 63190- 522 T OF BRUT US $974,022 F 1 .0041 $970,045 $436,520 $533,525 $436,520 $537,502 63190 - 524 T OF CATO $229,370 S 1.0000 $229,370 $103,217 $126,154 $103,217 $126,154 63190- 528 T OF FLEMING $325,709 T 0.6500 $501,091 $225,491 $275,600 $146,569 $179,140 63190- 530 T OF GENOA . $461 ,279 F 0.9451 $488,074 $219,633 $268,441 $207,576 $253,703 63190- 534 T OF LEDYARD $256,581 T 0.5991 $428,277 $192,725 $235,553 $115,461 $141,120 63190- 536 T OF LOCKE $28,917 F 0.1024 $282,393 $127,077 $155,316 $13,013 $15,904 63190 - 540 T OF MONTEZUMA $3,853 F 0.1759 $21,904 $9,857 $12,047 $1,734 $2,119 63190- 542 T OF MORAVIA $671,788 F 0.9391 $715,353 $321,909 $393,444 $302,305 $369,483 63190- 544 T OF NILES $483,572 F 0.9347 $517,355 $232,810 $284,545 $217,607 $265,965 63190 - 546 T OF OWASCO $663,204 F 0.8836 $750,570 $337,757 $412,814 $298,442 $364,762 63190- 548 T OF SCIPIO $191,889 T 0.5675 $338,130 $152,159 $185,972 $86,350 $105,539 63190- 550 T OF SEMPRONIUS $176,192 F 0.5806 $303,465 $136,559 $166,906 $79,286 $96,906 63190 - 552 T OF SENNETT $1,100,866 S 1.0000 $1,100,866 $495,390 $605,476 $495,390 $605,476 63190- 554 T OF SPRINGPORT $422,270 T 0.7553 $559,076 $251,584 $307,492 $190,022 $232,249 63190- 556 T OF STERLING $44,626 T 0.9149 $48,777 $21,950 $26,827 $20,082 $24,544 63190- 558 T OF SUMMERHILL $14,011 F 0.0533 $262,871 $118,292 $144,579 $6,305 $7,706 63190- 560 T OF THROOP $30,568 F 0.1081 $282,775 $127,249 $155,526 $13,756 $16,812 63190- 562 T OF VENICE $192,223 F 0.6084 $315,948 $142,177 $173,772 $86,500 $105,723 63190- 564 T OF VICTORY $9,557 F 0.0646 $147,941 $66,574 $81,368 $4,301 $5,256 COUNTY OF CHAUTAUQUA 63190- 603002 C OF DUNKIRK $1,874,229 F 0.7377 $2,540,638 $1,143,287 $1,397,351 $843,403 $1,030,826 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 5 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate Assessment SBRPS Full Value Claimed Full Value Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment = = = =:= = == =::: == = =:::::: == = == = = = = = =:= == = == = == = == ==:=::: ==:::::: == ==:::::: ==::: == == = ==::::= == == = == == =::: = ==::: = = =::: == =::::= == == = == = =;:;:::::= = = = = = = == = = 63190- 620 T OF ARKWRIGHT $63,487 F 0.9889 $64,200 $28,890 $35,310 $28,569 $34,918 63190- 630 T OF CHERRY CREEK $233,763 F 0.9299 $251,385 $113,123 $138,262 $105,193 $128,570 63190- 634 T OF DUNKIRK $143,291 F 0.3686 $388,744 $174,935 $213,809 $64,481 $78,810 63190 - 640 T OF ELLINGTON $4,376 F 1.0314 $4,243 $1,909 $2,334 $1,909 $2,467 63190- 646 T OF HANOVER $632,527 F 0.3397 $1,862,016 $837,907 $1,024,109 $284,637 $347,890 63190- 658 T OF POMFRET $14,125 F 0.3510 $40,242 $18.109 $22,133 $6,356 $7,769 63190- 660 T OF PORTLAND $4,404 T 0.9688 $4,546 $2,046 $2,500 $1,982 $2,422 63190- 664 T OF SHERIDAN $271,723 F 0.4246 $639,951 $287,978 $351,973 $122,275 $149,448 63190- 670 T OF VILLENOVA $86,917 F 0.3732 $232,897 $104,803 $128,093 $39,113 $47,804 63190- 672 T OF WESTFIELD $8,587 F 0.8305 $10,340 $4,653 $5,687 $3,864 $4,723 COUNTY OF CHEMUNG 63190- 704002 C OF ELMIRA $7,471,051 S 1.0000 $7,471.051 $3,361,973 $4,109,078 $3,361,973 $4,109,078 63190- 720 T OF ASHLAND $21,094 F 0.0302 $698,477 $314,315 $384,162 $9,492 $11,602 63190- 722 T OF BALDWIN $2,992 F 0.0382 $78,325 $35,246 $43,079 $1,346 $1,646 63190- 724 T OF BIG FLATS $1,475.208 T 0.9650 $1,528,713 $687,921 $840,792 $663,844 $811,364 63190- 726 T OF CATUN $165,719 F 0.4739 $349,692 $157,361 $192,331 $74,574 $91,145 63190- 728 T OF CHEMUNG $951,411 T 0.8572 $1,109,906 $499,457 $610,448 $428,135 $523,276 63190- 730 T OF ELMIRA $1,757,999 F 0.9604 $1,830,486 $823,719 $1,006,767 $791,100 $966,899 63190- 732 T OF ERIN $312,358 F 0.9446 $330,678 $148,805 $181,873 $140,561 $171,797 63190- 734 T OF HORSEHEADS $5,208,350 F 1.0738 $4,850,391 $2,182,676 $2,667,715 $2,182,676 $3,025,674 63190- 736 T OF SOUTHPORT $1,668,642 F 0.8007 $2,083,979 $937,791 $1,146,188 $750,889 $917,753 63190- 738 T OF VAN ETTEN $2,783 F 0.8299 $3,353 $1.509 $1,844 $1,252 $1,531 63190- 740 T OF VETERAN $100,801 F 0.1108 $909,756 $409,390 $500,366 $45,360 $55,441 COUNTY OF CHENANGO 63190- 820 T OF AFTON $61,032 S 1.0000 $61,032 $27,464 $33,568 $27,464 $33,568 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 6 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = = = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = = = COUNlY OF CLINTON 63190- 913002 C OF PLATTSBURGH $3,862,264 F 1.0094 $3,826,297 $1,721,834 $2,104,463 $1,721,834 $2,140,430 63190- 920 T OF AL TON A $519,409 F 0.8420 $616,875 $277,594 $339,281 $233,734 $285,675 63190- 922 T OF AU SABLE $264,013 F 0.9763 $270,422 $121,690 $148,732 $118,806 $145,207 63190- 924 T OF BEEKMANTOWN $1,048,985 F 0.9691 $1,082,432 $487,094 $595,338 $472,043 $576,942 63190- 926 T OF BLACK BROOK $213,619 F 0.6371 $335,299 $150,885 $184,414 $96,129 $117,490 63190- 928 T OF CHAMPLAIN $3,500 F 0.9643 $3,630 $1,633 $1,996 $1,575 $1,925 63190- 930 T OF CHAZY $56,453 F 0.9926 $56,874 $25,593 $31,281 $25,404 $31,049 63190- 932 T OF CLINTON $308,020 F 0.8119 $379,382 $170,722 $208,660 $138,609 $169,411 63190- 934 T OF OANNEMORA . $799,451 F 0.8337 $958,919 $431,514 $527,406 $359,753 $439,698 63190- 936 T OF ELLEN BURGH $847,133 F 0.8539 $992,075 $446,434 $545,641 $381,210 $465,923 63190- 938 T OF MOOERS $249,147 F 0.9784 $254,647 $114,591 $140,056 $112,116 $137,031 63190- 940 T OF PERU $2,452,324 F 1.0612 $2,310,897 $1,039,904 $1,270,993 $1,039,904 $1,412,420 63190- 942 T OF PLA TTSBURGH $3,623,264 F 1.0107 $3,584,906 $1,613,207 $1,971,698 $1,613,207 $2,010,057 63190- 944 T OF SARANAC $1,829,092 T 0.7655 $2,389,408 $1,075,234 $1,314,175 $823,091 $1,006,001 63190- 946 T OF SCHUYLER FALLS $1,010,297 F 0.9768 $1,034,293 $465,432 $568,861 $454,634 $555,663 COUNlY OF COLUMBIA 63190- 1006002 C OF HUDSON $2,734,563 S 1.0000 $2.734,563 $1,230,553 $1,504,010 $1,230,553 $1,504,010 63190- 1022 T OF AUSTERLlTZ $2,220 S 1 . DODO $2,220 $999 $1,221 $999 $1,221 63190- 1028 T OF CLAVERACK $2,485,738 S 1.0000 $2,485,738 $1,118,582 $1,367,156 $1,118,582 $1,367,156 63190- 1034 T OF GALLATIN $143,772 S 1 .0000 $143,772 $64,697 $79,075 $64,697 $79,075 63190- 1038 T OF GHENT $409,268 S 1 .0000 $409,268 $184,171 $225,097 $184,171 $225,097 63190- 1040 T OF GREENPORT $1,580,523 S 1.0000 $1,580,523 $711,235 $869,288 $711,235 $869,288 63190- 1042 T OF HILLSOALE $79,851 T 0.7171 $111,353 $50,109 $61,244 $35,933 $43.918 63190- 1044 T OF KINOERHOOK $32,761 S 1.0000 $32,761 $14,742 $18,019 $14,742 $18,019 63190- 1046 T OF LIVINGSTON $1,057,541 S 1.0000 $1,057,541 $475,893 $581,648 $475,893 $581,648 63190- 1048 T OF NEW LEBANON $231,390 S 1.0000 $231,390 $104,126 $127,265 $104,126 $127,265 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 7 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed OveNaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= == ==== = = == = = = = == = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = == = === = = = === = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = === == = =:== = == = = ==:= ====== === 63190- 1050 T OF STOCKPORT $581,253 S 1.0000 $581,253 $261,564 $319,689 $261,564 $319,689 63190 - 1052 T OF STUYVESANT $101,800 S 1.0000 $101,800 $45,810 $55,990 $45,810 $55,990 63190- 1054 T OF T AGHKANIC $715,682 S 1 .0000 $715,682 $322,057 $393.625 $322,057 $393,625 COUNTY OF CORTLAND 63190- 11 02002 C OF CORTLAND $2,796,665 S 1.0000 $2,796,665 $1 ,258,499 $1,538.166 $1,258,499 $1,538,166 63190 - 1122 T OF CORTLANDVILLE $1,423,087 F 0.6879 $2,068,741 $930,933 $1,137,808 $640,389 $782,698 63190- 1126 T OF FREETOWN $21, 1 29 F 0.9570 $22,078 $9,935 $12.143 $9,508 $11,621 63190- 1130 T OF HOMER $1,465,557 F 0.9829 $1,491,054 $670,974 $820,080 $659,501 $806,056 63190- 1140 T OF SOLON $109.939 F 1.0215 $107,625 $48,431 $59.194 $48,431 $61,508 63190- 1144 T OF TRUXTON $8,880 F 0.8959 $9,912 $4,460 $5,452 $3.996 $4,884 63190- 1146 . T OF VIRGIL $59,134 F 0.8833 $66,947 $30,126 $36,821 $26,610 $32,524 COUNTY OF DELAWARE 63190- 1220 T OF ANDES $11,838 F 0.3296 $35,916 $16,162 $19,754 $5,327 $6,511 63190- 1224 T OF COLCHESTER $557 F 0.0652 $8,543 $3,844 $4,699 $251 $306 63190- 1226 T OF DAVENPORT $42,565 F 0.0427 $996,838 $448,577 $548,261 $19,154 $23,411 63190- 1230 T OF DEPOSIT $3,185 F 0.0797 $39,962 $17,983 $21,979 $1,433 $1,752 63190- 1232 T OF FRANKLIN $16,554 F 0.3236 $51,156 $23,020 $28,136 $7,449 $9,105 63190- 1236 T OF HANCOCK $251,999 F 0.2990 $842,806 $379,263 $463,543 $113,400 $138,599 63190- 1238 T OF HARPERSFIELD $340,876 F 0.4386 $7n,191 $349,736 $427,455 $153,394 $187,482 63190- 1240 T OF KORTRIGHT $81,751 F 0.2304 $354,822 $159,670 $195,152 $36,788 $44,963 63190- 1244 T OF MEREDITH $64,012 F 0.6002 $106,651 $47,993 $58,658 $28,805 $35,207 63190- 1246 T OF MIDDLETOWN $986,948 T 1.0670 $924,975 $416,239 $508,736 $416,239 $570,709 63190- 1250 T OF SIDNEY $54,094 F 0.3102 $174,384 $78,473 $95,911 $24,342 $29,752 63190- 1252 T OF STAMFORD $179,175 F 0.4106 $436,374 $196,368 $240,005 $80,629 $98,546 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 8 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = == =:=========== = = = = == == ===== ==== ==;= = == ==== === == ====:== = ==:::: == =:=== ======:= = = == =::::::: =:====== ==== COUNlY OF DUTCHESS 63190- 1313002 C OF POUGHKEEPSIE $2,486,496 T 0.2140 $11,619,140 $5,228,613 $6,390,527 $1,118,923 $1,367,573 63190- 1320 T OF AMENtA $1,982,181 F 0.9685 $2,046,650 $920,993 $1,125,658 $891,981 $1,090,200 63190- 1322 T OF BEEKMAN $1,435,304 T 1 .0329 $1,389,587 $625,314 $764,273 $625,314 $809,990 63190- 1324 T OF CLINTON $1,586,840 S 1.0000 $1,586,840 $714,078 $872,762 $714,078 $872,762 63190- 1326 T OF DOVER $2,760,577 F 0.7694 $3,587,961 $1,614,582 $1,973,378 $1,242,260 $1,518,317 63190 - 1328 T OF EAST FISHKILL $472,353 T 0.2359 $2,002,344 $901,055 $1,101,289 $212,559 $259,794 63190 - 1330 T OF FISHKILL $6,992,694 F 0.9564 $7,311,474 $3,290,163 $4,021,311 $3,146,712 $3,845,982 63190 - 1332 T OF HYDE PARK $5,585,840 S 1.0000 $5,585,840 $2,513,628 $3,072,212 $2,513,628 $3,072,212 63190 - 1334 T OF LA GRANGE $4,530,948 F 1.1301 $4,009,334 $1,804,200 $2,205,134 $1,804,200 $2,726,748 63190- 1336 . T OF MILAN $20,540 T 0.9842 $20,870 $9,391 $11,478 $9,243 $11,297 63190 - 1338 T OF NORTH EAST $131,326 T 0.4522 $290,416 $130,687 $159,729 $59,097 $72,229 63190- 1340 T OF PAWLING $2,949,900 F 0.7157 $4,121,699 $1,854,765 $2,266,934 $1,327,455 $1,622,445 63190- 1342 T OF PINE PLAINS $6,095 F 0.7827 $7,787 $3,504 $4,283 $2,743 $3,352 63190- 1344 T OF PLEASANT VALLEY $3,264,364 S 1.0000 $3,264,364 $1,468,964 $1,795,400 $1,468,964 $1,795,400 63190- 1346 T OF POUGHKEEPSIE $18,288,953 T 0.9615 $19,021,272 $8,559,572 $10,461,700 $8,230,029 $10,058,924 63190- 1350 T OF RHINEBECK $101,404 F 1.0295 $98,498 $44,324 $54,174 $44,324 $57,080 63190 - 1352 T OF STANFORD $989,682 T 0.5672 $1,744,855 $785,185 $959,670 $445,357 $544,325 63190- 1354 T OF UNION VALE $745,306 F 0.7147 $1,042,824 $469,271 $573,553 $335,388 $409,918 63190- 1356 T OF WAPPINGER $6,063,468 T 0.6705 $9,043,204 $4,069,442 $4,973,762 $2,728,561 $3,334,907 63190- 1358 T OF WASHINGTON $451,672 F 0.1317 $3,429,552 $1,543,298 $1,886,254 $203,252 $248,420 COUNlY OF ERIE 63190- 1416002 63190- 1420 63190- 1424 C OF TONAWANDA T OF ALDEN T OF AURORA $2,664,430 F $1,604,567 F $2,855,028 F 0.8623 0.7295 0.6714 $3,089,911 $2,199,544 $4,252,350 $1,390,460 $989,795 $1,913,558 $1,699,451 $1,209,749 $2,338,793 $1,198,994 $722,055 $1,284,763 $1,465,437 $882,512 $1,570,265 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 9 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment == == == ==:== = == ==== === == = ==== == = == == ==== == == ==:= = == === = == = =:= = == = = === == == == ==== = = = ==:= == = === ==== = =:== = = === = == ====:== == == ==== = == ==:== == == ==== == ==== == 63190- 1426 T OF BOSTON $1,588,885 F 0.8455 $1,879,225 $845,651 $1,033,574 $714,998 $873,887 63190- 1428 T OF BRANT $902,839 F 0.9135 $988,330 $444,748 $543,581 $406,278 $496,561 63190- 1432 T OF CLARENCE $4,250,076 F 0.7942 $5,351,393 $2,408,127 $2,943,266 $1,912,534 $2,337,542 63190 - 1434 T OF COLDEN $522,692 F 0.7619 $686,038 $308,717 $377,321 $235,211 $287,481 63190- 1436 T OF COLLINS $1,521,796 F 0.9417 $1,616,009 $727,204 $888,805 $684,808 $836,988 63190 - 1438 T OF CONCORD $1,860,249 F 0.7978 $2,331,723 $1,049,276 $1,282,448 $837,112 $1,023,137 63190- 1440 T OF EDEN $1,736,713 S 1.0000 $1,736,713 $781,521 $955,192 $781,521 $955,192 63190- 1442 T OF ELMA $186,085 F 0.0778 $2,391,838 $1,076,327 $1,315,511 $83,738 $102,347 63190- 1444 T OF EVANS $4,110,207 F 0.9019 $4,557,276 $2,050,774 $2,506,502 $1,849,593 $2,260,614 63190 - 1448 T OF HAMBURG $12,284,224 F 0.8929 $13,757,671 $6,190,952 $7,566,719 $5,527,901 $6,756,323 63190 - 1450 T OF HOLLAND $751,808 F 0.9434 $796,913 $358,611 $438,302 $338,314 $413,494 63190- 1452 T OF LANCASTER $.8,754,155 F 0.8740 $10,016,196 $4,507,288 $5,508,908 $3,939,370 $4,814,785 63190- 1454 T OF MARILLA $657,808 T 0.7735 $850,431 $382,694 $467,737 $296,014 $361,794 63190- 1456 T OF NEWSTEAD $2,247,413 S 1.0000 $2,247,413 $1,011,336 $1,236,077 $1,011,336 $1,236,077 63190 - 1458 T OF NORTH COLLINS $942,285 F 0.6978 $1,350,365 $607,664 $742,701 $424,028 $518,257 63190- 1462 T OF SARDINIA $588,445 F 0.9412 $625,207 $281,343 $343,864 $264,800 $323,645 63190- 1466 T OF WALES $506,776 F 0.7157 $708,084 $318,638 $389,446 $228,049 $278,727 COUNTY OF ESSEX 63190- 1520 T OF CHESTERFIELD $214,137 T 0.9633 $222,295 $100,033 $122,262 $96,362 $117,775 63190- 1522 T OF CROWN POINT $187,478 S 1.0000 $187,478 $84,365 $103,113 $84,365 $103,113 63190- 1524 T OF ELlZABETHTOWN $1,813,837 F 0.9903 $1,831,604 $824,222 $1,007,382 $816,227 $997,610 63190- 1526 T OF ESSEX $718,103 F 0.9954 $721,422 $324,640 $396,782 $323,146 $394,957 63190- 1530 T OF KEENE $1,278,176 S 1.0000 $1,278,176 $575,179 $702,997 $575,179 $702,997 63190- 1532 T OF LEWIS $884,743 F 0.8983 $984,908 $443,209 $541,699 $398,134 $486,609 63190- 1536 T OF MORIAH $1,319,203 S 1.0000 $1,319,203 $593,641 $725,562 $593,641 $725,562 63190- 1540 T OF NORTH ELBA $2.614,313 S 1.0000 $2,614.313 $1.176.441 $1.437,872 $1.176,441 $1.437,872 63190- 1542 T OF NORTH HUDSON $94,240 F 0.1023 $921,212 $414,545 $506,667 $42,408 $51,832 63190- 1544 T OF ST ARMAND $686,601 S 1.0000 $686,601 $308,970 $377,631 $308,970 $377,631 63190- 1546 T OF SCHROON $1.308,320 S 1.0000 $1,308,320 $588,744 $719,576 $568,744 $719,576 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 10 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = ==== = = == = = = = == = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = == = === = = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = ====::::::= 63190- 1548 T OF TICONDEROGA $2,013,337 S 1.0000 $2,013,337 $906,002 $1,107,335 $906,002 $1,107,335 63190- 1550 T OF WESTPORT $398,763 F 1.0385 $383,980 $172,791 $211,189 $172,791 $225,972 63190- 1552 T OF WILLSBORO $978,764 F 0.8470 $1,155,566 $520,004 $635,561 $440,444 $538,320 COUNlY OF FRANKLIN 63190- 1620 T OF AL T AMONT $285,688 F 0.1554 $1,838,404 $827,282 $1,011,122 $128,560 $157,128 63190 - 1622 T OF BANGOR $57,325 F 0.0491 $1,167,515 $525,382 $642,133 $25,796 $31,529 63190- 1624 T OF BELLMONT $683,599 F 0.9310 $734,263 $330,418 $403,845 $307,620 $375,979 63190- 1626 T OF BOMBAY $43,954 F 0.0517 $850,174 $382,578 $467,596 $19,779 $24,175 63190- 1628 T OF BRANDON $130,433 F 0.8985 $145,168 $65,325 $79,842 $58,695 $71,738 63190 - 1630 T OF BRIGHTON $21,192 F 0.8140 $26,034 $11,715 $14,319 $9,536 $11,656 63190- 1632 ' T OF BURKE $30,210 F 0.0559 $540,429 $243,193 $297,236 $13,595 $16,616 63190- 1634 T OF CHATEAUGAY $56,606 F 0.0680 $832,441 $374,599 $457,843 $25,473 $31,133 63190- 1636 T OF CONSTABLE $90,682 F 0.1792 $506,038 $227,717 $278,321 $40,807 $49,875 63190- 1638 T OF DICKINSON $23,371 F 0.0516 $452,926 $203,817 $249,109 $10,517 $12,854 63190- 1640 T OF DUANE $160,245 F 0.8753 $183,074 $82,383 $100,691 $72,11 0 $88,135 63190- 1642 T OF FORT COVINGTON $163,241 F 0.1385 $1,178,635 $530,386 $648,249 $73,458 $89,783 63190- 1644 T OF FRANKLIN $1,188,587 F 0.8685 $1,368,552 $615,848 $752,703 $534,864 $653,723 63190- 1646 T OF HARRIETSTOWN $2,601,771 S 1.0000 $2,601,771 $1,170,797 $1,430,974 $1,170,797 $1,430,974 63190- 1648 T OF MALONE $4,341,404 F 0.9328 $4,654,164 $2,094,374 $2,559,790 $1,953,632 $2,387,772 63190- 1650 T OF MOIRA $66,459 F 0.0612 $1,085,931 $488,669 $597,262 $29,907 $36,552 63190- 1652 T OF SANTA CU\RA $42,405 F 0.0878 $482,973 $217,338 $265,635 $19,082 $23,323 63190- 1654 TOFWAVERLY $14,851 F 0.0505 $294,079 $132,336 $161,744 $6,683 $8,168 63190- 1656 T OF WESTVILLE $67,731 F 0.0825 $820,982 $369,442 $451,540 $30,479 $37,252 COUNlY OF FULTON 63190- 1722 T OF BROADALBIN $120,685 F 0.8667 $139,247 $62,661 $76,586 $54,308 $66,377 63190- 1726 T OF EPHRA T AH $344,536 F 0.9033 $381,419 $171,639 $209,781 $155,041 $189,495 63190- 1728 T OF JOHNSTOWN $70,589 F 0.8749 $80,682 $36,307 $44,375 $31,765 $38,824 APPENDIX A NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS Page 11 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = == == = = == = = = = == ===:= = = == = = = =:= = == = = == = = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = ===:= = ==== ==== 63190- 1734 T OF OPPENHEIM $278,577 F 0.8795 $316,745 $142,535 $174,210 $125,360 $153,217 63190 - 1736 T OF PERTH $624,951 F 0.9453 $661,114 $297,501 $363,613 $281,228 $343,723 63190 - 1738 T OF STRATFORD $272,976 F 0.7615 $358,471 $161,312 $197, 159 $122,839 $150,137 COUNTY OF GENESEE 63190 - 1802002 C OF BATAVIA $3,265,824 S 1.0000 $3,265,824 $1,469,621 $1,796,203 $1,469,621 $1,796,203 63190- 1820 T OF ALABAMA $386,428 F 1 .0036 $385,042 $173,269 $211,773 $173,269 $213,159 63190- 1822 T OF ALEXANDER $657,348 F 0.9752 $674,065 $303,329 $370,736 $295,807 $361,541 63190- 1824 T OF BATAVIA $1,238,036 F 0.8931 $1,386,223 $623,800 $762,423 $557,116 $680,920 63190- 1826 T OF BERGEN $63,840 F 1.0079 $63,340 $28,503 $34,837 $28,503 $35,337 63190- 1828 T OF BETHANY . $133,548 F 0.9878 $135,197 $60,839 $74,359 $60,097 $73,451 63190- 1830 ' T OF BYRON $379,240 F 0.9078 $417,757 $187,991 $229,766 $170,658 $208,582 63190- 1832 T OF DARIEN $86,931 S 1.0000 $86,931 $39,119 $47,812 $39,119 $47,812 63190- 1834 T OF ELBA $390,073 F 0.9601 $406,284 $182,828 $223,456 $175,533 $214,540 63190- 1836 T OF LE ROY $11,711 F 0.9403 $12,455 $5,605 $6,850 $5,270 $6,441 63190- 1838 T OF OAKFIELD $504,664 F 0.8938 $564,627 $254,082 $310,545 $227,099 $277,565 63190- 1842 T OF PEMBROKE $131,354 F 1.0170 $129,158 $58,121 $71,037 $58,121 $73,233 63190- 1844 T OF STAFFORD $460,118 F 0.8986 $512,039 $230,417 $281,621 $207,053 $253,065 COUNTY OF GREENE 63190- 1920 T OF ASHLAND $570,926 F 0.9488 $601,735 $270,761 $330,954 $256,917 $314,009 63190- 1922 T OF ATHENS $2,166,301 F 1.1315 $1,914,539 $661,543 $1,052,997 $661,543 $1,304,758 63190- 1924 T OF CAIRO $3,073,208 T 1.0046 $3,059,136 $1,376,611 $1,662,525 $1,376,611 $1,696,597 63190- 1926 T OF CATSKILL $6,229,620 F 1.0214 $6,099,295 $2,744,683 $3,354,612 $2,744,683 $3,485,137 63190- 1928 T OF COXSACKIE $21,139 F 0.0795 $265,699 $119,655 $146,245 $9,513 $11,626 63190- 1930 T OF DURHAM $83,543 F 0.0540 $1,547,093 $696,192 $850,901 $37,594 $45,949 63190- 1932 T OF GREENVILLE $183,167 F 0.0705 $2,598,113 $1,169,151 $1,428,962 $82,425 $100,742 63190- 1934 T OF HALCOTT $159,622 S 1.0000 $159,622 $71,830 $87,792 $71,830 $67,792 63190- 1936 T OF HUNTER $2,233,010 S 1.0000 $2,233,010 $1,004,855 $1,228,156 $1,004,655 $1,226,156 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 12 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = = = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = = = 63190- 1938 T OF JEWETT $780,573 S 1.0000 $780,573 $351,258 $429,315 $351,258 $429,315 63190- 1940 T OF LEXINGTON $697,455 F 0.9428 $739,770 $332,896 $406,873 $313,855 $383,600 63190- 1942 T OF NEW BALTIMORE $19,744 F 0.0632 $312,405 $140,582 $171,823 $8,885 $10,859 63190- 1944 T OF PRA TTSVILLE $568,071 F 1.1094 $512,052 $230,424 $281,629 $230,424 $337,647 63190- 1946 T OF WINDHAM $1,580,979 F 0.9529 $1,659,124 $746,606 $912,518 $711,441 $869,538 COUNlY OF HERKIMER 63190- 2109002 C OF LITTLE FALLS $343,809 F 0.2800 $1,227,889 $552,550 $675,339 $154,714 $189,095 63190- 2120 T OF COLUMBIA $27,009 F 0.0398 $678,618 $305,378 $373,240 $12,154 $14,855 63190- ' 2122 T OF DANUBE $444,792 F 1.0110 $439.953 $197.979 $241,974 $197,979 $246,813 63190- 2124 T,OF FAIRFIELD $11,977 F 0.0587 $204,037 $91,817 $112,221 $5,390 $6,587 63190- 2126 T OF FRANKFORT $2,971,032 F 1.0034 $2,960,965 $1,332,434 $1,628,531 $1,332,434 $1.638,598 63190- 2128 T OF GERMAN FLA TTS $2,866,126 F 0.9709 $2,952,030 $1,328,414 $1,623,617 $1,289,757 $1,576,369 63190- 2130 T OF HERKIMER $208,035 F 0.0796 $2,613,505 $1,176,077 $1,437.428 $93,616 $114,419 63190- 2132 T OF LITCHFIELD $418,464 F 0.9915 $422,051 $189,923 $232,128 $188,309 $230,155 63190- 2134 T OF LITTLE FALLS $20,225 F 0.0333 $607,357 $273,311 $334,047 $9,101 $11,124 63190- 2136 T OF MANHEIM $75,974 F 0.0724 $1,049,365 $472,214 $577,151 $34,188 $41,786 63190- 2144 T OF RUSSIA $7,515 F 0.0393 $191,221 $86,050 $105,172 $3,382 $4,133 63190- 2146 T OF SALISBURY $65,014 F 0.0962 $675,821 $304,120 $371,702 $29,256 $35,758 63190- 2148 T OF SCHUYLER $74,813 F 0.0563 $1,328,828 $597,972 $730,855 $33,666 $41,147 63190- 2150 T OF STARK $13,275 F 0.0432 $307,292 $138,281 $169,010 $5,974 $7,301 63190- 2152 T OF WARREN $448,761 F 0.9481 $473,327 $212,997 $260,330 $201,942 $246,819 COUNlY OF JEFFERSON 63190- 2220 T OF ADAMS $1,192 S 1 .0000 $1,192 $536 $656 $536 $656 63190- 2222 T OF ALEXANDRIA $1,145,876 F 0.7933 $1,444,442 $649,999 $794,443 $515,644 $630,232 63190- 2224 T OF ANTWERP $407,373 F 0.8678 $469,432 $211,244 $258,188 $183,318 $224,055 63190- 2226 T OF BROWNVILLE $405,700 F 0.9300 $436,237 $196,306 $239,930 $182,565 $223,135 63190- 2230 T OF CHAMPION $1,228,091 S 1 .0000 $1,228,091 $552,641 $675,450 $552,641 $675,450 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 13 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment === =:= ======= ====== ==== ==:= = = === = = =:== == = === == = === = = =:= = = == = == =:= = = == = = ==:= ==== = = = =:= = = == == == = 63190- 2232 T OF CLAYTON $1,608,286 S 1.0000 $1,608,286 $723,729 $884,557 $723,729 $884,557 63190- 2234 T OF ELLlSBURG $27,026 S 1.0000 $27,026 $12,162 $14,864 $12,162 $14,864 63190- 2238 T OF HOUNSFIELD $724,369 F 0.9399 $770,687 $346,809 $423,878 $325,966 $398,403 63190- 2240 TOFLERAY $3,093,206 F 1.0001 $3,092,897 $1,391,804 $1,701,093 $1,391,804 $1,701,402 63190- 2242 T OF LORRAINE $1,101 S 1.0000 $1,101 $495 $606 $495 $606 63190- 2244 T OF LYME $2,206 F 0.6351 $3,473 $1,563 $1,910 $993 $1,213 63190- 2246 T OF ORLEANS $852,368 F 0.7737 $1,101,678 $495,755 $605,923 $383,566 $468,802 63190- 2248 T OF PAMEllA $1,204,051 F 1.0932 $1,101,400 $495,630 $605,770 $495,630 $708,421 63190- 2250 T OF PHILADELPHIA $335,348 F 0.7551 $444,111 $199,850 $244,261 $150,907 $184,441 63190- 2252 T OF RODMAN $57,427 F 0.9457 $60,724 $27,326 $33,398 $25,842 $31,585 63190- , 2254 T OF RUTLAND $766,333 F 0.9427 $812,913 $365,811 $447,102 $344,850 $421,483 63190- 2256 T. OF THERESA $1,104,611 F 1.0251 $1,077,564 $484,904 $592,660 $484,904 $619,707 63190- 2258 T OF WATERTOWN $1,229,356 F 0.9767 $1,258,683 $566,407 $692,276 $553,210 $676,146 63190- 2260 T OF WllNA $1,895,046 T 0.9308 $2,035,933 $916,170 $1,119,763 $852,771 $1,042,275 COUNTY OF lEWIS 63190- 2320 T OF CROGHAN $34,864 F 0.1342 $259,791 $116,906 $142,885 $15,689 $19,175 63190- 2322 T OF DENMARK $254,794 F 0.5316 $479,296 $215,683 $263,613 $114,657 $140,137 63190- 2324 T OF DIANA $378,023 F 0.5024 $752,434 $338,595 $413,839 $170,110 $207,913 63190- 2328 T OF HARRISBURG $40,499 F 0.7376 $54,906 $24,708 $30,199 $18,225 $22,274 63190- 2346 T OF OSCEOLA $242,270 F 0.4978 $486,681 $219,007 $267,675 $109,022 $133,249 63190- 2348 T OF PINCKNEY $114,469 F 0.8826 $129,695 $58,363 $71,332 $51,511 $62,958 COUNTY OF LIVINGSTON 63190- 2442 T OF OSSIAN $4,290 S 1.0000 $4,290 $1,931 $2,360 $1,931 $2,360 COUNTY OF MADISON 63190- 2512012 C OF ONEIDA INSIDE $2,254,814 T 0.9525 $2,367,259 $1,065,266 $1,301,992 $1,014,666 $1,240,148 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 14 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment === =:= == ==== = === = === == ===:== = == == = =:== == ==== == = ==== = =:= = = == = = = =:= = === = = = =:= == == ====:= = = == === = = 63190- 2512022 C OF ONEIDA OUTSIDE $890,804 T 0.9525 $935,227 $420,852 $514,375 $400,862 $489,942 63190- 2526 T OF EATON $338.931 S 1.0000 $338,931 $152,519 $186,412 $152,519 $186,412 63190- 2532 T OF HAMILTON $1,085,982 F 0.9250 $1,174,035 $528,316 $645,719 $488,692 $597,290 63190- 2534 T OF LEBANON $132,732 S 1.0000 $132,732 $59,729 $73,003 $59,729 $73,003 63190- 2536 T OF LENOX $2,082,161 F 1.0358 $2,010,196 $904,588 $1,105,608 $904,588 $1,177,573 63190- 2538 T OF LINCOLN $326,323 F 1 .1259 $289,833 $130,425 $159,408 $130,425 $195,898 63190- 2540 T OF MADISON $382,897 F 0.9310 $411,275 $185,074 $226,201 $172,304 $210,593 63190- 2546 T OF STOCKBRIDGE $138,546 S 1.0000 $138,546 $62,346 $76,200 $62,346 $76,200 63190- 2548 T OF SULLIVAN $3,616,699 T 0.9205 $3,929,059 $1,768,077 $2,160,983 $1,627,515 $1,989,184 COUNTY OF MONROE 63190- 2620 T OF BRIGHTON $218,243 S 1.0000 $218,243 $98,209 $120,034 $98,209 $120,034 63190- 2622 T OF CHILI $2,871 F 0.0511 $56,184 $25,283 $30,901 $1,292 $1,579 63190- 2624 T OF CLARKSON $8,816 F 0.5306 $16,615 $7,477 $9,138 $3,967 $4,849 63190- 2626 T OF GATES $40,641 F 0.0794 $511,851 $230,333 $281,518 $18,288 $22,353 63190- 2630 T OF HAMLIN $35,163 F 0.6226 $56,478 $25,415 $31,063 $15,823 $19,340 63190- 2642 T OF PENFIELD $23,573 S 1.0000 $23,573 $10,608 $12,965 $10,608 $12.965 63190- 2644 T OF PERINTON $12,299 F 0.1073 $114,623 $51,580 $63,042 $5,535 $6.764 63190- 2648 T OF RIGA $8,437 S 1 .0000 $8,437 $3,797 $4,640 $3,797 $4,640 63190- 2652 T OF SWEDEN $121 F 0.0699 $1 ,731 $779 $952 $54 $67 63190- 2658 T OF EAST ROCHESTER $1,632 F 0.1511 $10,801 $4,860 $5,940 $734 $898 COUNTY OF MONTGOMERY 63190- 2720 T OF AMSTERDAM $335,176 F 0.1599 $2,096,160 $943,272 $1,152,888 $150,829 $184,347 63190- 2722 T OF CANAJOHARIE $489 F 0.1832 $2,669 $1,201 $1,468 $220 $269 63190- 2724 T OF CHARLESTON $145,137 F 0.6001 $241,855 $108,835 $133,020 $65,312 $79,825 63190- 2726 T OF FLORIDA $869,258 F 0.9573 $908,031 $408,614 $499,417 $391,166 $478,092 63190- 2732 T OF MOHAWK $58,220 F 0.5440 $107,022 $48,160 $58,862 $26,199 $32,021 63190- 2736 T OF ROOT $1,304 F 0.6544 $1,993 $897 $1,096 $587 $717 APPENDIX A NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS Page 15 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment === =:= ======= ==== == === == =:== === ====:====== == == === = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = === = = = =:=== == = = = =:= = = == = === = COUNTY OF NASSAU 63190- 2805002 C OF GLEN COVE $265,683 T 0.0425 $6,251,365 $2,813,114 $3,438,251 $119,557 $146,126 COUNTY OF NIAGARA 63190- 2909002 C OF LOCKPORT $3,962,055 F 0.8083 $4,901,713 $2,205,771 $2,695,942 $1,782,925 $2,179,130 63190- 2911002 C OF NIAGARA FALLS $12,233,018 F 0.9770 $12,521,001 $5,634,450 $6,886,551 $5,504,858 $6,728,160 63190- 2912002 C OF N. TONAWANDA $4,856,667 F 0.6795 $7,147,413 $3,216,336 $3,931,077 $2,185,500 $2,671,167 63190- 2920 T OF CAMBRIA $382,999 S 1.0000 $382,999 $172,350 $210,649 $172,350 $210,649 63190- 2922 T. OF HARTLAND . $560,958 S 1.0000 $560,958 $252,431 $308,527 $252,431 $308,527 63190- 2924 T OF LEWISTON $3,139,574 S 1.0000 $3,139,574 $1,412,808 $1,726,766 $1,412,808 $1,726,766 63190- 2926 T OF LOCKPORT ~2,490,184 S 1.0000 $2,490,184 $1,120,583 $1,369,601 $1,120,583 $1,369,601 63190- 2928 T OF NEWFANE $1,245,704 F 0.8469 $1,470,899 $661,904 $808,994 $560,567 $685,137 63190- 2930 T OF NIAGARA $2,324,713 F 0.8896 $2,613,212 $1,175,945 $1,437,266 $1,046,121 $1,278,592 63190- 2932 T OF PENDLETON $1,402,084 S 1 .0000 $1,402,084 $630,938 $771,146 $630,938 $771,146 63190- 2934 T OF PORTER $1,504,821 S 1 .0000 $1,504,821 $677,169 $827,652 $677,169 $827,652 63190- 2936 T OF ROYAL TON $1,274,444 S 1.0000 $1,274,444 $573,500 $700,944 $573,500 $700,944 63190- 2938 T OF SOMERSET $323,561 F 0.9861 $328,122 $147,655 $180,467 $145,602 $177,959 63190- 2940 T OF WHEA TFIELD $1,199,959 S 1 .0000 $1,199,959 $539,982 $659,977 $539,982 $659,977 63190- 2942 T OF WILSON $524,334 S 1.0000 $524,334 $235,950 $288,384 $235,950 $288,384 COUNTY OF ONEIDA 63190- 3013012 C OF ROME INSIDE $6,690,611 T 0.9424 $7,099,545 $3,194,795 $3,904,750 $3,010,775 $3,679,836 63190- 3013022 C OF ROME OUTSIDE $2,744,204 T 0.9424 $2,911,931 $1,310,369 $1,601,562 $1,234,892 $1,509,312 63190- 3014002 C OF SHERRILL $760,514 F 1 . 1 055 $687,937 $309,572 $378,365 $309,572 $450,942 63190- 3016002 C OF UTICA $2,186,083 F 0.1021 $21,411,195 $9,635,038 $11,776,157 $983,737 $1,202,346 63190- 3020 T OF ANNSVILLE $883,908 F 0.7788 $1,134,961 $510,733 $624,229 $397,759 $486,149 63190- 3028 T OF BRIDGEWATER $753 F 0.0913 $8,248 $3,711 $4,536 $339 $414 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 16 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =.= = = = = == = = = = = = == = = ==:: = ==:== == :: = = ==:: = ==::: == ==... = = = == = = = = = ==... ==::: = = = = == == = ==:= == == == == = = = =:= = = == == == = = =:= = = = = = = = = = 63190- 3030 T OF CAMDEN $64,281 F 0.0369 $1,742,033 $783,915 $958,118 $28,926 $35,355 63190- 3032 T OF DEERFIELD $363,443 F 0.2511 $1,447,403 $651,332 $796,072 $163,549 $199,894 63190- 3034 T OF FLORENCE $259,834 F 0.3355 $774,468 $348,511 $425,957 $116,925 $142,909 63190- 3036 T OF FLOYD $583,903 F 1.0065 $580,132 $261,059 $319,073 $261,059 $322,844 63190- 3040 T OF KIRKLAND $3,110,583 S 1.0000 $3,110,583 $1,399,762 $1,710,821 $1,399,762 $1,710,821 63190- 3042 T OF LEE $71,421 F 0.0459 $1,556,013 $700,206 $855,807 $32,139 $39,282 63190-. 3044 T OF MARCY $48,405 F 0.0334 $1,449,251 $652,163 $797,088 $21,782 $26,623 63190- 3046 T OF MARSHALL $30,868 F 0.9813 $31,456 $14,155 $17,301 $13,891 $16,977 63190- 3048 T OF NEW HARTFORD $5,167,934 S 1.0000 $5,167,934 $2,325,570 $2,842,364 $2,325,570 $2,842,364 63190- 3050 T OF PARIS $417,576 S 1.0000 $417,576 $187,909 $229,667 $187,909 $229,667 63190- ' 3052 T OF REMSEN $3,992 F 0.9557 $4,177 $1,880 $2,297 $1,796 $2,196 63190- 3058 T ,OF TRENTON $1,570,524 F 0.7479 $2,099,912 $944,960 $1,154,951 $706,736 $863,788 63190- 3060 T OF VERNON $2,158,803 F 1.0227 $2,110,886 $949,899 $1,160,987 $949,899 $1,208,904 63190- 3062 T OF VERONA $2,472,132 F 0.9459 $2,613,524 $1,176,086 $1,437,438 $1,112,459 $1,359,673 63190- 3064 T OF VIENNA $1,445,908 F 1.0462 $1,382,057 $621,926 $760,131 $621,926 $823,982 63190- 3066 T OF WESTERN $64,347 F 0.9603 $67,007 $30,153 $36,854 $28,956 $35,391 63190- 3068 T OF WESTMORELAND $1,293,860 F 0.9954 $1,299,839 $584,928 $714,912 $582,237 $711,623 63190- 3070 T OF WHITESTOWN $4,813,140 S 1 .0000 $4,813,140 $2,165,913 $2,647,227 $2,165,913 $2,647,227 COUNTY OF ONONDAGA 63190- 3120 T OF CAMILLUS $7,130,520 S 1 .0000 $7,130,520 $3,208,734 $3,921,786 $3,208,734 $3,921,786 63190- 3122 T OF CICERO $489,115 F 0.0706 $6,927,975 $3,117,589 $3,810,386 $220,102 $269,013 63190- 3124 T OF CLAY $744,064 F 0.0628 $11,848,153 $5,331,669 $6,516,484 $334,829 $409,235 63190- 3126 T OF DEWITT $643,021 T 0.0631 $10,190,507 $4,585,728 $5,604,779 $289,359 $353,662 63190- 3128 T OF ELBRIDGE $1,277,976 S 1.0000 $1,277,976 $575,089 $702,887 $575,089 $702,887 63190- 3130 T OF FABIUS $281,441 F 0.7918 $355,445 $159,950 $195,495 $126,648 $154,793 63190- 3132 T OF GEDDES $4,529,094 S 1 .0000 $4,529,094 $2,038,092 $2,491,002 $2,038,092 $2,491,002 63190 - 3134 T OF LAFAYETTE $111,907 F 0.0620 $1,804,952 $812,228 $992,723 $50,358 $61,549 63190- 3136 T OF LYSANDER $5,115,477 F 1 .0431 $4,904,110 $2,206,849 $2,697,260 $2,206,849 $2,908,628 63190- 3138 T OF MANLIUS $4,725,579 S 1.0000 $4,725,579 $2,126,511 $2,599,068 $2,126,511 $2,599,068 APPENDIX A NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS Page 17 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =.= = = = = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =.= = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = = = 63190- 3140 T OF MARCELLUS $7,744 F 0.0553 $140,036 $63,016 $77,020 $3,485 $4,259 63190- 3142 T OF ONONDAGA $5,254,712 S 1 .0000 $5,254,712 $2,364,620 $2,890,092 $2,364,620 $2,890,092 63190- 3144 T OF OTISCO $44,573 F 0.0404 $1,103,292 $496,481 $606,811 $20,058 $24,515 63190- 3146 T OF POMPEY $481,963 F 1.0124 $476,060 $214,227 $261,833 $214,227 $267,736 63190- 3148 T OF SALINA $561,938 T 0.0591 $9,508,257 $4,278,716 $5,229,541 $252,872 $309,066 63190- 3150 T OF SKANEA TELES $2,387,175 F 0.9934 $2,403,035 $1,081,366 $1,321,669 $1,074,229 $1,312,946 63190- 3152 T OF SPAFFORD $9,895 T 0.0407 $243,120 $109,404 $133,716 $4,453 $5,442 63190- 3154 T OF TULLY $1,464,840 T 0.9890 $1,481,132 $666,510 $814,623 $659,178 $805,662 63190- 3156 T OF VAN BUREN $278,396 F 0.0932 $2,987,082 $1,344,187 $1,642,895 $125,278 $153,118 COUNTY OF ONTARIO 63190- 3205002 C OF GENEVA $2,595,922 T 0.9773 $2,656,218 $1,195,298 $1,460,920 $1,168,165 $1,427,757 63190- 3228 T OF FARMINGTON ' $276,067 F 0.9020 $306,061 $137,727 $168,334 $124,230 $151,837 63190- 3230 T OF GENEVA $915,205 T 0.8980 $1,019,159 $458,622 $560,538 $411,842 $503,363 COUNTY OF ORANGE 63190- 3311002 C OF NEWBURGH $4,332,234 T 0.5121 $8,459,742 $3,806,884 $4,652,858 $1,949,505 $2,382,729 63190- 3324 T OF CORNWALL $2,894,917 F 0.8533 $3,392,613 $1,526,676 $1,865,937 $1,302,713 $1,592,204 63190- 3326 T OF CRAWFORD $451,318 T 0.5327 $847,227 $381,252 $465,975 $203,093 $248,225 63190- 3330 T OF GOSHEN $83,733 F 0.2570 $325,809 $146,614 $179,195 $37,680 $46,053 63190- 3336 T OF HIGHLANDS $1,600,576 F 1.0401 $1,538,867 $692,490 $846,377 $692,490 $908,086 63190- 3340 T OF MONROE $17,377 F 0.3607 $48,176 $21,679 $26,497 $7,820 $9,557 63190- 3342 T OF MONTGOMERY $1,408,505 T 0.9183 $1,533,818 $690,218 $843,600 $633,827 $774,678 63190- 3346 T OF NEWBURGH $7,745,724 T 0.6250 $12,393,158 $5,576,921 $6,816,237 $3,485,576 $4,260,148 63190- 3348 T OF NEW WINDSOR $1,879,242 T 0.2676 $7,022,578 $3,160,160 $3,862,418 $845,659 $1,033,583 63190- 3350 T OF TUXEDO $1,522,223 F 0.3096 $4,916,741 $2,212,533 $2,704,208 $685,000 $837,223 63190- 3352 T OF WALLKILL $85,612 T 0.4004 $213,816 $96,217 $117,599 $38,525 $47,087 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 18 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =.= = = = == === == == = == == == == = == == == == ==:== = == = == == == == ==.== == ==== == == == = == == = = == == == == ==.== == == == == == == == ==.== == == == == == == == ==.== == == == == == == == ==:== == == == == == == == == == 63190- 3354 T OF WARWICK $536,144 F 0.2408 $2,226,512 $1,001,930 $1,224,581 $241,265 $294,879 63190- 3356 T OF WAWAYANDA $3,806 F 0.3273 $11,628 $5,233 $6,396 $1,713 $2,093 63190- 3358 T OF WOODBURY $849,028 T 0.7177 $1,182,985 $532,343 $650,641 $382,063 $466,965 COUNTY OF ORLEANS 63190- 3420 T OF ALBION $1,156,175 F 0.8408 $1,375,089 $618,790 $756,299 $520,279 $635,696 63190- 3422 T OF BARRE $233,497 F 0.9877 $236,405 $106,382 $130,023 $105,074 $128,423 63190- 3424 T OF CARLTON $567,212 F 0.9545 $594,250 $267,413 $326,838 $255,245 $311,967 63190- 3426 T OF CLARENDON $345,604 F 0.9962 $347,123 $156,205 $190,916 $155,612 $190,192 63190- . 3426 T OF GAINES $352,255 F 0.8586 $410,267 $184,620 $225,647 $158,515 $193,740 63190- 3430 T OF KENDALL ' $392,838 F 0.9695 $405,196 $182,338 $222,858 $176,777 $216,061 63190- 3432 T OF MURRAY $898,230 T 0.9434 $952,120 $428,454 $523,666 $404,204 $494,027 63190- 3434 T OF RIDGEWAY $1,186,969 F 1.0226 $1,160,736 $522,331 $638,405 $522,331 $664,638 63190- 3436 T OF SHELBY $676,161 F 1.0237 $660,507 $297,228 $363,279 $297,228 $378,933 63190- 3438 T OF YATES $539,742 T 0.8297 $650,527 $292,737 $357,790 $242,884 $296,858 COUNTY OF OSWEGO 63190- 3504002 C OF FULTON $192 F 0.0629 $3,052 $1,374 $1,679 $86 $106 63190- 3522 T OF AMBOY $2,309 F 0.0359 $64,318 $28,943 $35,375 $1,039 $1,270 63190- 3526 T OF CONST ANTrA $1,462,207 F 0.8710 $1,678,768 $755,446 $923,322 $657,993 $804,214 63190- 3528 T OF GRANBY $6,124 F 0.9386 $6,525 $2,936 $3,589 $2,756 $3,368 63190- 3532 T OF HASTINGS $481,769 F 1.0120 $476,056 $214,225 $261,831 $214,225 $267,544 63190- 3534 T OF MEXICO $148,609 F 0.0997 $1,490,562 $670,753 $819,809 $66,874 $81,735 63190- 3536 T OF MINETTO $349,826 F 1 ,261 2 $277,376 $124,819 $152,557 $124,819 $225,007 63190- 3538 T OF NEW HAVEN $17,320 F 0.0258 $671,318 $302,093 $369,225 $7,794 $9,526 63190- 3542 T OF OSWEGO $57,626 F 0.0483 $1,193,085 $536,888 $656,197 $25,932 $31,694 63190- 3544 T OF PALERMO $110,936 F 1 .0460 $106,057 $47,726 $58,332 $47,726 $63,210 63190- 3546 T OF PARISH $47,623 T 0.0387 $1,230,568 $553,756 $676,813 $21,430 $26,193 63190- 3548 T OF REDFIELD $18,297 F 0.0240 $762,375 $343,069 $419,306 $8,234 $10,063 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 19 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = = = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = = = 63190- 3550 T OF RICHLAND $21,475 F 1.0367 $20,715 $9,322 $11,393 $9,322 $12,153 63190- 3552 T OF SANDY CREEK $48 F 0.0429 $1,119 $503 $615 $22 $26 63190- 3556 T OF SCRIBA $169,948 T 0.0936 $1,815,684 $817,058 $998,626 $76,477 $93,471 63190- 3558 T OF VOLNEY $9,914 F 0.0830 $119,446 $53,751 $65,695 $4,461 $5,453 63190- 3560 T OF WEST MONROE $14,664 F 0.0530 $276,679 $124,506 $152,174 $6,599 $8,065 COUNTY OF OTSEGO 63190- 3612002 C OF ONEONTA $1,079,849 T 0.3792 $2,847,703 $1,281,466 $1,566,237 $485,932 $593,917 63190- 3620 T OF BURLINGTON $284,299 S 1.0000 $284,299 $127,935 $156,364 $127,935 $156,364 63190- , 3622 T OF BUTTERNUTS $15,877 F 0.6300 $25,202 $11,341 $13,861 $7,145 $8,732 63190- 3624 T OF. CHERRY VALLEY $294,747 F 0.6062 $486,221 $218,799 $267,421 $132,636 $162,111 63190- 3626 T OF DECATUR $35,365 F 0.3091 $114,413 $51,486 $62,927 $15,914 $19,451 63190- 3628 T OF EDMESTON $320,101 F 0.8698 $368,017 $165,608 $202,409 $144,045 $176,056 63190- 3630 T OF EXETER $237,249 F 0.8318 $285,224 $128,351 $156,873 $106,762 $130,487 63190- 3632 T OF HARTWICK $744,345 F 0.9112 $816,884 $367,598 $449,286 $334,955 $409,390 63190- 3634 T OF LAURENS $232,029 F 0.6360 $364,825 $164,171 $200,654 $104,413 $127,616 63190- 3636 T OF MARYLAND $39,813 F 0.0564 $705,904 . $317,657 $388,247 $17,916 $21,897 63190- 3638 T OF MIDDLEFIELD $843,680 F 0.8212 $1,027,375 $462,319 $565,056 $379,656 $464,024 63190- 3640 T OF MILFORD $791 ,704 F 1.0399 $761,327 $342,597 $418,730 $342,597 $449,107 63190- 3644 T OF NEW LISBON $243,048 S 1.0000 $243,048 $109,372 $133,676 $109,372 $133,676 63190- 3646 T OF ONEONTA $2,138,395 F 1.0578 $2,021,549 $909,697 $1,111,852 $909,697 $1,228,698 63190- 3648 T OF OTEGO $570,648 F 0.8319 $685,957 $308,681 $377,277 $256,792 $313,856 63190- 3650 T OF OTSEGO $1,887,804 F 0.7716 $2,446,610 $1,100,974 $1,345,635 $849,512 $1,038,292 63190- 3652 T OF PITTSFIELD $5,124 F 0.7078 $7,239 $3,258 $3,982 $2,306 $2,818 63190- 3656 T OF RICHFIELD $746,766 F 1.0291 $725,650 $326,542 $399,107 $326,542 $420,224 63190- 3658 T OF ROSEBOOM $8,885 F 0.0277 $320,758 $144,341 $176,417 $3,998 $4,887 63190- 3660 T OF SPRINGFIELD $136,637 F 0.2900 $471 ,162 $212,023 $259,139 $61,487 $75,150 63190- 3662 T OF UNADILLA $52,708 F 0.8190 $64,357 $28,960 $35,396 $23,719 $28,989 63190- 3664 T OF WESTFORD $189,579 F 0.7679 $246,880 $111,096 $135,784 $85,311 $104,268 63190- 3666 T OF WORCESTER $615,676 F 0.9129 $674,418 $303,488 $370,930 $277,054 $338,622 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 20 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = = = == = = =::::: = =:::::::::: = = = = = == = = =:::::::::: =::::: =:= = == = = =::::: ::::: =::::: =::::: = = = =:::::: = :::::::::: = ::::: =::::: =:= =::::: =::::: :::::::::: ::::: =:= =::::: =:::::::::::::::::::: = == ::::: ::::: =::::::::::::::::::::::::: = COUNTY OF PUTNAM 63190- 3720 T OF CARMEL $843,123 T 0.0718 $11,742,660 $5,284,197 $6,458,463 $379,405 $463,718 63190- 3722 T OF KENT $547,568 F 0.0751 $7,291,185 $3,281,033 $4,010,152 $246,406 $301,162 63190- 3724 T OF PATTERSON $344,715 T 0.0632 $5,454,351 $2,454,458 $2,999,893 $155,122 $189,593 63190- 3726 T OF PHILlPSTOWN $458,240 F 0.0507 $9,038,264 $4,067,219 $4,971,045 $206,208 $252,032 63190- 3728 T OF PUTNAM VALLEY $508,054 T 0.0746 $6,810,375 $3,064,669 $3,745,706 $228,624 $279,430 63190- 3730 T OF SOUTHEAST $823,990 F 0.0811 $10,160,173 $4,572,078 $5,588,095 $370,796 $453,195 COUNTY OF RENSSELAER 63190- 3814002 C OF RENSSELAER $984,323 F 0.4990 $1,972,591 $887,666 $1,084,925 $442,945 $541,378 63190- 3817002 C OF TROY $2,397,027 F 0.2339 $10,248,085 $4,611,638 . $5,636,447 $1,078,662 $1,318,365 63190- 3820 T OF BERLIN $9,351 F 0.4252 $21,992 $9,896 $12,096 $4,208 $5,143 63190- 3822 T OF BRUNSWICK $1,277,678 F 0.3917 $3,261,879 $1,467,846 $1,794,033 $574,955 $702,723 63190- 3824 T OF EAST GREEN BUSH $1,577,326 F 0.4331 $3,641,944 $1,638,875 $2,003,069 $709,797 $867,529 63190- 3826 T OF GRAFTON $94,367 F 0.1561 $604,529 $272,038 $332,491 $42,465 $51,902 63190- 3828 T OF HOOSICK $1,198,167 F 0.4518 $2,651,985 $1,193,393 $1,458,592 $539,175 $658,992 63190- 3830 T OF NASSAU $335,391 F 0.9633 $348,169 $156,676 $191,493 $150,926 $184,465 63190- 3832 T OF N. GREEN BUSH $1,198,790 F 0.3919 $3,058,918 $1,376,513 $1,682,405 $539,456 $659,335 63190- 3834 T OF PETERSBURG $54,950 S 1.0000 $54,950 $24,728 $30,223 $24,728 $30,223 63190- 3836 T OF PITTSTOWN $1,140,145 F 0.5168 $2,206,163 $992,773 $1,213,390 $513,065 $627,080 63190- 3838 T OF POESTENKlLL $469,952 F 0.4173 $1,126,173 $506,778 $619,395 $211,478 $258,474 63190- 3840 T OF SAND LAKE $744,126 F 0.4036 $1,843,722 $829,675 $1,014,047 $334,857 $409,269 63190- 3842 T OF SCHAGHTlCOKE $1,043,144 F 0.4332 $2,407,996 $1,083,598 $1,324,398 $469,415 $573,729 63190- 3844 T OF SCHODACK $1,684,562 F 0.3974 $4,238,958 $1,907,531 $2,331,427 $758,053 $926,509 COUNTY OF ROCKLAND 63190- 3920 T OF CLARKSTOWN $18,816,805 T 0.6408 $29,364,552 $13,214,048 $16,150,504 $8,467,562 $10,349,243 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 21 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = ===== == ============ == == ==:== ====== == =:= == ==== == == ==== == == ==:= == === == == === == == == == == ==:= == ==== ===:===== == ==== 63190- 3922 T OF HAVERSTRAW $888,761 T 0.1119 $7,942,458 $3,574,106 $4,368,352 $399,942 $488,819 63190- 3924 T OF ORANGETOWN $19,323,106 F 0.9860 $19,597,471 $8,818,862 $10,778,609 $8,695,398 $10,627,708 63190- 3926 T OF RAMAPO $10,916,393 T 0.2968 $36,780,300 $16,551,135 $20,229,165 $4,912,377 $6,004,016 63190- 3928 T OF STONY POINT $1,456,458 F 0.3004 $4,848,395 $2,181,778 $2,666,618 $655,406 $801,052 COUNTY OF ST LAWRENCE 63190- 4012002 C OF OGDENSBURG $1,889,196 S 1.0000 $1,889,196 $850,138 $1,039,058 $850,138 $1,039,058 63190- 4020 T OF BRASHER $149,867 F 0.7586 $197,557 $88,901 $108,657 $67,440 $82,427 63190- 4022 T OF CANTON $353,260 F 0.1186 $2,978,583 $1,340,363 $1,638,221 $158,967 $194,293 63190- ,4024 T OF CLARE $1,322 F 0.0653 $20,245 $9,110 $11,135 $595 $727 63190- 4026 T OF CLIFTON '$418,952 F 1.0915 $383,831 $172,724 $211,107 $172,724 $246,228 63190- 4028 T OF COLTON $32,511 F 0.0791 $411,011 $184,955 $226,056 $14,630 $17,881 63190- 4030 T OF DEKALB $46,453 F 0.0828 $561,027 $252,462 $308,565 $20,904 $25,549 63190- 4032 T OF DEPEYSTER $134,320 F 0.9565 $140,429 $63,193 $77,236 $60,444 $73,876 63190- 4036 T OF FINE $757,965 S 1.0000 $757,965 $341,084 $416,881 $341,084 $416,881 63190- 4038 T OF FOWLER $184,321 F 0.3473 $530,726 $238,827 $291,899 $82,944 $101,377 63190- 4040 T OF GOUVERNEUR $1,663,211 F 1.0259 $1,621,221 $729,550 $891,672 $729,550 $933,661 63190- 4042 T OF HAMMOND $4,229 F 0.9519 $4,443 $1,999 $2,443 $1,903 $2,326 63190- 4044 T OF HERMON $3,977 F 0.2381 $16,703 $7,516 $9,187 $1,790 $2,187 63190- 4046 T OF HOPKINTON $40,859 S 1.0000 $40,859 $18,387 $22,472 $18,387 $22,472 63190- 4050 T OF LISBON $60,758 F 0.0846 $718,180 $323,181 $394,999 $27,341 $33,417 63190- 4052 T OF LOUISVILLE $458,891 S 1. 0000 $458,891 $206,501 $252,390 $206,501 $252,390 63190- 4054 T OF MACOMB $18,201 S 1. 0000 $18,201 $8,190 $10,011 $8,190 $10,011 63190- 4056 T OF MADRID $679,275 S 1.0000 $679,275 $305,674 $373,601 $305,674 $373,601 63190- 4058 T OF MASSENA $405,676 F 0.1334 $3,041,049 $1,368,472 $1,672,577 $182,554 $223,122 63190- 4060 T OF MORRISTOWN $755,529 S 1.0000 $755,529 $339,988 $415,541 $339,988 $415,541 63190- 4062 T OF NORFOLK $103,553 S 0.1000 $1,035,530 $465,989 $569,542 $46,599 $56,954 63190- 4064 T OF OSWEGATCHIE $947,094 S 1. 0000 $947,094 $426,192 $520,902 $426,192 $520,902 63190- 4066 T OF PARfSHVILLE $54,762 F 0.1033 $530,126 $238,557 $291,569 $24,643 $30,119 63190- 4068 T OF PIERCEFIELD $386,989 S 1 .0000 $386,989 $174,145 $212,844 $174,145 $212,844 ~ . NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 22 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = =::: =.:::::: a==:::::: = == == = = == == ===::: =:::: == == === == == == =:= =:::= = == == == === === == ==:== == == ==== = == == ==:== == = ==== == = = ==:== == == ==== == == ====1=== == === == ==::: = == 63190- 4070 T OF PIERREPONT $21,893 F 0.0552 $396,612 $178,476 $218,137 $9,852 $12,041 63190- 4072 T OF PITCAIRN $410,338 S 1.0000 $410,338 $184,652 $225,686 $184,652 $225,686 63190- 4074 T OF POTSDAM $850,251 F 0.2510 $3,387,454 $1,524,354 $1,863,100 $382,613 $467,638 63190- 4076 T OF ROSSIE $94,643 F 0.8827 $107,220 $48,249 $58,971 $42,589 $52,054 63190- 4078 T OF RUSSELL $20,078 F 0.6459 $31,085 $13,988 $17,097 $9,035 $11,043 63190- 4080 T OF STOCKHOLM $65,241 S 0.1000 $652,41 0 $293,585 $358,826 $29,358 $35,883 63190- 4082 T OF WADDINGTON $479,168 F 0.8523 $562,206 $252,993 $309,213 $215,626 $263,542 COUNTY OF SARATOGA 63190- 4110002 C OF MECHANICVILLE $1,040,028 F 1.1721 $887,320 $399,294 $488,026 $399,294 $640,734 63190- 4115012 C OF.SARATOGA SPR IN $284,390 F 0.0574 $4,954,530 $2,229,538 $2,724,991 $127,976 $156,415 63190- 4115022 C OF SARATOGASPR OU $265,210 F 0.0574 $4,620,383 $2,079,172 $2,541,211 $119,345 $145,866 63190- 4120 T OF BALLSTON $2,782,166 S 1.0000 $2,782,166 $1,251,975 $1,530,191 $1,251.975 $1,530,191 63190- 4122 T OF CHARLTON $1,020,196 S 1.0000 $1,020,196 $459,088 $561,108 $459,088 $561,108 63190- 4124 T OF CLIFTON PARK $5,892,170 F 0.5194 $11,344,186 $5,104,884 $6,239,302 $2,651,477 $3,240,694 63190- 4126 T OF CORINTH $127,323 F 0.7049 $180,626 $81.282 $99,344 $57,295 $70,028 63190- 4132 T OF GALWAY $1,461,270 F 1.0187 $1,434,446 $645,501 $788,945 $645,501 $815,769 63190- 4134 T OF GREENFIELD $1,451,550 F 0.4326 $3,355,409 $1,509,934 $1,845,475 $653,198 $798,353 63190- 4138 T OF HALFMOON $2,194,045 F 0.4567 $4,804,127 $2,161,857 $2,642,270 $987,320 $1,206,725 63190- 4140 T OF MALTA $3.857,747 S 1.0000 $3,857,747 $1,735,986 $2,121,761 $1,735,986 $2,121,761 63190- 4142 T OF MILTON $4,139,841 S 1.0000 $4,139,841 $1,862,928 $2,276,913 $1,862,928 $2,276,913 63190- 4144 T OF MOREAU $2,427,415 F 0.5373 $4,517,802 $2,033,011 $2,484,791 $1,092,337 $1,335,078 63190- 4146 T OF NORTHUMBERLAND $1,012,037 F 0.9458 $1,070,033 $481,515 $588,518 $455,417 $556,620 63190- 4148 T OF PROVIDENCE $146,785 F 0.4200 $349,488 $157,270 $192,218 $66,053 $80,732 63190- 4150 T OF SARATOGA $2,081,105 F 0.9498 $2,191,098 $985,994 $1,205,104 $936,497 $1,144,608 63190- 4152 T OF STILLWATER $2,382,490 F 0.9134 $2,608,375 $1,173,769 $1,434,606 $1,072,121 $1,310,370 63190- 4154 T OF WA TERFORD $943,532 F 0.5101 $1,849,700 $832,365 $1,017,335 $424,589 $518,943 63190- 4156 T OF WILTON $2,938,840 F 0.8160 $3,601,520 $1,620,684 $1,980,836 $1,322,478 $1,616,362 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 23 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate Assessment SBRPS Full Value Claimed Full Value Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment = = ==.= = = == == = = ==== ==== = = =:= = === = ===:= = == = = == = = = == = = = =:= = = === = = =:= = = == = == =:= = = == = = = =:= = === == = = = " NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 24 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = == == = = == = = = = == = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = == = = == = = = == = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = = = COUNTY OF SCHUYLER 63190- 4420 T OF CATHARINE $787 F 0.4308 $1,827 $822 $1,005 $354 $433 63190- 4422 T OF CAYUTA $66,387 F 0.5177 $128,234 $57,706 $70,529 $29,874 $36,513 63190- 4424 T OF DIX $1,408,687 F 0.9410 $1,497,011 $673,655 $823,356 $633,909 $774,778 63190- 4426 T OF HECTOR $2,593 T 0.8724 $2,972 $1,338 $1,635 $1,167 $1,426 63190- 4428 T OF MONTOUR $284,370 F 0.4383 $648,802 $291,961 $356,841 $127,967 $156,404 63190- 4430 T OF ORANGE $139,021 F 0.5202 $267,245 $120,260 $146,985 $62,559 $76,462 63190- 4432 T OF READING $203,467 F 0.4060 $501,150 $225,518 $275,633 $91,560 $111,907 63190- 4434 T OF TYRONE $11,451 F 0.4115 $27,827 $12,522 $15,305 $5,153 $6,298 COUNTY OF SENECA 63190- 4522 T OF FAYETTE : $625,447 S 1.0000 $625,447 $281,451 $343,996 $281,451 $343,996 63190- 4524 T OF JUNIUS $177,041 F 0.9492 $186,516 $83,932 $102,584 $79,668 $97,373 63190- 4530 T OF ROMULUS $28,356 S 1.0000 $28,356 $12,760 $15,596 $12,760 $15,596 63190- 4532 T OF SENECA FALLS $1,849,240 S 1 .0000 $1,849,240 $832,158 $1,017,082 $832,158 $1,017,082 63190- 4534 T OF TYRE $170,125 S 1.0000 $170,125 $76,556 $93,569 $76,556 $93,569 63190- 4536 T OF VARICK $220,463 S 1.0000 $220,463 $99,208 $121,255 $99,208 $121,255 63190- 4538 T OF WATERLOO $1,541,302 F 0.9606 $1,604,520 $722,034 $882,486 $693,586 $847,716 COUNTY OF STEUBEN 63190- 4620 T OF ADDISON $11,075 S 1.0000 $11,075 $4,984 $6,091 $4,984 $6,091 63190- 4622 T OF AVOCA $912,184 F 0.8985 $1,015,230 $456,853 $558,376 $410,483 $501,701 63190- 4624 T OF BATH $2,728,225 F 0.7923 $3,443,424 $1,549,541 $1,893,883 $1,227,701 $1,500,524 63190- 4626 T OF BRADFORD $38,052 F 0.1036 $367,297 $165,284 $202,014 $17,123 $20,929 63190- 4628 T OF CAMERON $48,252 F 0.0900 $536,133 $241,260 $294,873 $21,713 $26,539 63190- 4630 T OF CAMPBELL $40,586 F 0.0502 $808,486 $363,819 $444,667 $18,264 $22,322 63190- 4632 T OF CANISTEO $453,791 T 0.8096 $560,513 $252,231 $308,282 $204,206 $249,585 63190- 4634 T OF CATON $183,159 F 0.7948 $230,447 $103,701 $126,746 $82,422 $100,737 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 25 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = = == = = = = == = = = = = = = = = = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = == = = = = = = ::::: = = = = = =:= = = =::::: = = = =:= = = = = = = == =:= = = = = = = = = == = = = = = = = = = 63190- 4636 T OF COHOCTON $18,200 F 0.6569 $27,706 $1 2,468 $15,238 $8,190 $10,010 63190- 4638 T OF CORNING $2,096,444 S 1.0000 $2,096,444 $943,400 $1,153,044 $943,400 $1,153,044 63190- 4640 T OF DANSVILLE $436,196 S 1.0000 $436,196 $196,288 $239,908 $196,288 $239,908 63190- 4642 T OF ERWIN $354,010 F 0.1561 $2,267,841 $1,020,529 $1,247,313 $159,305 $194,706 63190- 4644 T OF FREMONT $191,785 F 0.7326 $261,787 $117,804 $143,983 $86,303 $105,482 63190- 4648 T OF HARTSVILLE $131,733 F 0.8274 $159,213 $71,646 $87,567 $59,280 $72,453 63190- 4650 T OF HORNBY $287,874 S 1.0000 $287,874 $129,543 $158,331 $129,543 $158,331 63190- 4652 T OF HORNELLSVILLE $1,356,846 F 1.0697 $1,268,436 $570,796 $697,640 $570,796 $786,050 63190- 4654 T OF HOWARD $440,730 S 1.0000 $440,730 $198,329 $242,402 $198,329 $242,402 63190- 4656 T OF JASPER $500 F 0.0621 $8,052 $3,623 $4,428 $225 $275 63190- .4658 T OF LINDLEY $13,377 T 0.0629 $212,671 $95,702 $116,969 $6,020 $7,357 63190- 4660 T OF PRA TTSBURG . $14,093 S 1.0000 $14,093 $6,342 $7,751 $6,342 $7,751 63190- 4664 T OF RATHBONE $4,312 F 0.1181 $36,511 $16,430 $20,081 $1,940 $2,372 63190- 4666 T OF THURSTON $12,578 F 0.0726 $173,251 $77,963 $95,288 $5,660 $6,918 63190- 4670 T OF TUSCARORA $3,085 F 0.0690 $44,710 $20,120 $24,591 $1,388 $1,697 63190- 4672 T OF URBANA $235,278 S 1.0000 $235,278 $105,875 $129,403 $105,875 $129,403 63190- 4676 T OF WAYNE $34,888 S 1.0000 $34,888 $15,700 $19,188 $15,700 $19,188 63190- 4680 T OF WHEELER $199,942 S 1.0000 $199,942 $89,974 $109,968 $89,974 $109,968 COUNTY OF SUFFOLK 63190- 4720 T OF BABYLON $1,733,084 T 0.0270 $64,188,296 $28,884,733 $35,303,563 $779,888 $953, 196 63190- 4724 T OF EAST HAMPTON $600,224 T 0.0266 $22,564,812 $10,154,165 $12,410,647 $270,101 $330,123 63190- 4730 T OF RIVERHEAD $7,788,357 F 0.3247 $23,986,317 $10,793,842 $13,192,474 $3,504,761 $4,283,596 63190- 4732 T OF SHELTER ISLAND $161,772 F 0.0411 $3,936,058 $1,771,226 $2,164,832 $72,797 $88,975 63190- 4734 T OF SMITHTOWN $1,304,901 F 0.0320 $40,778,156 $18,350,170 $22,427,986 $587,205 $717,696 63190 - 4736 T OF SOUTHAMPTON $2,131,035 F 0.0415 $51,350,241 $23,107,608 $28,242,633 $958,966 $1,172,069 63190- 4738 T OF SOUTHOLD $378,179 T 0.0276 $13,702,138 $6,165,962 $7,536,176 $170,181 $207,998 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 26 of 31 ID# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment == ==:= = ===== == == = = = ==== = =:======= = =:= = == = = == = = = === = = =:= = === = = = =:= = = == = = = =:== = == = == =:= = = == === = = COUNTY OF SULLIVAN 63190- 4820 T OF BETHEL $2,926,487 F 1 .0286 $2,845,117 $1,280,302 $1,564,814 $1,280,302 $1,646,185 63190- 4822 T OF CALLlCOON $1,216,902 S 1 .0000 $1,216,902 $547,606 $669,296 $547,606 $669,296 63190- 4824 T OF COCHECTON $581 ,707 F 1.1281 $515,652 $232,043 $283,609 $232,043 $349,664 63190- 4826 T OF DELAWARE $1,377,403 T 0.9954 $1,383,768 $622,696 $761,073 $619,831 $757,572 63190- 4828 T OF FALLSBURGH $8,266,952 F 0.9865 $8,380,083 $3,771,037 $4,609,046 $3,720,128 $4,546,824 63190- 4830 T OF FORESTBURG $136,922 F 0.1987 $689,089 $310,090 $378,999 $61,615 $75,307 63190- 4832 T OF FREMONT $700,624 S 1 .0000 $700,624 $315,281 $385,343 $315,281 $385,343 63190- ,4834 T OF HIGHLAND $33,311 T 1 . 1122 $29,951 $13,478 $16,473 $13,478 $19,833 63190- 4836 T, OF LIBERTY $6,171,300 S 1.0000 $6,171,300 $2,777,085 $3,394,215 $2,777,085 $3,394,215 63190- 4840 T OF MAMAKATING $386,010 T 0.4564 $845,771 $380,597 $465,174 $173,705 $212,306 63190- 4842 T OF NEVERSINK :$115,079 F 0.0846 $1,360,272 $612,122 $748,150 $51,786 $63,293 63190- 4844 T OF ROCKLAND $928,310 S 1.0000 $928,310 $417,740 $510,571 $417,740 $510,571 63190- 4846 T OF THOMPSON $10,225,120 S 1.0000 $10,225,120 $4,601,304 $5,623,816 $4,601,304 $5,623,816 COUNTY OF TIOGA 63190- 4920 T OF BARTON $203,744 F 0.1008 $2,021,270 $909,571 $1,111,698 $91,685 $112,059 63190- 4924 T OF CANDOR $9,181 F 0.0995 $92,271 $41,522 $50,749 $4,131 $5,050 63190- 4926 T OF NEWARK VALLEY $13,062 F 0.9889 $13,209 $5,944 $7,265 $5,878 $7,184 63190- 4928 T OF NICHOLS $284,565 F 0.3159 $900,807 $405,363 $495,444 $128,054 $156,511 63190- 4930 T OF OWEGO $346,485 T 0.0910 $3,807,527 $1,713,387 $2,094,140 $155,918 $190,567 63190- 4936 T OF TIOGA $182,317 F 0.1057 $1,724,853 $776,184 $948,669 $82,043 $100,274 COUNTY OF TOMPKINS 63190 - 5007002 C OF ITHACA $4,897,273 F 0.9206 $5,319,653 $2,393,844 $2,925,809 $2,203,773 $2,693,500 63190- 5020 T OF CAROLINE $18,619 F 0.9192 $20,256 $9,115 $11,141 $8,379 $10,240 63190- 5022 T OF DANBY $390,623 F 0.9612 $406,391 $182,876 $223,515 $175,780 $214,843 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 27 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = == == = = == = = = = == = = =:= = = == = = = = == = === = == = = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = === = = == = = = =:= = === = = = =:= = ===== = = = 63190- 5024 T OF DRYDEN $927,089 F 0.9622 $963,510 $433,579 $529,930 $417,190 $509,899 63190- 5026 T OF ENFIELD $469,512 F 1.0648 $440,939 $198,423 $242,517 $198,423 $271,089 63190- 5028 T OF GROTON $872,505 F 0.9139 $954,705 $429,617 $525,088 $392,627 $479,878 63190- 5030 T OF ITHACA $3,864,165 F 1.0124 $3,816,836 $1,717,576 $2,099,260 $1,717,576 $2,146,589 63190- 5032 T OF LANSING $2,730,817 F 1.0001 $2,730,544 $1,228,745 $1,501,799 $1,228,745 $1,502,072 63190- 5034 T OF NEWFIELD $1,500,762 F 0.9571 $1,568,031 $705,614 $862,417 $675,343 $825,419 63190- 5036 T OF ULYSSES $157,283 F 0.9934 $158,328 $71,248 $87,080 $70,777 $86,506 COUNTY OF ULSTER 63190- 5108002 C OF KINGSTON $5,314,565 S 0.5000 $10,629,130 $4,783,109 $5,846,022 $2,391,554 $2,923,011 63190- 5120 T,OF DENNING . $84,969 F 0.2945 $288,520 $129,834 $158,686 $38,236 $46,733 63190- 5122 T OF ESOPUS $1,736,714 F 0.2898 $5,992,802 $2,696,761 $3,296,041 $781,521 $955,193 63190- 5124 T OF GARDINER $1,120,632 F 0.5859 $1,912,668 $860,700 $1,051,967 $504,284 $616,348 63190- 5126 T OF HARDENBURGH $79,173 T 1. 1 017 $71,864 $32,339 $39,525 $32,339 $46,834 63190- 5128 T OF HURLEY $100,018 F 0.0435 $2,299,264 $1,034,669 $1,264,595 $45,008 $55,010 63190- 5130 T OF KINGSTON $13,894 F 0.0253 $549,170 $247,126 $302,043 $6,252 $7,642 63190- 5132 T OF LLOYD $2,673,624 S 0.5000 $5,347,248 $2,406,262 $2,940,986 $1,203,131 $1,470,493 63190- 5134 T OF MARBLETOWN $3,523,772 S 1.0000 $3,523,772 $1,585,697 $1,938,075 $1,585,697 $1,938,075 63190- 5136 T OF MARLBOROUGH $1,593,565 F 0.5381 $2,961,466 $1,332,660 $1,628,806 $717,104 $876,461 63190- 5138 T OF NEW PAL 12 $2,116,752 S 0.5000 $4,233,504 $1,905,077 $2,328,427 $952,538 $1,164,214 63190- 5140 T OF OLIVE $46,544 F 0.0170 $2,737,882 $1,232,047 $1,505,835 $20,945 $25,599 63190- 5142 T OF PLATTEKILL $1,107,436 F 0.3542 $3,126,584 $1,406,963 $1,719,621 $498,346 $609,090 63190- 5144 T OF ROCHESTER $1,513,398 F 0.3905 $3,875,539 $1,743,993 $2,131,546 $681,029 $832,369 63190- 5146 T OF ROSENDALE $2,625,793 T 1 .0150 $2,586,988 $1,164,145 $1,422,843 $1,164,145 $1,461,648 63190- 5148 T OF SAUGERTIES $7,571,668 S 1 .0000 $7,571,668 $3,407,251 $4,164,417 $3,407,251 $4,164,417 63190- 5150 T OF SHAN OAKEN $1,199,332 F 0.4819 $2,488,757 $1,119,941 $1,368,816 $539,699 $659,633 63190- 5152 T OF SHAWANGUNK $1,837 F 0.3528 $5,207 $2,343 $2,864 $827 $1,010 63190- 5154 T OF ULSTER $192,085 F 0.0248 $7,745,363 $3,485,413 $4,259,950 $86,438 $105,647 63190- 5156 T OF WAWARSING $199,473 F 0.0320 $6,233,531 $2,805,089 $3,428,442 $89,763 $109,710 63190- 5158 T OF WOODSTOCK $963,794 T 0.2604 $3,701,206 $1,665,543 $2,035,663 $433,707 $530,087 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 28 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment === =:======= == == =========:=== === = ==:== ==== == == = === = = =:=== ======:= ==== = ===:=== == = == =:===== = = === COUNTY OF WARREN 63190- 5205002 C OF GLENS FALLS $4,879,997 F 0.9940 $4,909,454 $2,209,254 $2,700,200 $2,195,999 $2,683,998 63190- 5220 T OF BOLTON $1,155,344 T 0.9886 $1,168,667 $525,900 $642,767 $519,905 $635,439 63190- 5222 T OF LAKE GEORGE $2,035,354 T 0.9583 $2,123,922 $955,765 $1,168,157 $915,909 $1,119,445 63190- 5224 T OF CHESTER $797,791 T 0.8323 $958,538 $431,342 $527,196 $359,006 $438,785 63190- 5226 T OF HAGUE $460,510 F 1 .0574 $435,512 $195,980 $239,531 $195.980 $264,530 63190- 5230 T OF JOHNSBURG $280 F 0.0470 $5.957 $2,681 $3,277 $126 $154 63190- 5232 T OF LAKE LUZERNE $29,046 T 0.7432 $39,082 $17,587 $21,495 $13,071 $15,975 63190- ,5234 T OF QUEENSBURY $6,630,097 T 1 . 1484 $5,773,334 $2,598,000 $3,175,334 $2,598,000 $4,032,097 63190- 5238 T OF THURMAN $379,322 S 1.0000 $379,322 $170,695 $208,627 $170,695 $208,627 63190- 5240 T OF 'WARRENSBURG $2,070,544 S 1 .0000 $2,070,544 $931,745 $1,138.799 $931,745 $1.138,799 COUNTY OF WASHINGTON 63190- 5320 T OF ARGYLE $1,358,861 F 0.9178 $1.480,563 $666,253 $814,310 $611,487 $747.374 63190- 5322 T OF CAMBRIDGE $706,670 F 0.9679 $730,106 $328,548 $401,559 $318,002 $388,669 63190- 5324 T OF DRESDEN $72,579 F 0.0821 $884,032 $397,814 $486,217 $32,661 $39,918 63190- 5326 T OF EASTON $40,774 F 0.0436 $935,183 $420,833 $514,351 $18,348 $22,426 63190- 5328 T OF FORT ANN $1.216,008 F 1.0683 $1,138,265 $512,219 $626,045 $512.219 $703,789 63190- 5330 T OF FORT EDWARD $1,746,524 S 1 .0000 $1.746,524 $785,936 $960,588 $785,936 $960,588 63190- 5332 T OF GRANVILLE $1,821,744 F 0.9876 $1,844,617 $830,078 $1,014,539 $819,785 $1,001,959 63190- 5334 T OF GREENWICH $1,021.953 F 0.7545 $1,354,477 $609,515 $744,962 $459,879 $562,074 63190- 5336 T OF HAMPTON $36,651 F 0.0572 $640,752 $288,338 $352,413 $16,493 $20,158 63190- 5338 T OF HARTFORD $88,678 F 0.1062 $835.009 $375,754 $459,255 $39,905 $48,773 63190- 5340 T OF HEBRON $555,377 F 0.8845 $627,899 $282,555 $345,345 $249,920 $305,457 63190- 5342 T OF JACKSON $504,615 F 0.5868 $859.944 $386,975 $472,969 $227,077 $277,538 63190- 5344 T OF KINGSBURY $2,568,498 T 0.8077 $3,180,015 $1,431,007 $1.749,008 $1,155,824 $1,412,674 63190- 5346 T OF PUTNAM $626,260 F 0.9910 $631,948 $284,376 $347,571 $281,817 $344,443 63190- 5348 T OF SALEM $637,276 F 0.5132 $1,241.769 $558,796 $682,973 $286,774 $350,502 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 29 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = == == = = == = = = = === = =:= = = == = = = =:= = == = = == = = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:== = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = = = 63190- 5350 T OF WHITE CREEK $48,484 F 0.0358 $1,354,302 $609,436 $744,866 $21,818 $26,666 63190- 5352 T OF WHITEHALL $111,791 F 0.0562 $1,989,164 $895,124 $1,094,040 $50,306 $61,485 COUNTY OF WAYNE 63190- 5420 T OF ARCADIA $3,257,096 S 1.0000 $3,257,096 $1,465,693 $1,791,403 $1,465,693 $1,791,403 63190- 5422 T OF BUTLER $431,003 S 1.0000 $431,003 $193,951 $237,052 $193,951 $237,052 63190- 5424 T OF GALEN $680,910 S 1.0000 $680,910 $306,410 $374,501 $306,410 $374,501 63190- 5426 T OF HURON $793,674 S 1.0000 $793,674 $357,153 $436,521 $357,153 $436,521 63190- 5428 T OF LYONS $1,337,443 S 1.0000 $1,337,443 $601,849 $735,594 $601,849 $735,594 63190- ' 5430 T OF MACEDON $?,695,123 S 1.0000 $2,695,123 $1,212,805 $1,482,318 $1,212,805 $1,482,318 63190- 5432 T OF MARION $903,237 S 1.0000 $903,237 $406,457 $496,780 $406,457 $496,780 63190- 5434 T OF ONTARIO $2,109,957 S 1.0000 $2,109,957 $949,481 $1,160,476 $949,481 $1,160,476 63190- 5436 T OF PALMYRA $1,461,462 F 0.9697 $1,507,128 $678,208 $828,920 $657,658 $803,804 63190- 5438 T OF ROSE $566,597 S 1.0000 $566,597 $254,969 $311,628 $254,969 $311,628 63190- 5442 T OF SODUS $2,248,301 S 1.0000 $2,248,301 $1,011,735 $1,236,566 $1,011,735 $1,236,566 63190- 5444 T OF WALWORTH $1,266,633 S 1.0000 $1,266,633 $569,985 $696,648 $569,985 $696,648 63190- 5446 T OF WILLIAMSON $1,620,876 F 1 .0090 $1,606,418 $722,888 $883,530 $722,888 $897,988 63190- 5448 T OF WOLCOTT $1,035,649 S 1. 0000 $1,035,649 $466,042 $569,607 $466,042 $569,607 COUNTY OF WESTCHESTER 63190- 5508002 C OF MOUNT VERNON $1,323,419 T 0.0793 $16,688,764 $7,509,944 $9,178,820 $595,539 $727,880 63190- 5510002 C OF NEW ROCHELLE $1,747,754 T 0.0843 $20,732,550 $9,329,648 $11,402,903 $786,489 $961,265 63190- 5512002 C OF PEEKSKILL $878,038 T 0.0831 $10,566,041 $4,754,718 $5,811,323 $395,117 $482,921 63190- 5514002 C OF RYE $537,792 T 0.0671 $8,014,784 $3,606,653 $4,408,131 $242,006 $295,786 63190- 5520 T OF BEDFORD $2,292,481 T 0.1932 $11,865,844 $5,339,630 $6,526,214 $1,031,616 $1,260,865 63190- 5522 T OF CORTLANDT $774,047 T 0.0436 $17,753,372 $7,989,017 $9,764,354 $348,321 $425,726 63190 - 5524 T OF EASTCHESTER $747,162 T 0.0436 $17,136,743 $7,711,534 $9,425,209 $336,223 $410,939 63190- 5526 T OF GREENBURGH $3,582,798 T 0.0935 $38,318,695 $17,243,413 $21,075,282 $1,612,259 $1,970,539 63190 - 5528 T OF HAFlRISON $795,613 T 0.0488 $16,303,545 $7,336,595 $8,966,950 $358,026 $437,587 , NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 30 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate SBRPS Claimed Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment Full Value Full Value Assessment = = = =:= = = ==== = = == = = = = == == =.= = = == = = = =:= = == = = == = = = == = = = =:== === = = = =:= = = == = == =:= = = == = = = =.== = === = = == 63190- 5530 T OF LEWISBORO $1,380,998 T 0.2122 $6,508,002 $2,928,601 $3,579,401 $621 ,449 $759,549 63190- 5532 T OF MAMARONECK $562,861 F 0.0495 $11,370,929 $5,116,918 $6,254,011 $253,287 $309,574 63190- 5534 T OF MOUNT PLEASANT $745,989 T 0.0383 $19,477,520 $8,764,884 $10,712,636 $335,695 $410,294 63190- 5536 T OF NEW CASTLE $4,047,151 T 0.4354 $9,295,248 $4,182,862 $5,112,386 $1,821,218 $2,225,933 63190- 5538 T OF NORTH CASTLE $426,064 T 0.0555 $7,676,829 $3,454,573 $4,222,256 $191,729 $234,335 63190- 5540 T OF NORTH SALEM $1,089,420 T 0.2071 $5,260,357 $2,367,161 $2,893,197 $490,239 $599,181 63190- 5542 T OF OSSINING $1,302,384 T 0.1048 $12,427,328 $5,592,298 $6,835,031 $586,073 $716,311 63190- 5544 T OF PELHAM $248,947 F 0.0613 $4,061,126 $1,827,507 $2,233,619 $112,026 $136,921 63190- 5546 T OF POUND RIDGE $710,889 F 0.2784 $2,553,481 $1,149,066 $1,404,414 $319,900 $390,989 63190- 5548 T OF RYE $734,665 T 0.0443 $16,583,860 $7,462,737 $9,121,123 $330,599 $404,066 63190- . 5550 T OF SCARSDALE $577,509 T 0.0461 $12,527,310 $5,637,290 $6,890,021 $259,879 $317,630 63190- 5552 T OF SOMERS $2,178,468 T 0.2240 $9,725,304 $4,376,387 $5,348,917 $980,311 $1,198,157 63190- 5554 T OF YORKTOWN $887,223 T 0.0496 $17,887,560 $8,049,402 $9,838,158 $399,250 $487,973 63190- 5556 T OF MOUNT KISCO $2,284,075 F 0.4250 $5,374,294 $2,418,432 $2,955,862 $1,027,834 $1,256,241 COUNTY OF WYOMING 63190- 5620 T OF ARCADE $1,169,495 F 0.8684 $1,346,724 $606,026 $740,698 $526,273 $643,222 63190- 5622 T OF ATTICA $785,157 S 1.0000 $785,157 $353,321 $431,836 $353,321 $431,836 63190- 5624 T OF BENNINGTON $361,894 F 0.8488 $426,360 $191,862 $234,498 $162,852 $199,042 63190- 5630 T OF EAGLE $352,858 S 1.0000 $352,858 $158,786 $194,072 $158,786 $194,072 63190- 5632 T OF GAINESVILLE $40,796 F 1 .0885 $37,479 $16,866 $20,614 $16,866 $23,930 63190- 5636 T OF JAVA $646,330 F 0.9273 $697,002 $313,651 $383,351 $290,849 $355,482 63190- 5638 T OF MIDDLEBURY $3,629 F 0.6954 $5,219 $2,348 $2,870 $1,633 $1,996 63190- 5640 T OF ORANGEVILLE $8,892 T 0.0776 $114,588 $51,564 $63,023 $4,001 $4,891 63190- 5644 T OF PIKE $39,366 F 0.9525 $41,329 $18,598 $22,731 $17,715 $21,651 63190- 5646 T OF SHELDON $456,818 F 0.8372 $545,650 $245,542 $300,107 $205,568 $251,250 63190- 5650 T OF WETHERSFIELD $21,377 F 0.0887 $241,003 $108,452 $132,552 $9,620 $11,757 .' 4 NEW YORK TELEPHONE SPECIAL FRANCHISE ASSESSMENTS APPENDIX A Page 31 of 31 10# Name Tentative Code Rate Assessment SBRPS Full Value Claimed Full Value Overvaluation Claimed Overassessment Assessment = = = =:= = = == == = = == = = = = === = =:= = = == = = = =:= = == = = == = = = == = = = =:= = = = = = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = =:= = = == = = = = = COUNTY OF YATES 63190- 5720 T OF BARRINGTON $74,238 F 0.6649 $111,653 $50,244 $61,409 $33,407 $40,831 63190- 5722 T OF BENTON $291,105 S 1.0000 $291,105 $130,997 $160,108 $130,997 $160,108 63190- 5726 T OF JERUSALEM $935,448 S 1.0000 $935,448 $420,952 $514,496 $420,952 $514,496 63190- 5730 T OF MILO $877,199 F 0.5060 $1,733,595 $780,118 $953,477 $394,740 $482,459 63190- 5732 T OF POTTER $5,858 F 0.8366 $7,002 $3,151 $3,851 $2,636 $3,222 63190- 5734 T OF STARKEY $37,272 F 0.7811 $47,717 $21,473 $26,245 $16,772 $20,500 63190- 5736 T OF TORREY $289,555 F 0.6739 $429,671 $193,352 $236,319 $130,300 $159,255 I ' "