The URL can be used to link to this page

Cardenia, P.A & V.I Cover Pa!!~&lndex for RPTL Petition for Cardenia_ (135601-6158-14-478413-0000) This package includes: 1. RPTL 730 Petition 4 pages 2. Sampling of external articles from 2002 - 2007 Supporting errors in MJW revaluations 9 pages 3. Original RP-524 15 pages 4. RP-525 2 pages 5. Matrix & Back Up data on SF going from 1724 to 2222 11 pages 6. Due Diligence & Foils trying to obtain data 6 pages 7. Work sheet on How my assessment compares to closest fit 8 pages If a formal evaluation (assessment) is required, please advise. This was not required last time (2002). Insurance & other data was sufficient. We believe that extrapolating a FMV based on correct square footage could be enough. MLJ Consulting & Town acknowledge error; but have not been able to correct this problem to date. We are asking that if we are found to be correct, that access parcel & Access.org databases be corrected to prevent future problems. If a formal assessment is required or needed as further evidence, I will spend the additional money but will ask to have it reimbursed along with costs associated with generating, copying & filing this RPTL 730. :~: R. :~:: -0,-, Z :~_ :2;~~ i ~i::~ oR I (.!'{ IVl---L. RPTl.. 730' jJCS ~()O (R&v. March~ 2~CT} PETmOtJ SMALL CLAtMSA$SeSSM!NT ReVIEW fNCOOI'../nes ourSIDeNEWYGRKCI'TY (0118 patill:)n p~cratcel) ~ :3 PARI 1 GENERAL IN::ORMA nON slJPR.EM~ COURT, COUNTY OF!.':):";, \"" c iot r: .$ ~ '_"_~~'_ f. FjJ1""'~. . 'i'. .S.LfSLf C3~t~at# 2. A$$cSCI~tJJ~ Q,.' ~ c. .~ L;>r) A.et i l;l4""14.$ '" " 0;:-.. '::'.~ .. f" 5 .. (::) ~. .'It." 3. T G'-Y 1 )2.. (1ft "1- 1. .3l.Jq I ~c (IF c' ;):). 11' t;. c)L-';('J Ii> _ 7 ~/ v... ~r~~ \"3>. 'Z"tJ$ ~'f . _ ..._.............l........._.................... Q 1? A. !:;A VI- c:../~:rt~ ,'Dr]; IV ; A. ,5'8.~ IV ~i.' tv\ f:-~ (~-,a ,,-4 UIF . ....... JV ~:' l1-f'lw-I';'?J! ~~ I-:;":,~',) A,"/ / ,,__ 6 )'t? Oateol !'in$! l;lqmplati:JIl and ruing of all.Si!:sSMettHto{l {a) T ~~lfJ {b) Exempl amoun: 4. {c} la)iabt~ ali5eSSiH~ value {3tl--3bj Oa~.l)Hmllg (Ot malltngltiaUllon ..~~ 5. Name of owner t31 OWf1!'lrs of prn~$tW: ?~st O~lc~ A<\jjr.s,$.: " T(llBflMM #: ~ t{~:Y Z.<; '1 ~11--7'~~ 6. It ~pp~ab!$,nam.. and addr'!ss ct tl!pfeSiOm,ati\ia 070ymer. if (;tprOSi)n~ati"$ is filIngeppljeatil:lO: (Owner fl'HJst Cl)mpfel~ Oeslgna~iOn.o1~~pres.ent;stiY$ secMn.) reIEtphtme#~ ,....-- /' If,; /.-; ~..- 7. Oe$enptiDn 9fpIUpttn)'a~ ~tBppears on ,he as'S~ssmentrQH. r;5'tcc I Te:< Ma~ ~ 6Jsn.:S Steibll 1'1 Slo:1: 'f7B4f/31.ot (l'qt5(t,5 8. \'(lcation of prop130Y {Eitrst,:t, load. hit\fw,'ay flumt>et. l3lld ct,. ;,own or Vma~~) 5'8, IU fL ME S ;f:"j1... )~\lG . .. IVY l(i A tr r IJ E~ &>f( S t A.U. .s.l 1'7.<~~., ..... ,~ /' G/ r'\'-'\-" ) fl,t;.\J \... ~\)G 1 , 1\)\)1 ,...I~ C\..E.t\\Z \O~.. 117/~T L 73C' .<J r '-t.:'.. . l';~' 4: /1' i ...... ;.....- '.- ,.: ~;::.::;....,. ... .~ ::- .- PART II GROUNDS FOR PETITION ~sses~~~~~~~:'~~~~~~ton the COi!1Pii:r~?i/:le~',~~ t~,e [~~1, ~t-i~~~S:;;7;~fvt'fL ';-<;( 2.. Exem'pt'amovnt~ if ar:y . . VI .'~. . _ 3, Taxable asses?mer:t 11 :L.'to/.; ~D 0 (.. · ( t.~ ,. \ S t4 OW ~t1.3 (i~~e..N) ) ~.~. 6, C,ALCULAT10N OF EQUALIZED \JAL\JE AND MA-XIMUM REDUCTION tN ASSESSI:JENT 1, [1 Property is NOT in a special assessing unit ASSESSED VALUE ... EQU..t.UZA TION Rt:.. TE = EQUALIZED VALUE ..., t{... Property IS in a specci<;l assessing u!",it. ASSESSED \tALUE .;.. CLASS ONE RA.TIO = EQUALIZED VALUE 3. [ Ii th~EQttALIZED V..ti,L.U'E e;~ceeds. $45(:,000, enter lhe ASSES,SED \/?\LUE. f}Sre: . t,AlJlt;p~y the ASSESSEOV,t..L.UE D)< Er,ter the result her6: The result is tne maximum !otalasseSSme:11 request reductio,,! aiicN;,able. ;.;. .25 I" <.... r L U~,lEQUAL ASSESSt.AENT: The total assessme:1t is t;neque!( because the property is a's~essed at 'a.hi~her . percentage of (1.1:1 (market) "alue than (Ch;1Ck one). .' ~~L <rM,.5',.jA/,,~ ~'.Jih;l ,.t.~ H (a) the averag~ of .d other property'on ths<'lss~ssmentro!l. or t~"'L'I'~ f( f 6211 ~..tM { J (b) tne average of r~.s;denUafprGpert.Y en the assessment roll.. f!.. ~t. 730, ,:111"*,,! L:.{~CS(. . ij"1f.\Q~'~A-~ij);~t,iL . 'Full (mar"'elJ value, of property: $ '~lirb-9-0 . ~-4sJ.a.~til./;) e!' Ct~~w,'t...cJ Z?/~ Basedo~.cne or mcreo"f the fO~!O\l!;,ih~:;, peht;oner beGeves.th~s p~-operty s;nculd be:as~es:sed ~a-t. ~% nffull (market) value:. . ' . , , . The latest, State equaEz.atiCh rate fi)r the assess;f1o unit in wh;~h theprcperty is locat.ed (enler latest equalization rate: _ %), ~. . , j. 1he latest. residsntia!assessmenl rago for the assess~ng unit irfwhich the property is located (enter H:~sjdent~<il assessment ratio: %\ ~.3. pq A sample af mar~~et values of recst.t sa:es prices Me assessments of compat3bleresidential ~ ' .propertles..on '.'ihic!.' petitioner relies f,or ~b!€d,ion. C;st parcels en a Sep3ra(~ sneet 3!lCa...1,aCh). 4. { 1 $,aternents of U"H; assessor or other local OfilC!2l (nEt ptoperty h.asbeen placeo on the roll a~ . ~:.:,. -~.Ii,r~~ , IN Rf"5'l.tf, rID{;>/r1~,.1)/!L APPf/1:1/,l.... .?.I'rtc-73~.. .. . . . PehtH:.:nef behaves the tots' ,assessment Sr:lCiU!:j be reavc.eo tQ $ Zw,/Jft: I n~s amount may not be less Inan the total asse~sment amount ind;Ca!.ed in SectiM ,t", (1), ~g~\.;-whi~h~..~ i~''9r.eau~r_ . t . 2, D, EXCESSI\i2 ASSESSMENT: 1 9'1' Tne lotal assessed value exceeds the full (m.arket) value of the property,' .. T cia! assessed vallis of property: $-3-'i 1/ () DC. . . . . . (;,.'i.1 1 Complainant behe".'Es the tots; a5-,;;essme~,t shoulC be reduced to a fun vabe of s;}J~1?_(J Attach list of parcels upon which ccmplahar1t reiies for oojecti':Jn. jf applicable. ______-:' This amount may not be ies~ than lheamo\.Jnt indicate,jln Sectio'l A (1), c.~ef:;;;n B ('9-). \' 2. r 1 The taxable assessed va~we lsexcessh:e because of the denial of all or a portion ofa partial _ exemption. Specify exempUon: $ _ (e ,g.. a'Yed; clergy, veterans, ere). Amount of exemption cI3:med: $ ,Amount granted, ~fa;,;y: $__-__ Tt-lis amount may not be greater than the amount lndica~~d in A (2). . I(application for exemption was filed, attach a cOP:'- of applicat;cn tc. this petmGt'l. Hr:!"JI i rrc /V'/.h ',1 7).4- r77 t.l '5:: L'b (~'V j~ J[/)lft. {;( H7trL-..' /;() A $' /1./ ((,s t:..t. f/ G.:'~t I I tl.) l':N""'- J If" ,2~ ~ 4()' 4~. . ,~i,. .. <I , . ..Lt '" . . . I ........ ~. ?il!<..$M. ''':''~' I /f.Y;A! ~7 h. ?l,),.Q)i,..~'" 11t-{....fj ~/'LX~f!.. dl>~.~>'~. <<.,wet: ,L~~, ....t..O ,"i .... ..l.15AA. ..' ~~ Co.' 1/ Z*, tJ /. S-~' ., ; "'V",","~'.'---4ooI".' "'. ~ .. s '"'. . -/',,;._. :,""." , . ..iI..... ;"",. -.:, _....... " . W,. . ..:.. ~'.. ~..... .. ..""\.!. ~.\.Ji"'{.... '.$''1; ,,~.,. ,~~ ~..t..,." C.l.~~:J....'~~'1,w->"",..t .A..x~ ,.-l...,(..(;.v(...4<.,~<(..~ 4'..-.f...$"'I( <'z .~ z ?cs ....e..V~1V ..,..:-c.<.,. 5;' r 1? f' 'TL .- '73 () /0/ t:'/" .z.. 0(' "I _. ~NFGRtiA Ti5?N TO 'SU?FC)~T TH{FU~~C (t-,LA.Ri\En.:',ALUE: C.l.A.hlcr7 :. p<J :-,urC~u$e pne:: <::1 pfQ~:e.:1y .~ .. ( <1 J ~f 0 L r-H~. nf -..,"-1-_~ - I <-'I' .',.., ......G'.'O;;;' '.1.; ~U..~...~:d:.:)t: " , ~f .1) ~::.:; Re~ahcnsh~p;: ~f a'n:/~,behveei~' :~t:n€r .and p~Jr~:;1~aser .- ii)crrtr:;, " .:.. H pr~:;.pe:1:: r::a.s' b-€et:, recenEy cdJersd -t.~f safe-: ;/;/t'1eJ18:1d fer ho':,~? h::r~g: i.-1;~:.....v CJf€ted: ,;;$~: i'!1~I pr;c:~e: S .._____. " .....). ~} It pr.(;:pertl has been recenHy apprafsed; \'1he:1 ~tt:t: ~} 'U)Oz.. . 8yWhom: TCi({.l)) /1.<:l<;(!'$.:f.LI,e t:.. Pu. r:;:ic~e cd ac'pr3;s~L ';-" vi..:.;.;.. '1?""-':;'<::: 'r'...,. -'.J "'" Y k,t'L;:"'}i;,l':>.IW( , . ,,' "J' l' .'..', v' ,.... ....;.I""ji' ~...!>""'r""'" ~'-t:,,)'7"'v~' I ,t.,C'r'trai:;e,jvalu<?: S :MV-li.fb .&00 CCPU::..i:-''''P ..... f.:t Y., ~ . . ... ... j <' n-'.::----.:.::,"..--...:.... .-~.~.....................:c.....:.; .....:a..:~....'!... O"l-..} O....~4.~.4<l~~~,"'d C)-Q 0 ;::>", lOO f:.'3:, 5 .i:1j7[QV'~4C{."CHJnN~K...,;J-;;~. .. If ,-'~;"\,;1"9S have beef': recenli/ remcce)f,;G. c<:<:,,;s!ruc:ad. crad~itio;:a. :r;'1prCvemeGlsrr~Gi?. S:<K~: ~{ <E.;:: rr em<)<J'C led; c:.~~n s trur;te :j", Da!:9 .~>:lT;rr::,enced.~ 4. crac:j:ti:;r:s n~a:je: A/P 1:J.}.)ptr?"C,'iVs:.' ~;~'-ty 1-1'(;/,.1'[ {).~~..~ c~.~(~...b=-~~e,-i'~.'...- ' " .-.........~_._.......~.____.~. ... "" ~iJ/~; f- UJ{+-& !( niA$a,f7~~~"L..' ;::;:WStrl> .- -- /j. ." it. "2 (',.'2U ~T'? t Z t) ,~. t....i Am:;)unt ftg ',',hich lour o:c<certv is inSwre;j. :; >r -:~...:;.. . t"Z' I ~''l /"'c'.:;e.'./ _ l .;' 'To'''> ""." 4i"- 'F.. . ... '., ;- . ... ~'-. .. '" . /~"""t 6 to/ft.:.... ,;; . H ff,j.f:.r' r...~mecf ~n?\..ir<!nc~ cDmpany an.;) p';J:1C.Y !1Uffiaer.., (K..1.t/f(;''''/5 '.. "',. I . "''''<r74''((JJ'&~" 't.)rrH ./.,4..;., 'f> t4-b(>,.~::- i!f f.; ~~ t: ;3 .; . .... . [Xl Purcnas'.':l j,)(:ce d .::::o:-nparable prooeny(ies)recenn.., sold: S 2 t.....fSS t2..tl.J."'P (7:YZ;"-jO..'l') . ..1: ., .,., \' .;-:. to;: ~ ".,-~..._.--- '. ~~....4i.t.t.) /~~tA$'>'\..!.fi~..v '~'\....L..~ _{..~'",*~:X ,.A""~hY~~.r . ,.i .' ~~(!..i~k~ ~.<,"~,"'l:.la.fj<J t:~ ~-)\..P"'~:d"~_~~~;~i~ ..e~: L2./py;, O'()c:;' ..__' ".---, \ I I J I ~ ; ! i ! ~ SGHOQL D!S..T..:.[~.:,... ..(.(,?i1.1?/:?(...1!....(.z.. {;' f.~ ... ....~....................... ..........................................................:-..4::.... The problem. I beli~'el is dUlt the dfita tl'eatedJ cntetel! (ill R.sres~ment database) ~md used by MJW Congultin~ was erratic, incollslncnt and uftelt gYfissly incorrect (S.ee 3ilach~d "dipl>ings" n>:glu'ding MJW 1l1aCeUrlldes & re\'l1.luaiO:n problems). III our case, tbe total square ft)(Jt was .\tnd 5tiIl is 1724 SF. Thi~ numberi.s l"cfleded in the t.6wn asseliffOI"$ card dah1 in my file, It reflects the home sbe prior to 1m)' r{'c\'aluatiolls. During he l"e\:aluation the sqUlu'" footrige wentfmm 1724 to 2222 for no reason; tlO c.hanges were mad~ tobome. Tbe incorrect datIl was fouud amI broug.bt to tbeattendon f}f both the to'Wll a~se:s:sor a.nd MJW Con~'Ulting, MJ\V was to (:Ol'rc~t dataha~e aud town w,ts to use nf'\~dMa llefOl~e timuizing IL'is:eument I."(lle~. Tbe data was ('hanged ill tbe town assessors dlua card (~ee copy af tbeir ca.rd); tmd altbougif origin aU)' COl"t'ectecl in 'MJW dlltabluet it was set back to the incorrect "'allie, Tbe atttu:ht':u matrix that shows status bcfo~ 1001 through 2007. This sheet sbows tbatsCJttal~ footage was 17Z4 before any l'e\'alu3tlo-n and durh:lg the re\'aluatinn \leU raised &, towered se\'eraJ times but not c.orrerted prlorto locking in tbe final usessnlent data, Since the e.r-ro.r InsqtulrC footage was nevel' ~of'l'eeted. This mllde thf cakuluted as!ressmellt ~uso incorrect {substantially higher). The tiltm ft!8e1lS0r lowered the cb5C!iSment SS.O=fto (from S354iJOO to S349,000). Tbis r:epreSetltlla decease of at>Qut 1.$l%, Tbe a{~tual error in >>quare fOOtage is 498 SF:. This rneanttnat alUl<lugh the. Sf wtn.i down b)' 22%, the assessment reducthm was onlv 1..5% '? C:cs:L ~S . -.... ~ 6. PART 111 LISTING OF T.t..,):'jNG DISTRiCTS 1-, COUNTY: '--i~) ~ ~r c i~ 'r/ S S LJ fi-P tlM t; t7R II Names. of Taxlr'lQ Districts; 2~ TO\:\N: . ';./;LLl~~G E: ~ ) .. 1 t:.'J /1 ;. ,> .., ....- "1-- (.-..... J-r, f /ll....CtC::: 7(.s ("':0" ~".,'1 .. ,...:. f 1'1"'/.../..' ,. . .....iI" ,< 1. 7r'Pr L .-'73D /')/. tf:7 .3 <t tl RPTL no PART IV DESIGNATION OF REPRESENTATIVe OF FILE PETITION ." ". I, ", as petitioner (or officer thereof)heteby designate toacta~y representati\le in any aod all proce-edings beforelhe Small Claims Assessment Review of the Supreme Court in -......, County for purposes Offaviewing the assessment of my real property as it appears em 'Ie vesr assessment roll of (asseasing unit) '. ""'. "', ',Signature of Owner ('Sl: officer thereof) ',. "'-, "f......... Date -.,"-. ",. " PART V EllGIBIUTYAND CERTIFICATION I certify that (8) V"'Tha owner has previously filed a complaint required for administrative review of assessments. . (b) VThe ptopert.y is improved by a one, two orlhree family, owner~occupied residential structure used ax-elusively for residential purposes, and is no! a condominium; except a condominium designated as Class 1 in Nassau County or as <homestead' Class In an approved assassing unit. {c} 0he requested assessment isnQllower than the assessment requesledon the complaint tiled wilh the assessor orthe6oard of Assessment Review. {d} IV",lf the equalized value of the properly exceeds S450,OOO, tha requested assessment teduc;tion doe.s not exceed 25 percent of the assessed value. {e} V'lnave maHed. by cerlifiad mail, retum receipt requesled. or. delivered ~n person, within tan days after Ihe day of filing this pelition with the County Clerk. Qfl9 (1} copy Of this petitton to the clerk o11he assessing unit. or iflhere by no such clerk, then to the officer who performs ., the customary duties of that officiaL (f) , 1 have mailed by regulaI' mail within 10 (ten) days after the fjJlog of the Pelition with the County Clerk one {1} copy of the Petmon to: (a) The clerk of the school distriet(st within which the real property is tocated, or if lhere be no. clerk or the name ~nd address cannot DEl obtained. then toal,.ustee, (b) Tha treasurer of tile county in which lheproperty is loeated, and (c) The assessor, or, the chairman of the board of assessors I certify that all s!atem~nts made 00 this application are true lOlnd correctto tl1ebest Of my knOWledge and belief, and llJnderstand that the making ot any willfol false statememof material fact herein win subject me to the provisions of the Penal law relevant to t~EJ..~~N~ B!)a..filing ~f false instruments. ~""";""";{// ./ ",~, "J ", " " 'i J" -,,-' t ,",~" ",.,,.. ,.,7,!- -'-'. .":i"t.-< ""1 ,.. .. .,,-, '.-...... -- ._~_.... .....~. Signature of owner or representative (-NOTE: You are not raquiredlo file with Ihe Buffalo City School District, the Rochester City School District, the Syracuse City School District or the Yonkers City School District.) ~.~ ..~"" . _7 ~ Cover Page SA~IPLINGOF E,XTERNAL i\.RTICLES supporting errors in l\'fJW Consulting Revaluation. Errors From. 2000 - tbrough 2007 Article 1- Town of Nortb East freezes\lalues Feb. 2007 (2 pages) Town terminates 1\IJ\V Consulting Contract.. Audit shows 15%. error rate Article 2 - Angry Spackenkillresidents protest town evaluation 1\'fay 2006 (1 page) Town Board draws large c~()wdtopr()test & critique workofMJ\V Consulting 3,400 aJreadyprotested...,. Town assessor says it to late to haft revaluation Article 3 ... R)fe Town Republican Committee Press Release Oct. 2005 (4 pages) MJ\V Consulting ,,'ork rejected by Patterson, Kent & South East Putnam Valley town board sees l\fJ\V values & threw~lJW & numbers out Errors in square footage, number of rooms, land valuation MJW failed to follow industry (IAAO) guidelines MJW specializes in CMIA based statistical modeling "if data is wrong ..estimate wrong Article 4: Bellefair ~Iay 2004 (1 page) Town l't.sidents discover gross errors in new valuations Dim~ulty speaking with some:nne at l\rlJ\V Consulting (at 866 number given) Correction not made (my complaint) by lVIJ\V or BAR e\'en after error pointed out Assessment Articles Page 1 of2 Assessment Articles 2.../~ ~/2, 11'('19 Artidesthat have been published in localpublicati( ~--::~~~~:~;~".,::~;G~~,:-~:~,~,',~~~5~~~~;~~:~~~~~~~~~~~;~~:fr-~'~~~~ 1 l .. , " 'f' .. 1 :.:::::::..:.",",'" " {" ~ Tuesday, February 27,2007 North East freezes values Reassessments controversial B)~ Michael \Vo)'ton Poughkeepsie JOllmal MR.LERTON - Propeny assessments in the Tow11 of North East will be frozen for 2007, and a new assessor ",iU most likely takeover next year. . The town decided to discontinue doing annual updates to the property values for the current year, Supervisor David Sherman said. <; Aside from basic roll maintenance, like adding new properties or documenting renovations, new values ",in not be developed," he said. At. a recent etin, the tow ennioated the contract with MJW Consulting, Inc. The Queens-based firm. !l.lli!.. ,~ beenp':~~ reassess" all tow~:..E.roE!rties and do lVe annual up'._ate~_~!!~~__~!.,.~~~;P.!~a.~U~?JE.~~,,~~JQQ n.eoo~nt ,~--~1.Y.alue,_- _._..._....--.__.-~~.- Two4pdates were don~,",- John, Watch. president of rvmv, could not immediately be reached for COmment. 1Y1JW has done revaluations for numerous toWns in Dutchess County. Outcries from some North East residents who felt the assessments were unfair led the board to hire a cOlllqltant _. -.-.... ..' ". - -, . '. . .':., - ....,;.....:..-.-.......-- ,..,' .. ... ....-..;.--.....~..._'"'.._............. -~....-.... to revtew ~MJW; 5 worK:"" ------.~.~,-~------.........-...-.".-^...,. .. .-.................... --- .. .....-..-...-....... .~ert~1Je!t~fM~A..Q~sllt!i!l.8,~4 V.l!lu~!io~) an. Erie County firm, ~~~.~.~~~rr~~.,~p.S~~~,t~?r:~t~l.1.~~~,,~ipg ~~valuatmg an commer~~al.p!..o~rtY.!!!d 'y~atln~aU P!S!e,~~~~~d cares to ensure the mfonnatlon IS cOrrect. "'--- -_.~......o;o........-....w......~...............~__...;'9I;..;>m~x~;:;:;~:~;o::.~.~.;:~::-::'":'~~~e-;.:. - -- 9 T",^-~"tI;.) StrelI estimated about 85 percent of all data collected by MJW was accurate, //;'$"';36 .c...,~.......,') An additional data coHeetor position was added by the town to help correct the remaining data. Because its property will not be at 100 percent market value, the town '\\iU not be eligible for state aid, For the 2006 ta.x roU, North East received $8,830~ Shemlan said. MJW received $3,200 per annuai update completed. Assessor departing Adding to the uncertainty of the to\\'11 , s property values, Assessor Jon Barrett announced he wiJJ not seek re- http://\\-'ww.netaxrevolt ,orglAssessment_ ArticlesIPoughk~psie _JournaJlNonh,_EastJreezes _values... 8/9/2007 Assessment Articles Page 2of2 election in November. Barrett is also the appointed assessor for the TO\l.m of Beekman. He said .Monday he\\-'as uncertain whether be would continue as assessor for Beekman when his six~yearappointment ends in October. Shennan is working on the assumption there will be a new person in the North East position come January. He said Barrett has been cooperating with the board to solve as many of the problems as possible before he leaves office. "There is a shared commitment to move fon.vardas best we canto accomplish this," Shennan said. l\1idlael fVoyton can be reached at l1fWOVIOll@p:ougl.lkeepsiejoumalcol!!, http://\\'\\w.netaxtevolt.orgfAssessment_Anic!esfPoUghkeepsie...J ournallNorth _ Eascfreezes_yalues... 8/9/2007 Angry Residents Protest Town Revaluation By Cara Patterson tfp.f! 2 C>. 0 0.- c- To say SpackenkiJI residents were unhappy '"\lith their prope.rty assessments would be puttingii mildly. While many peopJ.e are seeing a change in the assessed values of their Tmvn of Poughkeepsie homes. To\\'l1 Board members Todd Tancredi (R-6th Ward) and Stephan Krakower (R-5th \V.ard) said Vlednesday that protests from SpackenkiH residents~ .in particular, led them to believe the entire neighborhood may have heen over-'assessed. "I don't know that the numbers are correct yet," said Krakower. Residents certainly didn't seem to think 50. A ?\1ay 2 IO\vn Board meeting drew a l~Ege cro~~ whQJ?fQtested ". ,Jhe vall!.eli and critiqued the work of the outside consultant MJ~:YS;9nsuHjl!8.:==-~ . Anma Bakhru said SpackenkHl numbers "make absolutely no sense.:"Bakhru said her home had been appraised at 5389,000 in December 2006. Her ongmal assessment came in at $550,000. After she protestedt it was lowered to $450:000, but Bakru feels that is stHl too high. "None of the comps came inat that level)" she said. ,....Krak~~in~fl with ~~n~~nts in caU.in.Kror the rev~ua!!o~to beha1te~e revRlugtiQtlslmuld.Jill.lb~ !~~~...?P!..~~..~~.,p.:?~2.se we~1l corre~t It m theJm~:' he said. However, to\vn Assessor Kat.hleen Taber~said that under state law. it~~.~<4 too !~~\!9_ halt the !ev~u~!~E; While some residents said values in the entire Spackenkill neighborhood should be lowered, Taber said that w'as not going to happen. Any changes must be on a case-by-case basis, she said. Residents must now fill out a grievanceform available in tbe assessor's oft1c.e. Over the next three weeks, Taber's oIfrce IS granttfig""StipUlatlons; or agreenfenfSio change the .asses;e]1'alue. tothose she believes qualif.y based on grievance fonus and accompanying documentation. On Grievance Day, ~1ay 22, the. to\\'ll will begin fonnalreview heann.12s. The office\\rill have extended hours on several days this month: check ..... '," . ,.."". '.' , 01. '.:'. .......--____..._....'.......... v.-'ww,townofpoughkeepsle.comfOr a sche.duie-:-.......w................_.......................-..._...~......._..........-_..- Those who have already protested and \\tho are to receive a revised assessmentwiU be notified shortly; 3,400 letters were to be mailed May 3. ,- ~&~~ Before angry residents took the microphone, John Warch of!v1J\V Consulting attempted unsuccessfully to preempt concerns. "\Ve're here to air our vi ews," audience members called out http://v."'W'W.theweeklybeat.netl2007/05/04/poutownreval. html 8/912007 PREf:S REl,EASE FOR IMMEDIATE PUBLICATION RYE TOWN Rt:PtJBLICAN (:OMITTKI~ P.O. Bux 883 Port C"ester~ New Vat 16~";~ Page 1 of4 For"immediate release P",R,...ns.'s..,...RE.LE.ASE .. .'........... ..............., , """", ....-. _.~ .,..~--"" ....' ,- ~~ , ' ~ ~ber 10, 2005 ~/ -..~.._...,.-.-~...;.~._.~ Topic: The T,'utb Exposed about Rye Town's Revaln3tionP,'oject The following report on the revaluation of Rye Townp.'operties has been resec'lrehed and compiled by the RepI.Wicafl (andidates ror Rye Town Council .Jost.~ph Carvin and William Villanova.. Ttae (onclusion of tI.isrt~port is that' tbe Town Board did not p.'ollcrly hire tbe company tbatcondllded' the Ueval,andthattbe revaluation is seriously "awed. " In the Vnited States, our local government property tax system is based on the principle that the amount of tax paid should depend on the value of property owned. )n this system it is of fundamcntal importance that the value of property is accurately assessed as it is the assessment proooss. that detemlineshow muchyoll pay in taxes. 'nlcreforc the integrity ofthc assessmentproc.essis essential to the healthy tunctioningoflocal government. Regrettably, the Town (.lfRye Hoard mismanaged the revaluation ()f our properties in the same way it. has mismanaged all Town atTain~ for over a decade. The Town of Rye Board used the same practices it has become known for -" lack of transparency, followed by no bid contracts issued to finns of questionable quality that. overcharge thr their work andthert make campaign contributions to the Town Board's political parties. Indeed, it. is hard tl) imagine a worse case scenario. The Town of Rye Board, with no prior study and fbr no clear reason, reversed their earlier policy and decided "go it alone" and Imwe lbrwardwith the Town of Rye Reval without waiting for the rest ofWesrchester County. 'l1lCY then awarded a$I.3 million NQJllIl contract to a little known Jirm,...MJW{;OtlSldti!:!gJust months after MJW Consulting had its'work thrown Ollt by each ()j''thc'lbur towns hi~tnam COuntyit.hadOe.enJiiFJtO advise.. . ..-.....-.......... ,..._~_._...........n~.._~_......,n... """.....----. '"._~....._AQit.' I .".........,.. . .~ -~.~ -----..".. The MJ~ contract signed in September, 2002, included a clause that stated that if there were a political change in the Town of Rye, the contract would becomeruny aue-alfd"payabh'r"nra-Criieans that the Town of Rye would have had to pay for the revsl whet.her or not they wanted it. Quid pro quo? ,MJWCollsuJtiog made $10,500 in campaign contributions to the Town of Rye Board's political parties and also hired a Councilman's son to work for them. MJW Consulting specializes in CAMA based (Computer Assisted Mass Appraisal) statistical revaluations with mucb of the work being done in Arizona. Thl~ choice ofthis firm detennined thatthc Town of Rye reval would he hased on statistical analysis rather than physical inspections of our hOllles. However, as anyone who has ever worked witheornputermodeling knows "ifY(lu put galbage ill you will get garbage out." It seems to me thatthish~ exactly what happened here in the Town ('}fRye. When the Town of Rye first took up the issue of revaluation, they passed a resolution stating that they would implementa revaluation provided that http://www.ryetowngop.com/t~ress%20Release%202005%20Reval.htm 8/9/2007 PRESS RELEASE FOR lMMEOIATE PUBLICATION Page 2 of 4 80% of the other towns and cities in Westchester did the same. For some reason that has never been made clear. thc Town of Rye abandolledthis prudent policy, As a businessman, when ( nrst began to look more closely at the reval. the tirst question lasked was: where is the study? Where is the analysis that states the problem and proposed solution '? ~111e Town of Rye never conducted any kind of in-depth study analyzing the costs. bencfit~. andprobablc impact ()fthe extraordinarily complex and difficult revaluation process. It did, however, convene a Revaluation Committee that met On six oocasions in 2001. When that committee was first convened, Supervisor Morabito statcd that thc committee was set up to examine the advantages and disadvantages ora town wide revaluation with thegoaf of "'drafting a working document to lake to the public", Unfortunately, that document describing the advantages and disadvantages was never produced. At the last meeting of the Reval Committeeotl October 29, 20ot, Mr. Morabito infomlcd the commltteethatMJW had bt.'Cn hin..d and that he had spoken with County officials and lCR1]led that there would lo+bc no countywide revaJuatkm". When the Town Board leamed that the County would not move forward with reval, they should have abandoned the Roval projt.'Ct as per the resolution they had passed. Again, for reasons never made clear, the Town decided to move forward witb the Revaluation, In fact, the Town implemented the RevaI without ever having passed a resolution approving it. It is surprising that the State Ollicc of Real Property Services did not insist on a.resolution being passed. The process is further mired in secrecy because the Town Board never putout: a publicadvcrtiscment or request tor proposal (RFP)Jor contractors to bid to provide the revaluation work. Fora process as complcxand ditlteult as this one, any government intent on achieving faimcss and equity would have put out a formal RF.P inviting major national finns and local 110115 to bid. Tht)se fions W0111d present their credentiaJs, references and valuation methodoloh-Y' (fthe TOW. n of Rye Boa.rd had. d. O.'..lC d~.i.S..t hey ,nt.i.S.h .lh. av. e found......Ol~t th~t: each o. f~<: fOU. r towns il1l~t l~nam co. un.t.y tha. 1 WOrked. Wi.th.. MJ. W. · COO$\l/ting oJ' ~ rejected MJW's work. ~JW Consultmg adVIsed th~ towns.Qn lreJl<.f1ng,an~llstJ!(tetxcy~!uatw.n.s..the~.hgc.t~H"?Inp-l~t~.....Jh~.~.sessors of each of ~he ,th:~~~(~~~~_':..~~at~~~.s.~~:...~~.m.~~~..~.~~~~!~'.'..~~~~~~.~!le ~~.!~~..~~. W~~V!.~e<! by !"IJ~.:f~~~~.lting. ~ ....W....hm~..........~.._.'....h.. The foutthtown, Putnam Valley. ha~not yctgone thr~sl~tLon. .Ml.W...cansultingilf~paroo,.the..nunlb.~~.!!!4hc:Jjd..a.more..cQmpr.~h~'O.$.~Y~ .tCY-ah!~!ion [9!J~~m. ..~.~~!:!..!~.~..!9,wn$p.~n!~.~.~r~.W.~~~Jh~.E.mpb~~,.1lifYl!!!~.liui~4.,..... Wb.eu..!he.:rQwn.B.Q.~!~~.~~~~~~.y.C!.l.!!~~..pr9.YidL~..b}:.MlW, they. threw the numbers ana MJW out. The Journal News of AprIl 6,2002 reported the followmg: .-" .."-"'-----..........._u......._.~._._,,_..__-__._._._.......-............""~:u.--.....-.-............_-"....".u-................-...._...J'IV....".._._.~..............,"";,."...~~_.....,_........"...".....-..-_........".,A.,....._"""'"............._n................................._.........,............. t:' . '''I.'h.C rea s.sess." :lc'ntsdre.w.. hun.drcd.S. of complaints. ~ron.l hon;l. eow. n.c f.S about. inflated. propelly V.alUC.>S.b.. ". Sed. o~ deScnptiv. e data .I!l. s{)meca.~es. ~).' ~.. .:i.~~.""-.,( Q $guare. footaa~~!)d num~~.~~~~.W..Q!lg~ .In oth.gJ!!ft~ns.:es~ V:~~.~:ld~. sl~'~w~.?7.~r..P.?~.?~~..~~..Y~.~~..~..~.f.~~.~.~S..~lJY. ~:;',.. ~<<< b~ildable~r~~rt~ged. k)F Sound familiar? I have encountered numerous people in the Town of Rye who expressed similar complaints. l11e best one was a Rye Brook resident who said be was told he had b~)th a swimmiIlg pool and tennis court in the backyard when he bad neither. The big problem with no bid contnlcts is they create suspicion. not trust. In thiscasc the suspicion seems well founded. In Putnam Valh...y, MJW http://www.ryctowJlg()p.com/Prcss%20Re1ea~e%202005%20Reva. ,him 8/9/2001 PRESS RELEASE FOR IMMEDIATE PUBLICATION Page 3 of 4 Consulting was paid $ 31.000 for the work it did on 6,000 parcels ofland. The Town of Rye Board hired MIWConsulting to a NO BID contract of $ J.3 million to value 1 j ,000 para."Is of land.. presume the scopes of work were different. However the big question for the Town Uoard is. was the scope of work $ 1.27 million diOerent? Worse, the MJW Consulting contract included a NO LOSE clause. Pat RineHo and William Villanova ran against the reval i02oo3. If they had won they would not have moved forward with the roval proposed by Mr. Morabito. Hnwever. the contract signed by the Rye Town Board would have had the taxpayers of the Town of Rye pay for the MJW contract even if Ms. RineHo and Mr. Villanova had won the election. From page 24 of tile MIW Ccmsulting contract: "If the tennination of this contract is the result of a political change in the current governmental structure of the Town of Ryc~ the contractor shall be ptlid in full for the services contracted for." What does this say about our Town democracy? Docs this mean that tbe 2003 election was a sham? . ,~~hen . examined MJW Con~l!ting' s~~d~tials'~......:rh$t.tb.Q..rL!E~!~~_~~~!Qf.~cJiQ..t'!.~L~~amj~eMJ\V':,~9m9~ntiJ!ls......~~_~~Hh~^min.u.t~~.g.cthe (Q.wn meetings. i lapp-ears thqUh.~ Town 4~~~~<?,[Q~f!tl~J,","MLRC!YIJon.k.e.,.ey.~ll.l.ate.d.,M1W.~,s..~de!1tii\l~,., It is not dear why the Town would abdicate that momentous responsibility to Mr. Jonke, Mr. Jonke, who hails from Putnam County, most certainly must have known of MJW's problems in his County. Why then would he approve aNO BID contract for a company that he knew had hadsigniticant and serious problems in his area? Why would he push for revaluation in the TownnfRyewhen he is fighting revaluation in Cannel? Yes, that's right Camlelistheonly Town in Putnam County with a full tiOle assessor that has not done a revaluation to this day!!! To muddy the waters even more, according to our calculation M:r. Jonke was paid $83,445 in 2003 for advisory work douein the Town of Rye.. Presumably some ofth()se monies were paid to oversee and review the work of the very linn he had recomOlended, -~ .. .. .. .. f The T.own Board's decision to ~jre MJW Consulting to a NO 1llDcontract not only fundamentally compromised the int.egrity of the project; it also Uompromised the type of valuation methodology that would be used. Jt Acc~~ing t~l the ind. u~try !ext hO?k publish~d b~ the Intemati~ln~1 A~s~cia.tion of A sse!)sing {)mce~s (IA. . ..1\0) in. Properly 1I!P~a6~1l1.())t4 A.''Ses.'_ . " 1 Adnllm,"1ralwn..~ phYSical mspcct)~~.~~l.~,,~.~~~.~~~.~~oper1!_es lS~~~ to a...~~cess.ful R:~~luat~~};,.- M S'w -- .'g.~ vr:t1 { ~>'Z JjP T ;'A re.al pf()perty asst!~smellt .'iJwtem I11m.t have all inventory of altreal proper/ie...; their Ilse;\~ and their physical and JiJcalkmt.lJ charClcteri.~!it,"s. U,e ;l1ve.\tmenl in making this im'elllory call be 75 percent qfthe cost of reappraisal .... ; Appraisers rely Oil .,'uch data to estimate vallie. {f)he daltl are wrollg. thelillal e.wi1llale may be wrong. l1u$ is certainly true ill a (;Ofl1pllter-assi.vted ._~ ;nass It[J/Jinis(fl (C'AA1A) syslem. a~' the compuiei- ha~ no (Jut...ii'k7tJu,w7eilifc'iij't'hej')r(JPer(:V;iiiiglwift!iiii.>d. "ud market CQlldilifJ11.(;. ... ./ , MJW Consulting spedalizcspreci~ly i~ t~!!..~L\M.A bJ~s~~~.~sti~tmode!;!n!Uyj.th.mucl1.Q[tht.~Qr.~..~~iI!~.~o~~~.Ari7.ona_,uptb~ately ~ for US, what was necac<lwa:ntphysrcarrcvaluation, not a statisticalrevalu8l1on. The last time a reval had'6een done 10 the Town of Rye wa:fffi......;; ~ ~~n..._....._"'--..._,,_ ~....;,...;-_~"..)oo---~ -.........--_..............;0.-...;..0"""'___.............--.,...,,:---.;.. ____.. bttp:/lwww.ryetowngop.com/Press%20Release%202005%20Revaf.htm 8/9/2007 . PRESS RELEASE FOR lMME01ATE l>lJBLJCATION Page 4 of 4 ..J.967. Clearly~ data coIloction and tbe physicalinspccrion of people's homes.. wben none had been done for 35 years, was a nL'CeSsary ingredient to ensure that fairness and equity in the reval process were achieved. Again the indust:ry textbook supports this analysis: Requirements/or i1llerj(Jr ill.~pections vtJl}'. 11111ewer comlll1l11ilies where COllSlrllCliOIl j.~'ftlir/.y ,wandaI'd l}lf.!rtt is usua/{v lillle variation in interior,,; features (!{ the !louse, Howel'er, in ()Ider t:01l1mlJflitieswith predfJ/nifl(tlely ()ldt.~r houses, often the critical characteri.\1it.:.-. '!ffec/iug va/ue(lre ill:~'ide the hOllse. The data collector cannot de/ermine the e.xtetli (?fdeterionllifm or renovatioN withmtt gaillingentrQm;;e. " While the intellectual support fur phys~cal inspections is overwhelming, this requirement is easily understood. Would you buy a Immewithout having seen the inside ofthchouse? How then can you value a home without having seen the inside? Clearly, the Rye Town Board does not take either its constituents or its responsibilities seriously. That is not new. Only this time, their callous disregard tor even a modicum of propriety has impacted every home in our community in a direct and fundamental way. . Over the course of the Ia..;! 2 months [have knocked on close to l,OOQ..daorsjo.thiscommunity. [have yet to find anyone that told me that the reval P!.~~~-.~.as 1~i31i(f~"]!fa~f"lpav~n~e~ri.-g?Od.'poopre;nara'wofking pe~pJe,.p;;piewh()'ilave'~aiinrunY"pat,rfllelr' i~x;s'for"ovei..lfire{td'ecaaes~'len me thattht.j' can no longer afford ltl hve Ul thlS community. When I mentton the rcval, people gnmace and shake dlClf heads. Iff had any sense that thereval process had been fair and equitable then it would be easier to accept these grimaces and faces of despair. HowevCf) I have absolutely no confidence whatsoever that faimessand equity W'clS achieved. Just hecause Me Morabito says this process was fair and equitable does not mean it was t'air and equitable, The ovCtWhcJming impression that] have come aWdY with is that this pmcess was wholly unfair. Regrettably~ now the Town of Rye and alllocaJ governments in our community really do bavea serious problem. Now) the very integrity of all local government has been undermined by a Town Board that launched a process that was patently unfair and inequitable. http://www.ryetowngop.cmil/J>ressO/020Releasc%202005%20Reval.htm 819/2007 Tax Revaluation Alarming and Error.. Prone ""..'~Y:JY(). .... .... ,./'....1 Lf..... . ., ., . ...) .*"'&w., L ...t~ LtO tiJ t{,)., t fl,h,"'.<i:.t t:. . ~'<<<<<<';<W:<<<<';~"''';';'<<Y;';';';':':':;~ In interviewing man:r of the residents ofBelleFair~ it is ob\ioustbat fc\\"are happy with the resultsof'the revaluation of Ollt hQllles, The Ijst'~fcQlllPIain(S includes some of the fOlI9W.W,g,:f.tQJn.Jl1Q~Q.;~.Qpl~.}.ypph(lyedjscovercd gross er- ~~~....~~,.,~~~..'.~~~~t.~~~~.:::~.Sh...~,;....."". . ... ................................................,.,.,..,.,.'......,.......;"",."...;......,.,..""."...,';'.'"...'."',.,.,.,....,.,;",.;.;...".,.....,.,,,."...:.....;, I) . A second floor, where there isn>t one ~#'<' 2) Additional bedrooms that do not exist Lw":"':'.'. 3) Additional bathrooms that do not exist ~,~:<,:<<,"'... Also listed as a compJaintwas the difficulty ofgettUlgan appointment to speak \vith some<'lTIC (A1JW Conslllting:866-814-7114) or the fact that phone calls had not been r.eturned. Another complaint mentioned that infonnation on a given home was not changed by the Boanl OfRc\iew. even after an error was pointed out by ahomeo\"\'l1er. \~Vhi1e some people have bad some success and had their YaluatiOll lowered, others have found the appeal process frustrating and non-productive. kIany have been shocked by what they consider to be very high valuations~ and almost everyone is apprehensive about the effect oCtile rC\7aJuations on their taxes. Gary Zuckerman and other members oftne Village's Assistance Task Force~ speakjng at a meeting on Thursday, Afay 6th at the Senior Center, claimed that the revaluation numbers were not going to be used for reassessment oftases. The bottOm line seems to be tbat if-you stiUhavea complaint aoouf)"our reyalua- tion, you have trom June 1-15 to file a grieytJnce with the Board of Re\iew. I; .~r' j '._~)';"''': ,. .' .T '~'~~:;'O;~ ~. BEF(JRE THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIE\V fOR COMPLAINT ON REAL PROFERT\" ASSESS?HENT FOR 10 9 ~ I tJ'<" j':)...t>;;:~ f .N. rC l<'it"~;' t"",,:_ r":. .~.. ;~. ,-.~, "'-,."'. _.' ";,;._ {c-ity ~ ~a.~n",:'ili':a:ge'or-::;c.c.n ~Y! PART ONE: GENER.i\L INFOR\IATION (GenEra: h:lJrm::ttiC1~ and f~Jt.t-..ctf.o"<s.hr contp!etb~g 1his /orrnaie ccmialr:.ed it.f'JrmF..;.l' -524-Inr) 1 N'a."'e a''''; tel...",!.. ""',,..... ;: ".<. . ..~., _'\ .. l:.... ..-u 'i<-i"'UV~." 'AU. OJ. Uy,n....d:3.1 V"""l. ~'-tL.''''h. ...'\ ~. iC.~"" -,.t. "vI fA);:;/ ~,:",.'",'J -,..r. Lh ~ ~.... ~ Cl. ~.,..,~... :<C _ !:.,:~ ~"~'I"' ~<..-:,," ,.... -'"'{ /l/) ':~:. /:......:.1 ...". L~../"^,f'./( O.c::~' /-,.,':1 /'....1- . ". )' ~ . , y,'l / ~.'.'..'.',,-~.~.......,.,<-._.:;.;.' (t;:.:.~.~..,..',~.':;~..i,;,:: l?:::'1' S~\,. .:'l~~<'" ,,) ;<',w . m~' 1. Mliling Addresso[ o~+\~nerr:;) ~';-"~:.\ /') ";"'''('') , }~..!i' .f"" ..,....;. ~';~......~ '\.....:-.y~::u<' ):>f 1.... ,:. ~~ t.....{.:l fNl'/)\:=""4.'<::r 6'ft .S: .n .. ," . x>...'..f;..'~....:.,:,.~l",~... ..:;~ It.:...::t~~. -c. (".. ~ .*:::: ;:..:.~.::- A~' \.i" ,'it.~~ l _'~ .: .... i~;).:::Ji.~~.t:t ~;;. Da~..;' no. - . .t.';.~~nlrtg,':n.Q. ., ") .........; .....:. .,"; ;:l::::l1:: .,.S .~~l~ ::~:;:.... .,,".,:: .':';';';';' .f .;;....l ~:::;:. j. Nam~, addres,; and telephone no. of reoresent.uive of owner, ., .' . ,"k." c.'' . _ _ (if apphcabie,compkre Pa'rt Four on p~ge 4.) ~,,,,,,,,,,~';";":4- ".,.,.~"'. .#,.~ " if rept:e5;~.ntati\'e is filittg:app1icstiot1. .../ ~'J 4v' ,: .',.... /",,-- X i''Y .' "~' ..;>.~ ",;0;;" ~.:;:-...;.. 4. Prt~pe:tty location . -') .5. .f:) l!)sA'Yi.I ,S'treet.. i~.dd're:ss /1".t't{:,';Sll'j(j ;:;::J l:J oJ . :~;:~ &t.)i}' Pi~/~/;(j: i('^X'j'; ViHag~ (ifari)') .........""'-....... ,'''. t" .J' .-::< .:.':;?::t:.,~'.:~:.'~.(.i~'~t~~::'~":!j;"^.::.;~S. ...".,~ (;, , #.."".:. if r'l.:..~j ',.;. r A..:f-.."'-.....;: , , t:~..//~~::t..#::::~,f;:::;:::.t,:,: :(::;,~:.4..:../;(.$.: (:it:'1~lr o;;;,"~n ?y./:~<//>/i:::;/.{::/ f:~t'it?l .z::, School District C{)Urlt)~ , .... Properrf idem:it1cation (see tax biH or assessment raH) Tax map number Qr secticrJbkd:/lot /""") C" / ,:'\1. ~..:'.: (.-.. l > : ,. ,...,) F.., ~,. t -.-' ..... _...~ .... . ~ I C."'.1 -I. Li_, Li..'" (C) .,...../ b I r ...... '? '.(:") 71 ~~"2' :<<......\....{} l) /.- ,......~ .', "{. :(, ...... ..... ,<.. -~".;....." '.' 'V""-' :.... '.',' Type o fproperty: Residence ~=s:..;,../ x., / -.~. Farm. Vacant land Commerc131 Industria! Other De~cription: ~ ..~.,-"J !!v ;::~; t., ....:".:.. .It..,. ~~.....l.(:../;;; .~~. ?/' .. ~ ~/~~:.tl:~:;:; 'r~/ iY'" ...,...:.:::,....~.'..;..! '.. . ~~.:.;.;.;. ....;. ..:. .... :...;....... ;:". '~:'.. .:.;..." '. . .' . . . . :.;;. A.)sessed vaIu{> 3pp.;:aring em the as~eSsment mil: }.. '~', .", . .~ .HCl. k( Ii'....;.., P i'\ h ~ <J,:...:(,.:.i:4:I.,:;,.4'\,:~: t~.f,;'.::b.:.'}:{.4f'. J: Total:$ ..;;J'\ ...ll\ ,\4........... l.....,~. .... ., .. .". . . ... ''1'" ,,;.},",:.':'. '.:.:..:.~:. ,..~....:::.:"'l~l' ~~. f:i:J1".l i;(',~1:}<,:t.,:<<.:qS ti;';"', . ,. ,~ ~ -r \", Pnyperty O'NMf'S estimate of current full market va ke. of'p!';Jperty (se~ 1':~rt})Yb 0n p~ge 2) S <:;......,::'.i:. <:: r,. ::.,., .::>:0./ '::-"{:.::... 0;:.,.... "," ;::' ~. "'. t ".. ,. i~: ?<~~~~~t:~:,::.:': &6' If 6 Land .s .l~'t/ \.-. F'\ ~" W;~. 'j '" .,...:..,l'),.. t:..~ .(i~:;;;:~:l .,$'. /j. /.....?>:;~;f<:,; /li:' /:~) .,,<o:::),{; ... 1.6~:;:I::r ~('" ~;d./ ~~)~f~G.:J~' ~.... (i.J. "'/'$: ~:::c> {/ t.::>'i~t. 1}>t..1':,(.ll~~... [<';'>8 <,~ i(t, .._l ""..,.. 'L PA.RT T\VO: INFOfu\Li-\. TION NECESSARY TO DtTER.\UNE VALUE OF PROPERTY (rf ad:d~t1{)r~a~ exptanati.-::.n or d(;;.c.umentacic~n is r,eGe,:z.5-ary ~ plelse. a~t3;'ch.) bform,nwn tc- $:.lPp:;rt the value .)f pr<::;perty daimed in F:::rt On~, nem '"! i::omoiete one Qr more)" 1. ~ ~~u'r-~" -'" -,-.. -.::" ........., - #,'\, r...l~.~_ Ol.......... .~.~ Dr..,o~..."... ~ ,. ,..4. <I . . ~ .-.. .. ," '." -'. .... . ' . '... .. .. d_ .. _. .. _ _ .. //'" .j"'~ j .../ "".-:-;'--" ....~ '<";-:'.' S ____.f iii'':;! l-. v. Tenns: I 9 ~ "N;Y'" J.-'';- .:;;,~~'"\ a [late .ofpurc.ha~-e: Cash Ccnt:"J-=t l)tb"r {:.>'.....:~ to'.;'! ",",,'...H__, ~ _"~'""" :.-..:..-;:....... Ii t. · >r"( . '/t';JI^~"'" '<:,.;~:~:.. ;""" 'R:elatii~r;.~hi.p bet'~":ie.e:nseiler a!1d 'p~u,r~~'f:lase.r fD:.ltent-chi!d. in- L:t~CiS, , , . ~.... ' , . ~ ''''. su::-nn.g3.. et:;; 'j; d. Personal prcperty, if :lr,y. inciuded iF: purcha,.;e PIke (fl.lmitt.~e, H'ves!Ock, etc.; attKh Est a.nd s:a1.zs mx re<:e1pt).' c:. (.H?1'A f;';} <:1" i~~\~~) A-&"(c~.; A'-?'~\(:':6:! r;' ?t-.:.. /,1< ., ..;.... Pr(~perty has b~en r-ecentl:? offen~d for sale (attach :::opy Dfhsting agreement, ifany); \Vhen an.a for h,:>w' it>ng: H.o"~v offered: i~~5~:iI'~ g: pr1C z:: $. ___ Propett}-~ ha,s. be~n r.~:,ent]~( ~p.t:'rai'sed. (attacrl copy)~ \V'net1.. By \\n1om: PurpO$e ~::f af'pr3.lsaI: ~ np...<;-~p..4 ~;r'-3J1".Q,- S .:. ""~" ....""'~.......:..~ , \,;lo:,oi.olo-....,. _ < ~, D ., . ., 'l..r' , . d _.L escnptlonor-any ,:>uhwjng~ or lmpr0Vi:me11}~.!o.P:~<, on con~!r;.i:tivn and pres<:nt corrdition: /lJor<~h~:"'" t;t,~:~:~' f. l the property':. ~;1 ~:r~>' ~;", in~ludh1gyear of ., . . ,. :;:.......,,,.o,.?..} ~) t:~;.-l:~:t f~:.;;/ f-'/'''.. , ^. . .. ),;;: - Buildings have been recently remodeled, constructed or additi:)na1 imprQvement~ nUde: Cost $ Date Started D. C ,.. ate ompere-a: Complainant sbe:uld submi.t construction cost det,i.ils where available 6. - Property is im:ome produci g ~e.g.)~aped or rented), comm~ro.:ial or inJ:..rstrialproperty and the ;:.;:;.rnplainant is preD.ued to pre. t.4etaff~.;;iAnt~:H:mJtion about the pmp.;r!':: inChldin{! rental1ncome: . . . ./i' ,\"",,;,:,. . . - _ Dp:erat1n.g ex,penses" sales '#'lolu'-mc~3nd tnt-orne stater.nents; ..,. x ;.A~dijiti1)n,al sup p,c:rt.l rlg' docnmentat.io:'.... (;~: - e~k.,,!\oat~:lC.,9:~l.>^. -::. t~t,'. ..:.~:.: /"2 Y f..AVf.{....' ...,.1_".'. ,"_- J., "'" . U "l; j)n ,..;. "4'~... V ?t~~~~t ;;; tJ;P:::;:::~A::~i"~~~jj~V/;~~I< ~ A,} /"''1'''1. I ..".; (.,..) , , ,b J t '2, l? '{lOA:! l '-T..,~ S -l'" ~t;; t.~~:.. <.0:,\ I"" W" ..~ *f<5:~:~.} 3 ., p ART THREE: GROUNDS FOR COiHPLAINT f\. 15NEQtAL ASSESSI\lENT (Cornpl":te it~lIJS 14) 1. Th~asses.$~:..ent tS ~nequal,fQr theioH.~'=.V4"1g rea$Ctn~ (:hetk.acr b) a. _ Thea.s;i::s5e:j:i~;u~ is at a bghr'p~rcentage':::f ':ah.le t:hanilie~ssessedvllke0fQtherre>lt pr:::perty on.the assessment roll.' ,.. b. The assessed .....a1:.le -of re;l.i propzrt:'lmprov:e,j bya on.e, to.'.>>':' urth~~f2.mil:: residenceis.~'t 1 higher percent.:!ge. cf [;;]1 (m3.rk~:) Y;al~e tha.~'th~ as~esS'~d "'!/alue,Qf C":het"~.~:iidentlalpr-~perty qn:<the~ ass':;.ssrnent roll or at a higherperc!:t:.tage of f~H (m.:;;rket) '.'ahe ti"an theas::;~ssed vrJ;.:.e ofa!t r-eiipw?erty on the ass.e.3sn'lei1tr~~H Thecompiai.n.am beheves tbs pnip-erty .sb)uld be assessed at Lt} 0 c'~offuH vabeba:5e::L~n onecr mc<~ 0t ~he:fon~)\~ving {~he~k.cl~e or rIlcre}: a. The lat~st SLate eql.lih:atj0l1 rate for the city. W'.VTI or '{i.Uag~ in ..t'bd~ theprGptrtyis10cated is ~%. b,_The latest residentiai assessment ta.tic,estaNi;;hed ~~r the c,ty, t1"l,.~. or'1ilhge in ~;l<+i~h the residential prcpert'j'is bcate.d E~ter lat~str:e5lderitia12ssessment rJ!liJ only ifprcperty ,$ imprcl.....ed by acne, t\Vu or thr:;~ flr.nHy r:~sidence .~.~, ':. Statement cf th~~ :i:ssesso. (,r ot.';er kca! of.fic.~; that prope:-:y ha;; be ~a 3s~.es.Ed :::: \.; 4 V r.". .." <. ,'" ""..... ..,. ..-J. 5~ S ~:. ~.,,:'_S. ./"! ~ .,. ''-'" :......A-'...ltne.Z' teXp~aln:::rl ~lrt~cnec '~r~eet}~--- V~J..~ (~''''. t.-'c(~ ("'f 1':_ - ~ ,.. ~;~.~;:....:.T.'" \;'aLl'e ,ofpn)p'~rt}~ frGm Parto~e #7,. .'.~.. ...~~. ....... ;a..q .:.....~..-.. ",'. ......... ._... .... .'..... .':"~' '~",'. .'.; ".' .._'. .-$ C:::<mplamant beHev~s the asse~m:1er'.t5hould b~ red:;,;:,;d tG -.... .... "...., .~.. ... ....... .....__ ...............$;. 3~ .,j ...... B. EXCESSIVE. ASSESSMENT (Chec.kone or more) Th~ ~smen.t is. !X<::'~Ss1'ie f~r th~ foU;)wL,"lg r~a:<::n(sj' , L . ... Theas$essed '.abe ex::eeds d":e fun value of the property a_- .~ss~ssed. 'Va1\le -of pr:-:;'perty r .._'. ..~...... _. ._.... ,_.".. .. ..,..~. _~.." ..~... ....... '_'.~' ... ,,:. ~ '. ',~. .,,; ...... .. ~~. '0. Compla.i~ant b,el~p":;,'''e5 ~h::t a.5~e$sm,ent snoutd be ;educ,ed ~C' fun ~la~ue o,f (Parf"~le#:) . . .." .. ... ...-.' c. .t..tt::l.ch hst of prceb l~p0n \uhich ~;~mplair:.ant rehes for oejectk<n, lfapph<;abk:.. 2 _ Th~ tT<.able: ::s~;;~:ied 'lalt;e !.s~:;~cesslve be:;al,:lseGf ~he denial .;;.f an c.r po.rtF::'," of.a panill exempii6n. 3S;;::0~f:: exempti'Jt: (e.g, senior ::!ti:ens, Vetetilns, sch~oI ta';( reh.zf[STARJ) b., ;~~ou~~t c~f eX.e;npti<Jn -cla.imed .-.. .,-.... -"'U~,"", p...... .......~ .~... h', 'n.", .......... .......,". .... ........... '... .... ...:. . .$ :$ s 3. C .:~"nout~t granted~. ::f~y :...;~. ~.....,....,..._ .+_. ~ ,:~. ~~ .~_............. ..... ...".".... ._....:.... ".' .. ... .~~~,.~. ...............~,... ..&'....~.. ~ ..~ d.lt appHcation. for exe!T~ticn:~"~::> med, attach copy of application to this -=omphim Improper cabJlaU011 of trans llion assessment (AppIicabte i1nlY in icpr~'/~dass~ss!ng unit which haii adopredirans~ti;)n a3ses~mer.tq' ... . ., < .. . a. Transition asaesosment............................ ................ ,. ....... '...... ...... ...... .. ... .....,.......... .. :$ b.'rran,sino:l1 ass-e5,$:n~nt .:laimed ~ . ...... ~ ~ ". .. .......... .. .;.... . . ........... .,..~ . . ~; .;;...-.. .... .... ...... . . .. _. _.' .....a '. ' ... ...-....... S C. CNLA \VFUL ASSESSl\-fENJ. (Check one or mure) Tne ;:a.~se:ssrrrent 15 unla~~~..:fu1fcr the' fo1h:j~"'lng re3..sort($}: 1. .......:.- Property lS w~cHy exempt. {Specify ex~~pticn (eg, ncnpror:t crganizatton)'j 2._Propeny is entirely outs.de the bm..mdat'.es of the dtl'. town. 'idiag:;, SChN;:<l ::h~rn::t ,,,r~pe;ial dIstrict in .'"J/h.~ch ir: is d:::':;igJ1:lted as being, locate.d. . 3. __ Prop-err)' has beer! ~se&se::i and ent~red .:-n the ass:;S$m~n.t rcll by a pers.Qn or '::idy wlthcutthe -al.ttnOl':ry ~-D rn:ikelliee.rlt~""j : 4. __Prpperty cannot be idenfdied fr::;m destnphon o{tax map !llunbe:-ftln t1:lea:ss~s~mentr<:)tL 5 _ f'roperty is special franchl~.e pr<::perty, th:asses;imem of;vh.ich exce~ds thefinala~ses;ment thercd a.5 < . 0 4' . '.... n .z. R 'P .. _.. "'.. - ~ B -J . ~ , '::!et~ml';+1e~ .by {1:::e ~tate Qoar.:..; -0:[ ~ ea~,. toptrt:;: :ser.:~:es; {~...ttac..~:c"')pyc.:ft::ta:te ,~:,ar,:' certl!l~ate.} D. :\USCl.ASSIFICATION (Check one) Thepropen::.; is mi:s\:las~ifid for the f:)1l0<.>:tn.g rea~on (tele~'ant (jdy in ..tppro':ed :m~Hing lL'1it whi;:.h establish homestead and non-homestead tax:ra!ts): i';lassdesi'g:_.a;tion (:~n the as:i~'ssment rol!: .................a.... , c.." ~ b"'" ..~ d.' . .' , ,. b i,_ .....omp.;:aman, .....ue"~e;) ClaS5. es!gn'a.lonsnCUlj, .e .... .. z. _ Thea5S~S$ed. vatue i~ !n1pr0.p~rly alio::ated ber.;,.<~e!'i homeste<:d ~nd n~'n.h~:;.mesteaj real.prjp~rty. Arlccation of '3:s.s'es;'j:e-d 'la!ue ;:~n a3Se&Smer~t rc~n H()~neste3:d .... ,'.~. ._. $ f-:Gn-H{:~m;~steJ.d. ". $. (':laim~d eHo-cati..on ^Yol .;,:........ ~ F-S:4 ::~~{.{:;:2'.~ ,< .""? PART FOUR: DESIGNATION OF REPRESENTATn'E TO l\L..\.K.E COMPLAINT. .. . . ..- ..... . ~ .:}~, 'CG'mpl~~n:1r~t (:~~...9J!1::er tnere0t} tl.~~r.e.c'y" ~~~~~~:p bef.,:.re the to~jQf :~:;se53m~n:reYie\v sf the d"'j"i::?,;)";/'v"'dl;ig;,;:~~~~~;~~r:: ~;;re$en.ta:,""e In an.y ~'~_:1U ~'Fo~es :.f F:,<'!,e,.1,:'rr.g the 2$$e$.>m~:,t cd my reat P:~g~31"j.a..t~FP~a;s '~n t\~ _(year} ::en:2.h'Je aS5e:3$nl~;;.. :";:?ll r 5~~cr~ as.se~5$u:g ~Jti~t,: D~ t:~,~.",;-""'''''''''' ....:..:.-.;....~.._.... . ........;..;.... ......;.0..........;..,.. Signatu.r<:-;,: (:!. ::.:t;..:ner (er -~.)fii:.:;:'r th:e.rec.J) certlf:,/ that .aH,tatemer-,t$ made ;:)i\ this applidtion are tn.:.emd t;;:rre;;:t to be best ,)f my bG~Rledge $'i.ci b~hef,::!>ld r r:d.erstand-~h3.t '~hem.::;k~ng c.f any'..;"il1f..ll fas~ staterr,.ent(:..f rn~a.te.ri:a!fa::;t h.:e:r~,in\".rin;s~~'..~ect m,t t~J the p.rovisi,jriscf ~:e :P:;:zlal La't..v re~.e'/ant .tc~ the rr~aking arrd !1H~1gof .fa15eir:=tr~rrien~.s PART FIVE: CERTIFICATION ,. /"'.0;.... ,/';/ ../:.~ +/ I ,....) .. "~",, {~>; ../ ......., .,/. i.:~;:,,:::... :~~~~;>(:;;:;~.... ';';':';.;':'. _.........-:f .... ,f~,::::':'~'{<' ,. ....... " ... . .. ..... . .,. ...... D'at:: . . ....-,.... S~gr;ir~reGfo.:l/he:r (or r'Zpre-se:t~tah~~e:: 'he ::0mpl:am~nt (vr ':;;~mphmam's :ep:,esentat,y~) and ass:esso:'(<);, l!i.SeS8Cr desi5u2.ted by a m:;.j:)rityQfthe: b,:;ard of $ses.;;o!"$) ,.vh.~:;~s~g~ature5 app.ear bek<..... st:pulrM,:ha~ th~ fdlo'Hi,ti'g 3-sseaaed ...::ilue is t:~ be a;::phed tc: the ab,;";'..e ,;;~cribej pn3pertY'J:!'l. the ~(y~~:") a$:ie5sm.~nt rtjlL L.andS . 'Ictal S . :;;'~"""'h.o........~ b.'::;~' ~; -,t;~,nl~T~;~~..'::a.....,,-':r'.....~~...P~; .o,,~.pt"'l1-~:":~<'-n ~~. ":::~~~~.;l,.~i~ "p~otk 'T~;...':tA ~.~;":"~~-:.-.. B'~ r:~. r:.1.",: ~...oIo,o't"''''''''.''.;l.: .\"..'- ..... ::;~=-,......................r... -r"'t=....... .....:;) .....~........:-.,;.:&;..... _1..~,,:..'U.4w.....:.....;... ;a.,"".. ...;a.... ..............t _..""'~\.<.,;::.... -w_. "'" -- r , PART SLX: STIPULATION :0r;{plau1J~:t ()T re?r:;.se~1t.:.:tu':"le . ...A....~.s.e:ss c-:t D3. te SPACE ,BELO\\: FOR USE OF BOARD OF ASSESSI\-lENT REVIE\V Dt~r;'o:S1 ttC: n Oi t!n~t"",:u,._"l... .-a._~..;:~:~:_.~.,,......,,'~.~...; C::lZX.;............'.l:~~A ~,~....o-:.;:~~.a~.~ _ __ _~_ _ _'"- .;.... _....~~ ~._ .;.".....::.-:..0.,/.....".............. O .~~~la',:i...;S~1 'a; .::;~"".~::"":";;..=O"~ U:~l:'!~:;~~.....~.~~f'i:'..ah.~~.:""". __~>> .. ..._.. ..Jo.........3...-..;.........~... 1.:..1'....~.."""..~.................... ~o;..."-.,+ n 'R,zt~+"";....~+~i...)'"O; .'"'"tt=~..t~np..:~:'"~.~ ~.:=.....A-.....~~~.+r-l,..:~...... ^~'3.n.7w';"'" ~<:.':",03-..~.....r""~.. _ ~..._.'-~.:........_:.....;.;.c.. .....'... ~ '.t-'.;.a....:,.)......~ '"...:;:r....~~~..:~......,.;.~L--l~,'c...{ '\,;...:".:0;.. s........a :->......:-....~~)...t....:.':~ le:Jj.~,~n DAl.' 1..';""-"'" ,,",,~...~,,-.~ O .t il - :"1""'.-"" "'... -..-'" .. ....a... \.,.;..,:i.:L:...~..;_ ...._......;...-f'... Vote on Comphlillt .--' U'agan:'st D:1o~"",;" , ",_~"t". ;-'""11""'.~ i' ,..,t U .'-'~'-'-" r~arne nw' "~"''''..;;:.. , "l;l.-- .- n::r:h:~l':-;"~~ ............... ,.0,.... '.~ ;.A ~. ... n: '.....~e'..,. ~ ~~..~ "..\. 1'.l~m'e r:::~'Lal.as's;ess~r~~::nt: Tenl:lti\'~ assessment $ Decision by Board of Assessrn~JILB.~vie~ .t ..... } S S rr.a.ns.it~c:n a5seS3.rn.ent (~f a.!1y'j S ::'1;:~!ript ~'nQunt ....,...... ."... .~.~. --.... $ f:ax.able asse.ssment.....,'....'...4.:'..'. $ ::1j-~5 designati6n 'and alic~catian of assessed. value (if a.ny;~: H~G'rtle$tead .."..,. .$, " ~ :s $ s N,-,n.h,::me~;ead ... ."" '.' ......... $ D~te rlc~tIi~c.a.t~o;~ n13.i1~j to cOtnplain-ant ...... l.1 < Reference Property of: Pasquale & VIrginia Cardenla &8 North. Mesler Ave WappJngera FaU., NY 12590 s r~aJDt.I)q,.R~AJ.RS:l'\~V"'!lWt.umRnt;.~11)l);t. Attachment to RP .. 524 (10/02) submitted to Assessor May 21, 2007. Ground. for complaint: Subparts A & S .. UNEQUAL and eXCESSIVE AsseSSMfNT Cata used from wWw.reassess.org The referenced assessment ils unequal& excessive b~aU3&, among others things: 1 AU properties in the .asseasin:g unit are not use.sed fn a uniform manner a,requlred. 2 All clas.es of propertyln the assessing unit ate not assed In a uniform manner as required. 3 Propertles'n the same class In the assessing di$trictwere not asse8$ed In au.nif9rm mannera.requlred. The as.sesslng unit partlcIpa1ed In a large scate reassessment in an effort to bring all property on a par. by using a company (we believe It to be MJW ....) to do the revaluation and achieve equaUty & fairness. The assessing unit used this data, which filled with errors: mad~ many assessment unequal & unfair. it also made it difflcult to assess our fair market value by comptning to similar homes~ since there are so many errots. The errors are In many areas Including land assessments. home value assessments and data on propenylaat sheets. Attached are several examples, and many mofe can be provided if needed, to show that this effort yielded very unequal and In some case excessive and in some cases lower than true market value. In addition. to errors in both land and property asse~u~ment$. the revtewing body should be aware that our assessment was SUbstantially raised above tneaverage a.52} Increase, even though a RP. 524 & subsequent RPTt., 130 adjudicated by J,H. Thomas Esq. (Sept 4. 2002 . hearing I ease" Supreme Court, County of Out chess, filing 3044-(2), this fuU.revlew yielded a fair market value of $146.800& an assessment 0'$83,700 (equalization rate w8s57%). Property values have not doubled In less than 4 years, (9J02 t() of thi, reassessment); no other doubling was found In dB In fact. the property acroal thest,.,.t (2 Lin Rd.) sold on 2/1412006 fer $325K & was just reassessed at $.281K (1&%)?? Tb. property (1709 -1715 Rt 9) sold In 1999 tor$1.1M. currently assessed @$1.5M an increased ofoniy 38% In8 years This property has 2.23 Acru and is land Is assessed.~ 225K or abQut $'tOOKper ~re forptime commerCial prop.erty while resIdential properties are assessed belween a low of 91K1acre (on take) to 238K1aerefor 42-44 S Mesier Av. Other disparities Includes the assessments verSUB aquare foot living space; based on mysampling of 24 properties. This varies from a low of$5~/lq ft (SO Spring St) to an average of$165Jsqft (2 Veterans PI & 38 High St} to a high of $328/sqft (25 Liss Rd) Similar usage land parcels were compared (both residential & commercial) and many were not aS8eSsedequally. Lake side (lake access) property was assessed at a lower rate (per acre) thtm property without lake aecess. Residential property adJaeent to commercial propertywasessessed at ilhlgher rate than those only residential. Commercial property is aS$es.ed at a SUbstantially lower ratethanresidentillprQperty & varies greatly between 2 Adjacent properties; Station on Rt 9 (.46ac. @ 'tOOK ==217K lac.) & 1701 Rt 9(3,34 ac.@ 265K = 79K/ac.} a 275% delta The sq ft liying spice for our property Is in error, assessor Is aware that it states 2084 sq ft &. should. be around 1450. Our home is t"e same as 2 Lisa Rd + we converted garage to living space (added 450 sq ft butlostattach4td garage) Ba.~on the comparisons made.w& believe that our assessment should be $294.800 UBfngour true living space of 1450 sq ft* $1S0/sq ft replacement cost + $53K {.53 Ac@100KlAc}+ 24K other. 294,600 Thle is the same If you use our 2002 aSS8S$mentot $83,700 .. 3.S2 (avg. Multiplier). Result 1&$294,600. I apologize for not being able to appellr in person, lam away 5122-"5/24. J appreciate your consideration hlthls metter. Pat Cardenla 5/20/2007 .h"'-. {". .-" ~~1!.."'3l) IDHuFF Wi \X/ILKES. U.t: '<:' ~~n~ ~!~ ~,~J :)~~;':.r.l.~~ !1~J.f.;;~"mH"~'I!.~:!'!- ':9~ ......... , -.. .. DE:ISICN or ~=A!m>G Cf~TCS! I j 1 i '~ft'f;:ol:t~ 'I'> tf.;::llut.. C~r.~p!!t~ wj:"';:n~O e.~'S~r ':';:'1 G~ r.,ali.lng.. Sana ~r.e ~~./ I tl':~ p.t'i~ta-!ltl if !;lOt 14~~~~mll~.?r.-e,.;:::~", t~ tt':;t :r.~I.,,~;tUal t~:l~eullrif.;; t;",It. 5U.i .~~::S:::'::;';r._~;?~~ Del I 1 I i J DA\'lD C. \'illLKfS :<:::OU1~~a!;.O?- ,~.l' l..^~JC' ;*~ }.~s>; .!-'t'R'=~r WMir~ Pt..()~~~$~'NY)~!:-QC 'n~~' ~t;~"f4~::~4'~~~: J.~~ ~~:J\~~~~.~~:B.~ .l:~1~M~iT?.a1' !'it!it~#.",.~\' It{.:l4 ~ht~~f}~H"5:: .l'-~'\:;:,:!.i$'.IH~-S, :OJ: .. Sv:;;~m.e4'"r.. C~l\~~f~~~~:g(:f)::: '.. Nam_ of CI'H~lIt#tOW~eta; . .. ... A~IQlit ;C;I.',..'S~~.,'l::;) C .tt&Jeuinlif fJil~; TiyMall# ..':.::::.::-:::::" Ct-~~:c l" -2-:::'J..;~.~~r n,..,.~e~~~e~~ I O~Sj:O$'TlCt" - Cilc~ 1, 2. 3. A <l~ S I: . .. 1 I O~l~:J~lif,~d4:~.:::!.;: !~;:.tl:';::~~n. !lv~ !;e!cw: r J1. t r~~I~ ;t,~thr&' r,,~:;... ~. ~. t :1 ~~~~ 4'Pi;,,":e:r#!J~e.iJJ:hlu . 4%. ( iPf.z.J:!.'I";'( .not :sud n-:::iustlo'*-)dc: .:n':,l"'lt..., jl~t;:;:;HI~ e.~ 1 Ceo:'l~.;l,,~ f;. -~c:~~_;~"'fs~~it.l me ~:n~~ - t.~:j~ ._~ - 'Q~=~m;~~tifu ~4~~~:~~6.~.-.c~~~$.J: ~t:: - ~3$S3tJ .C"t;~;".~-~. ~5 ''1:'c,~~d1HJQ'' i~ ar.a~:;m;'j!~ ~S~l[S;l1~ ~~it f.l:Ot~~~ Stilt. fl!~~~I"'~ ~'.; ;.:~~i'.~~~ ,,fiS:e. '''.!ltt~n !:O:,pi'{s-ef!:t:n; ~f _ ~~~ :~~~~ ~;. ~ f9~~.:~~~ '~}e ~~;:tn..S'f!Sf.:r~f A,u".$.me~~ '~~~t'i/ .. . ~ f l i .i: J I I Nor;:C~C~ClfSOUAU~:CArlON .:l,:';~ ~'GMt T:) ..L:C(lC1A~ ~~V:tw ~ .'" !t._ ~~t~t 1 G t1"'~Q~t', ~., ~s e:.e:: l(~~,: ,ft'hri~~~: ,ej$ :~i~~tic~~ ~e~Q;:";~:~?' ~e( .r.~~.w 'V~~tf :~t:.~;~~~t .c~~~rn~: .~_~.~e~,i~~~ r R~,~i~w' Pt-e~~.~.~UI$u.:tfl~,lU tU:~':;;:~ ''3.0- .~f' -~~.'!'.;.~'~~~~et~{ Ti-~(.;.~\"': . He~'i&~';;=:~" y~~::-n.:;:" '$;~~~:'i~~iel.a~ f'J.:..;e..'" '(,J:'H~~~: ao ::!~o$ ~? ~;!efi~~ f;f t'ffi$ n<Weec, r1J,A~ Cit~SJ01-{ !Y Ke~i!SIN~ . qff:!C~~'t,:\ ..: ..... . : ..... ... ~I" ......ITfl. ..... ...,llI:\f!>. ... t/\'ii~~.:..... . tX1 ~ A~SjS$.S~,~iN~ p..",,; ..... . ~.~~ \f)fJO cu.~Meo A.SS.fS5Mt:~~; ~ <tL.} OOV lms~;'tro~. ! t 2 i 'j ~~ ; ~, tS. ~ \ . ~~~~~;riSt-:~i;~ ~S~ I (~C~~;l (If. 3: ~lia,'I't'~<!.d'to ~l',i ..,,:-:~;c.,,;,:. ~ ill': ll~i~ ~y !!':lI~ss~n':r." ':..~:.. . . . . .... . .. i t~~,~2 ~ - ~'UI~rtt) Q~f;:=~ :~f .~h~- ~.e~:I;.e~ :'a.::!~~5~ !~4! --~.s~.e-'S.$~~~~, -~'.;!CC,,~ - C(5:;,~ c~, fr..c:.~I ~::'~a',.:'~;~~~ ~~~~~~m.~t..Y~"J~~~(S,.: ! ~War13 ::l~'H:; $~:s..o-:l. If 1~'l! ie.~:$;c" !!!oe;.:l;~s {nos oluan:':\i.~.!::i' (l;n'~l'=~ll ao ;1:::;1 Cl!:'\~. '(10" ~~;. ( aw'S':,j !l:::;!!'~i :-:h;;; :!:.\ U;C:-, ; . \~ t;~e<;~l T.-:ril. AeUUr."4!nl A$'Senml1~. f-"~U$;":i! b.m~r .f,,$~U~min~ fl.l'\':~l<B~ ~:::' ~~Ul"..;" Ttt"a:~z~. ;nt'Se1t~&~t ~$SI$~~lIr-t S,m':t +,~f$':':<"i'lHj) tin ag-~!...":~llt ~tt.cm ;:a:"J4~. t .i $ . '$. ~ ~a~OftT Nc;:nce qF:~:,O;-UH1::} AC7~C.t~ '!Y ~.s"!.=SS~~N~:''';::t:O 'TAX:~~G.jU;';!S~:C'TICNS I I I.. I r:~~5. Qc~,:s~.:t. ;:If:'t~$ '(~~c~:, ;at~~o~. 'm.~r~c;. ~~ ~ ::\. ,~S~~ . ~.~,:.!iie ~~:::':-e~t, )Vm Zif e~~ns~~~ . :t~~sz~~~,~$'t'::Qt!!1~! Je,<ve1 ~):~~r cr . r~::;.;~'d' '.cr:~A:~$ ~^~~:':~F. ~JZ~ '.~::'~-1:~~:'-!~ '-:!..n 'c.f,h.. :.;;a of t!'s$i ~~~ti.e~..~n::c!:!l; .~~ ..~ Hl-: ~f1!"4Sfl:tri1:ltSi :::.~:n~: ~,t::'.$~~.~~l. -Qt:,~~C i:.-:m:6,::,::'i:~ ;~'~E; .::~~~~'~~~a:b:~: for,ti!(!r,~ . ~~:~. !;:ti~~. C:lr,t~!t.tth.5 nama& 'e!. ~d t. x~;iUt;I:e-i~t~~~" :~iat!:~ ~e F'\.lr:"in of y;:ut !;~~~~n '."'J::~~~. '!~;Cf: ~ime{s-~ ~5ted ;n ::4~&.~a::.:.mtnt l~ ti..t~~;':.t ~r}!. a=!:~~;;~~!:~ ~tsC~f!~~r 'dtC-5r.r!:(e~ti$; ,~.o' ~.& :'~)~a~~~~ if. ~b~ nf~~"':V~" S~3~~:'G~:"'~a '~1J~~~'~"$1#. ;~,G ~~d;Si'~:ot~"t.e~"::'~n;~t:-:-;::;~1 Z!!~S$::-:.t!:::::. 3~:! t'~'" t:;a$~s J~t:It:~~f .:t~:e;.:~P. i I t I I -- /~.. ~.., ~ ~ ~ :: :~ ~ " ~ I ~ : ~ t '. ~ s -4 I ~ 1 j ~ I ~ t l ! , I 1 -03 t7 .. .nH1f 1:.l-J:.f(.;J HOl'" EO\\''NERS POLICY PASQOM.E A ~. VIRGH.u:A I CARDENIA S8MESn.'-R AVEN wAPpntGEltS 'PALLS 1tt 125~O YOUl' Agene~.ts Nmnc i\11({ Adgres,s EM!.RY . & \)'El.1B, INC, !29!o~.!.tt S'SEE'r pOIJG.nro:EPSIE lttl.~60~ Named Insured Your PoUu)'Numher: . S1-2541393 G3~ 2 YOU14 Account Numher: 9.1~541S93 F(jrPoHc~: Se~iceCaU: (S4.$) 4S4,...4220- ........ ,.: Fu!' ClalmSf}r.vieeCaU: l-aOO-cLAtM.3.3 ....... '.:.T~'~~'t~~e.~~':'~4;i.~t'6ti12.~'Oj.~.}~~;..... STANDAlW ~INS_A'J:THERES!j):ENCE llRi:M!sts ~~I~~,~rf~t~:.~:~;premi$$$ li1A:PP:n{G~:RS?At.1;s.."iU 125$0 -~.;.....- SoctiOh 1 .Pfopin~ts Co"erages Limn$()f Liability ~"fl'. ":7 J ,. /~. . ... ...d ... . ....... ........d ,<. .:>,,<.<t) bL> ).$..:t.?~iQ9Q<. .J t ... .:i'1.Jjt)tf? 1.23.t200 S~(60t) Premium ). ,.. Oti'&L1.1NG B - OTHEB. STRUCnmES C - P.lmSONAL PROPE.p.n T) - LOSS OF OSE .......... """""',,' $<$94.00 J.l:JCL INCL :WCL Section 11- Liability C(}ycrage~ $ ~ i's:Itsot-tAL tIABtl/l '.\'Y (~oon.Y: !NJtl"R! MID paop~'T~ DiUl.~t.;El EACH oeetJUE1tc! F."" .MEtl.lCAL PA'l~$ TO O'r!iERS- EACB.Pii:RSOl-: $ jO(),OOO 1.COt) $ la,oo IWCL PoUc~'Forms and Endor~eJnf.!nt5 HO-2 (12-86) ll<>meowners 2. B~a<t i'()~m SA-1M ]:.]Y n,.l-D)) spe~j...J. Prov.i.aion>> HA"'390.~ U2-02} ~j~J:'kerB Compettsa.ti~n and Employers t4abi.l:1.ty 56512 NY (02w98) Addition.'l.l .~p1a:Cl<atMntC~$.t P~ot.eet.ion 1 $pec.i.tiect ~urt~ -~ximum AdditiQnai ~~~unt of ~nsura~ee 2$~ 58064 NY (Q!-99} Value ^dd~d Package $ 1:2 . 00 Total Premhllu $ 424 .00 Your Premium R~flecC5 th~ .~on(}win& Cl'~dlts or State Surcharges AecO\1nt. DiscQu.nt -St.OO --,- e-()ntinu~d o.n. nex~ p~ge In:zured Copy .Paqe 1. of .3 ~~..t~'~ ~..~ ~i'.;~~.H~Sf~~ C~~~*". 1 f.~~;;lX!,;'::\):' ~:~-i~C:;~., t~~~~~, ~~~tj:f . ,- ".... ..,........,......... .''''''''''....''''..-.....--............,.. . :.:::::;:::;::::::~::::::~~t~:::~:::~::::~:::::::~..;.,.~:(.~," ." . ;;;"",,'~-,:;.,.'..:.:~}J.%~~~:.::.:~.~,,~~.. .,...:;z;~(~<<;;;;~.(.Y.~;.~~N;.N;.v;,:~~:..:.:...~~~~~~~<<<<~~:~:~~.~"4~.:;.;;:'_~:.~:;~~:;:;:;~*;;;:~;.;;;;;;.~;;;;;;;;i;;~;;;;'. ;, ..".,:.~,~~~~~~;:.:.;.;:.:;:~ :'~::~~:;~::":.".'.~":.~~~;:;,-::~ .;~.o:":.':o:o: .;-;.:.:.::::::::::::::::::~:::::::;::~:::: ::=-:':.~:-:,: :: .,- Propert Size A$.ses$OO K House SF LA SFK$ C(lmment 55 N Mesier 0.83- 76,07Q 91.651 336.000 259.930 1425 0.182 lake front 25 Liss Rd 0.52 6&.093 130.948 394.000 325.907 993 0.328 lake front 33 Liss Rd 0.42 56.380 134.238 312.500 256.120 1040 0.246 lake front 10 S Mesier Av 0.50 10.630 141.260 3S0.S00 279,&70 2944 0.095 10 S Mesier Av 0.50 70.630 141.260 350.500 279.870 2944 0.095 5 Liss Rd 0.47 66.763 142.049 380.500 3'13.137 1490 0.211 lake front 21 S Mesier Av 0.46 71.035 154.424 383.500 312.465 3058 0.102 30 Spring St 0.40 81.825 154.563 414.500 352.615 6285 0,056 7 Liss Ru 0.39 60.495 155.115 3'17 .500 257.005 1340 0.192 lake front 38 High St 0.33 53.183 162.062 357.000 303.817 1740 0.175 30 High S1 0.33 55.171 161.203 419.500 364.323 2344 0.155 3 liss Rd 0.35 59.546 170.131 324.000 264.454 .1290 0.205 not lake front 27 N Mesicr 0.31 54.797 176.765 311.000 256.203 1638 0.156 not lake front 2 Veterans PI 0.26 47.959 182.101 302.000 254.041 1604 0,158 33 N Mesier 0.26 48.149 183.425 314.500 266.351 1364 0.195 7 Veterans PI 0.26 ..;4~ .4.34.. 184.510 410.500 362.066 2898 0.125 over 2X size only 25% more 2 less Rd 0.29 . 53:658' '165,026 261,000 227,342 1006 0.226 notlake front 1 a Spling 5t 0.26 47.769 181.329 343.500 295,731 3058 0.097 ~ 47 Uss Rd 0.22 41. 992 190.873 332,000 290.008 1420 0.204 lake fron1 , 4 Liss Rd 0.23 45.205 198.703 355.000 309.795 1342 0.231 not lake front 37 High St 0,23.' 45.205 200.911 408.000 362.795 2540 0.143 29 N Mesier Av 0.23: 47.769 207.691 327.000 279.231 2052 0.136 40 High St 0.19 39.697 211.717 401.500 361.803 2501 0.145 42~44 5 Mester Av 0.19 44,624 231.995 319,000 274.376 2436 0.113 58 N MosierAv 0.53 Other Anomalies mentioned 62 E Main Sf 0.32 1701 Rt 9 3.34 1109..1715 Rt 9 2.23 r-f" 2 less Rd.. 0.29 1 l" .j .L ..f.:,........] 1".../"..(~1>. 'H.--",+~{~..k L.. kt~ ~. ~~..-~ 67.903 23.000 265.000 225.000 53.658 128.119 354.0QO 286.097 1450 0.197 not lake frontlerl-orSFLA not.2084 .. .,!/{.J...,C. " '. '." "~... (.1"'" .,. C I ( . J 'Ii' ....~, c-".,...' "l l' t.~ t:'... ( J; (/ ~.. p....-'..... . p....y~. . ..J. ." 72.100 . ('.,~~.",~'uJ..t;,.~~. (-' IF 19.341:r "~u.v..V'~.{f.;o.....-<:,... 1 00,891/' 1.5 M 185.028.....- 281K Soldio 19Uor 1:t M Value increased only 36% in 8 years Sold in 20tlfor325K Value decreased '16 % in1~t)r ~............................ ~-;-'-'-; .._._.0.0.......... ;';""":" ..-.............- ~-:-:'-<" .--'-" :,,;.;~H2~~::::::::~~::::~~::~~:::-"-"""""'" .-..... ............ "." .:...-.-........ (:. <) ILl f> 5 .s c;An?..=r..... {7 " L (tD 'r/> < ., .1 '" (I ..... <..:j i' ." {.l "'.. !-1"", t.. €. v.f:)i-.-,..;f.~.:-:..: f''';''':' ~./ Pro rt Size Assessed K Com House SF LA 30 Spring St OAO 61.825 154.563 414.500 352.675 6285 10 S MesierAv 0.50 70.630 141.260 350.500 279,870 2944 10 S Mesler Av 0.50 70.630 141.260 350.500 279.870 2944 8 Spring st 0.26 41.769 187.329 343.500 295.731 3058 21$ Mesler Av 0.46 71.035 154.424 383.500 312.465 3058 42-44 S Mesler Av 0.19 44.624 237.995 319.000 274.376 2436 7 Veterans PI - 0.26 48.434 184.510 410.500 352.066 2898 29 N Mesier Av O,23q q 47,769 207.691 327.000... ~!.~,A3tq . 2052.. ;.:::;:;c:-:.:.::;:.:;v.~~:..'.' 37 High $t 0.23 45.205 200.911 408.000......~.795 2540 40 High St, 0.19 39.697 211.717 401.500 361.803 2501 30 High $t: 0.33 55.177 167.203 419:500 364.323 2344 27 N Mesler 0.31 .. 54 .797 176.765 311.000 256.203 1638 2 Veterans PI 0.26 47.959 182.701 302.000 254.041 .1604 , 38 High St 0.33 53.183 162.082 357.000 303.817 1740 55N Mesier 0.83 76.010 91.651 336.000 259.930 1425 ""0 7 Uss Rd 0~39 60.495 155.115 317 .500 257.005 1340 t 33 N Mesler 0.26 4&.149 183.425 314.500 266.351 1364 47 LissRd 0.22 41.992 190.873 332.000 290.008 1420 3 Li$$ Rd 0.35 59.546 170.131 324.000 264.454 1290 5 Uss Rd 0.47 66.763 142.049 380.500 313.731 1490 2 less Rd ~r,y" 0.29 53.658 165.028 281.000 221.342 A 19Q~r:i 4 Liss Rd 0.23 45,205 198.703 355.000 309.795 1342 33 l.lss Rd 0.42 56.380 134,238 312.500 256.120 1040 25 Liss Rd 0.52 68.093 130.948 394.000 325.907 993 - 58 N Mesier Av 0.53 61.903 128.119 354.000 286.097 1450 SFK$ 0.056 0.095 0.095 0.097 0.102 0.113 0.125 over 2X size only 25% more 0.136 0.143 0.145 0.155 0.156 not lake front O.1~8 ....... 0.175 0.182 take front 0.192 lake front 0.195 0.204 lake front 0.205 not lake front 0.211 lake front 0.226 not lake front ... 0.231 not lakelroot 0.246 lake fronl 0.328 lake front ...f.... ... J. .' -F'.t.(" )tf!t;; 16.> I\f Il'" . ;. /.~, J.,.r . < . ;3~' ~,("":'~....:.,(. . ..' .. K':. ~:" ~ I ..' .. ."It ~ / ..;:>f. ,,;,.....# . .;?/) 9:1.91 not lake fronlerror SFLA in 00002084 ",' ..... . . ~ ~ :..... LJ::J H fl) p;>V l'!~'7t.. 'n'.~' .L...... J .~ .:,..@,.....,,:,. . "^x., . ... O. ,. ':~~' ," ," ,)l'~:"" '." t.. . . V .'... . ,r...It tQ ,.". :.tf'.:.i,,i/' .}. '.' - f':Lt?SM -- k-Ff+: ...." .'~'~~i' ~. '^ .. .. .~fV ',. . .~ 1$1 p1 ~J """":;",..."'~""Gi~"""''''''''''';.'';;'''''~''''''''''''' "~'':'' ..... 1.' .. I ~ HEI..P I CONTACT. Re;/~SSeSS.01Ji1 <"L. ..\ y<) ", 1"'1\ ,~ ';.J V http;/lwww.reassess.orgIDisplay .asp?txtLookupI<ey=o15S- 14478413-0000 .....'>J.. . , \ ~ < 1 - '.' '\ ,..... .], /....'<~) > ". .-r. ... .'.' . .. . .. . .. .. " :; .... . :." ...~..' ~..'. . ~"...;.... ,.. tJJ:-; "-,. ../'\.. /' ... ..... ..' ;, " ........ ,.d...>f.;{)-.....,\ ~. .",;b:~l:r Ii ~) i \ t'"Yi". :"'/ \ .' '-' "~:..'. "./' \,.,. ,.....: ..~8~./ ":,. '\ '.' /' ..' t.: .......... \. . '...... l} . .......... / ./''1' ../ ,.1.. ,/ ....: ) . ~../ 1'i ~/....... 1'\ D ~. ,.,", .' ....> ... f-. .. , .' . .~:..". , . ~" ') .' ~ .n .",:." ;.. . f,. ....' 1\6. ,,...........- V"..~..-..~,.. .../ ':1 /1..1:-6 ;"'1 \ J."~{<U/-. ./ Y.' 7~ i ~~.'~....../ 1Jt//.u /: /'Q ~ ~C Co, .r- l'IV ..~r {O.:?.l)f:~"..;7;,~ Town [/loo(;.r 2. =~7t:~ hE'a.t. l..aG;;nge~tmra'fl:l'~'tonval. AmaniaF:~~1I FlshkUl Seacon po:;: =7J.-'"I." ,'-" ..!.,,;. "'."'.'''''''::/ c.. '. . 1~'1"-" A/eVb'jt QRPS 6 Fair A.sessmerrts Main I I I I I: I I -..:t~"{Cl !Site , Site Number: l' TODOaraDhy: level atGrad~ Waten Ipubll~ I 'rontaoe:J!o I Land stae1123033.73S1 I fenCina:IINone I Tfees:1I1 t~3 trees I SCenic: View~IINont I Rafltoad:!1 tom__I. !BUilding I Prog:111966 En_dor w.n IwnVI Sldin" Materlat: , ." I Bath.:1I1 I Heating Typo:llHot Water/Steal'll BaBC~:: Icrawl RoafilqJ Archlt8ctural Mat.rla" Grade fndoHd I Porch: 330 Additional Floor Area: 0 5B1.;1161.58-146478413-0000 OwnenllP&sQual. An Cardania swfl:1I135601 I Black:llco14 I Nu::r=:llss II proJ:=11210 I II Section: 006 Lot: 478 Street N.m~IIN Hular Av &-'1 DistrIct: 135601 ~lS." -- I Street T\lpe:UPUblie ! Zoning:IIR12.s n sewenllPubllc JI DaPtlul{o II Ne"'~~IISiJbUrbll~ II Drlvewa.,;IIGtaV.1 n Wet411r View:UNone II River View11 II Traff'tcaf. I ~I laulldlng slV,elllSPlit II Yeat Buift: II 1955 II Bedroom.;'13; 1I Fual Type! on I Overall . . . Condltion~ NQrmal for Aga i Open PofCh:1 o. I Fir.t FIGel 1386 "\0) Ar_ ....' Kelf storv 0 Floaf Area; . Totel $qua~t i.,~"'j'.I""11a. ...8Hement 1672 _ Foot.um l'J .,J F, II. b Farnthl Room: Half a.tlllll fjnr.~d Attlcllo '=::'a::J16a4 pC>~~I."~11 unAulaltechl1 County> Auf I Sub "llaRdllS8 I Sub I.Ot:1I413 It Sidewalk Tv'elllNol1e II Utntt1es:U4 It Land Type:llol I . 1.#. teata.1 e.;.. .r..... I Site o.lrebUily; . 2 II I TVp~.1 to . landsaplng; NelrJhbomot>d II WatetFront:UNona I Pond:! Indu.trl.J: I II II: I .tad.:l!1 KitChenSIlll Flr.pbu:<< 10 C4l:nttat Ain NOM OVeran Grade: leconomy feOl/ered Porch:llo Sec:ond FIO. 0"\0 Arn: 1/4 Story. FIOOf..lo. Aree: II Gar.oe $F;IIO \I Garage Typo:1I0etached 2 I Firilshed Ove:rO Garaael 51212007 Dutchess County, NY Property Record . ParcelActtlll . l~~l(.ku Count~. N\'. . ':::::~:'::::::::;:~;-:.-:.~''''~*He~~~~~~~~;'::::~'~.-: -.:.... TENTATIVE RolI- May 1 . 2007 Pale.1 ~OIt!~OI\(;rlCaoon ,; t3SB01~1$8-14.371313~(X)p ~~ 1& Iil9h st VilSQB of Wappir.g.ilrFallll CYmer InfcrmatM KIlIlca.....' . MOllY Belh (PJ Bonedetfo. Vlncatl1 (A) EllI:nitt.fP.i.Q.omGf tMH A.ddnt~ S 42 Gale 0' POL'ghlcElepW NY 12oo1000tl P.rcGl~ Size (ecres): Flla Mllp: Fila lot#; Split TI1,vn o.oa k. AsuJ>lmlmtlnfonnation Land: _w.....-TOlal: $24217 $308500 ...................------., Tal( Coda: H; Horr.eslead RDR Secticn: Tenl..RolI: 5l1f2OC8 Final. Roll: 1/1(2007 Last SaleITransfar ~~.- $135000 R P 524 """ , l:)I'A-l-(fl.c; Page lof2 /8 1ll(iII.srdH . ..~:.. .:::.. ~:~:~..~: :~:'_'.' .r. "~r:: . n..;@?i'<X:::):::~~~~r,.!rrrr!I!l!l~rl,:.'.""~~,~::(~m;.<.<:::::::::::', 1......R@H?f.9!t:::J lslY.f Use Clau: Agri.OlsL School Dislrlct (230) Res.'denlial: Three FlImw Y~ilr,Round Re~ , (0) (13S601) ,^iapp~-.g&r Falls. Cenlnil Sllt-OOl mlltrtct '~oo 5'0 () ..j 0) Z 4.1 L I, 7 - 2-E;Lf) 2~'t3' :t.Lf 78'S 1= l.. f+ :: 114, 72..~"t.4 ;2., 't78 Sf: t-f- .~ K..t(If,t:-w ~ '$ rr~l(..~~1lS Countv Taxab!&: UOSSOO 10-...'<1 Taxable: S308st}O Sctlcol TilXlillle: $308500 Valige Taxa*: $308500 Uniform %: 100 Full Markal Vatue; $ 308500 Valual~n: 7f1;2008 Deed Book; ~ Pagu: Sate CGfldilion: 22005 &65S (C) Sale Oallt: 711&'2005 12"4~:3 t PM SkJJ.\!9~ SIIe Numl>er: 1 Water Supp.~: (3) Comllvpubfio ~!mI1!I18u~din9 InfOOMl~ Sltit NumlN:t: 1 Yeaf Elullt: Yel" RerrrOO:. 1835 0 No. Kl1ehens: CBnl1al Air: Heal Type: No. Paresis: 1 http://geoaccess.co.dutchess.ny.US/parcelaccesslpropenyCard.asp7swis::; 13560 l&parcelgr!9=13S6,., 5/19/2007 Sewer Type; (3) CQmrr.'publlc C-6suaMlty: (2) Typical Zflr.inG Code: R2.F Used Ai>: o 5uilaing SlylB~ (2) OupleJ( No. SlglielS: 2.5 ~: 241$. 0/$11111 COil~k (3) Nlmnal Nt). HaIfBalh~: o No. Bedtootnli: No, Fife PIQ;e.&: o BMe:1'n~nt Type;, (4)Ful! - .~..~.. Fuel Type: Fi<Sf Sto:y; $ ul>>mf Swry; Addl.Storr: Dutchess County. NY Property Record K r,s 2 i.f- [;xJri1(>lt Z. Page lof2 'Lf $" Lt ss RJ l':Jar(/e~ccet$' .1:,~;:;,,"!,!!!.!i';''''.:::''''~ll''''S''_:'('''((: ">'l)I*r<:(~):.Rl!>.~~#y'<,,,,,$~<~~(<,>,,,,:::: .....;::~:~=~~,:~fI' Pri~~~........l TENTATIVE Roll- May 1 , 2007 ealeel Grid ldenljf~llQJ:!.!; 1}5601-61Se..10-480554.QOOO ... . ......, ,. . . . . - . . . . . . .. ..., '. . ~~.~<...... '.V~~iJ~!YI#~~f~ ... CN,m!f Informallon Ge!wr,joo , Ernest R fPJ G..lo."lUir.o . Bellv {A) primGrv fP) O.wlitr MallAlI9m>> 45 Uu Rd Wappirigens Falla tf'/ 1~ooaoo Parcel Dafllfi$ Siza (&r:I'ea); File Map~ File lot ,; Split TO't\'Il 0.23 Ac{o) Aa1e".mem InfonnaliQfl Land; ----;:Qflll: $41239 S318500 Tax Code: H: Hcmastead RoUS~: 1 T enl. Roll: 5/1/2006 Final. RoM; 71112001 la10t SaleiTtBnsfer Sale; Plioe: $0 ~R,".!!\r9~ Si!1l t<lurr.be.. 1 Water Supply; (3) Ccmmlpub~c BUg,enlilll BulldinQ Inf9IJXlit~.ffi Sfle Number: 1 Y$r &2t Y91.Rfimod.: 1956 0 No. f(Jct!.er.s: t No. Full Balhs: 1 C&nlnll Air: Heat Type: Land Use Class: ('210) R&&idenllal: Otl& FIln'<lly Year-Round RSllidcmos ,1\90;. Oi$f.: School Oi8tnct: (0) i13560t) Wappinger Fa Central School D;'!ilIict County T~abI8: $'318500 Town Tnablc: 53 tll500 School Ta;table: $:)18500 VlIla;e Taxable: $316500 Uni!'orm %; 100 FUll Mirit:et Value: $318500 Vilr~Hon; 7l1i200s Sale Date: Q Sa!ll Corllfitii:ln:' o No. Paree!s: o Deed 8QQ-k: 1210 Ci!ed P~Qe: Q47& SEWer TVpe:. (3) ComrNPtlb~ Oes3'abl:ity; (2) Typical Zoninv Code; R12$ UHd As: {} Buildillg Stil&: No. Sloiiea: Sf,a, OVerllllCttnd,: (03) Spn 1e~81 1420 (3) NOtmBI t,fo, Half Batbs: No Sedroolrni: ~. fits Pla(:fi; Bsement Type: 1 :4 0 {3}P8nlal Fllel Type: Fisllt $~~IY: SaCl.md $llli'y; Addl.SIoly: 1-~6~lJ~1:Ss,'l;d:((UlLlresgJl~".14llJan!~ru.u.~flUl}1OO)'(YC:u\ (l~lr~iVtS~15']oht~"lJID't!0litro;!..1SSo..~ .~ SI19/i'U'U I Dutchess County, N'YProperty Record PareeiAt:cess. ~:~ld~~~ (;(I'C#~. NY :. :';:~::~::?...;::ri;:-:f~.i:;:#::;V.{;;:~~::-;:;:~~::;:~~>>~~)\,,>>~..: TENTATIVE Roll - May 1 . 2007 Parcel GrlqJd.Il{\\lI:~.ttqn.~ 135601.,41S&-14-451:s03.(Y.Y.)Q ~ar.tl \dt~tm!l lVeleraM"P[,; . .Vill!!ij~li(~flJ.ll.J.I. . ........ .............. -.........-... .............-.. -.... ---.. 0mI9rlnf~t~!! MUllellt . ViIlcem J (~i Primary (Pi (M1\e( MJlifM~r~~.J 7 Veterans PI Wapplrrgers fa~li N'1' 12Sg.:lCOOO P.!~ 0s1ailB: Size (a.:t8$): fI.Ib Map: Filo loll: Spilt Town 10 X 150 2251 <4 AllSe!!n1IlIlllnformslion 1..1J1lG: Tolal; $48434 $410500 Tax CediS: H; HcmfllltClId Roll Section: 1 Tem. Roll: 511>'2006 Final. Ro!l: i!112001 LatilSalelTfllnsfec Sale$ p~; -...... $0 R f' S 2.1- bk+1tl (;' 3 Page 1 of2 ., .~(..{m~.#.s' 16 '. .......:.:::.:..::::~~~~~~,.~..!..~)xw!1rImrrl\l~!?I:wJl .r'".~.!o/.':~~~~~~~~:'::- 1 ,Pl'inlpAne )s. ~""O:--:-';'J.',',',:'", "'~"'''';':';';'''' Lj /tJ!i:'60 9~li3.l{ -319 -./ {.... '._ .~. t..... (/ f,9 (Q 2 S 18'S'f4A ;;- l.ar.d Use Cf3ss:. Agri. Oi$!.: (t1) SeMolOl&triet: (135601) \\9ppil1gerFalls CentmlSchool Oislfict .:;X.. .I;;1..5/s:;=t..:4' 3 S 7p/216!-S' IP Counly Ta~able: 5410500 TIl'NnTllxable: $410500 Stllcesl TlIXlI!)le: $4 1Q500 ViJloi~ TaXable: $410500 Unllorm%: "Full Marital VallS": $410s00 100 VllllJatkll1: 7!1i200s Otad Boo\<: 2200<4 SlIle C'JfIditiOn: I)'.) No; ParcelS; 1 Sale Ollie: llJ812C041ti:26:01 AM Site Inrorm~I~.I).:. S~a Number: 1 Water Supply: (3) Commfpub~e ~Jal BuadinlllnfOmJlIl~..n; Site Number. 1 Yesr Built: Year Rerr.C<i.: 1960 0 Nn.lQt:;t.etlli: 1 NO..Full Ballla: :2 CenlIal AIr; Heal T'{lle: CeiId Pag&: 12201 Se>lmr Typc'l: ('3) Co.mmlFlrb~C De5!lllb!l;"ty: (2) Typio;ill Zor,illg Code: R12.5 UiCdAs: {) eU~~lnlJSlYI8: i05) ColoniSt No. S['IOO5: 2 ~~f ~.~q ...... " , ,."..... &;~lomd.: <~'3j&~1 No. HAlf Balh$: o flo.Sedr~:1~: 4 t~o. Fife p~~ Basemanl Type: (4}Full fuel Type: F~1 Stoty: SliIiXIl);(iSIQlY: . Add!. Slet'{: http://geoaccess.co.dutchess.ny.usiparcelaccessipropertyCard.asp'?swis=13560 l&parcelgrid= 135.6... 5/19/2001 Dutchess COW1ty~ l'iY Property Record ~#~....#t.I' 1" A ./'>./'a l' .. 'l~w' r;;.'~.U'1~r,;~;::~:#.: .' .A . . . .. . .~, ~.... ,. ,.. . I.X"., . .", .'. . ~.~t{:Il.t~~~...:"'~~H~t,~~.~.... ""~:~"::-:::?*;:~:},; :~:~:~:~::~::,~~W::~:c:r'~mr{~. ,',' TENTATIVE Roll- May 1 . 2007 e~!."'l~rii'1 hi,lllX'lCatioll ill: 13-$01.6158-10-438530-??oo .:.J~~::/: ..:.:.\~~#W#P#i'@W:fa~ O'.<.luwlmosmaron 1A'Im. . Robanl( 1. T (P) CI1ti$fine , Anne RM (A) l.e\<M.. EllZabeUl 0 l.. T (A) ScIIlllllskf . Margaflll Mary AM (A) l.l8'Iffl; . Psut Kevin RM (A) PfflnlllV (p) Oh"'&1 Mall Acldtem! 33 Liss Rd Wappingers Fell& NY 125900000 ~l.II~!'Q!!!!l~ Size (aert4): File Map: Fire lAt.: 0..42Ac Spl~ Town Mll&Ument InfClmllllon. Land: Tolal: 156380 $a 12500 13); Cede: H: HlllL-D1ltSlld Ro~l Set:lloo'. 1 Tan!. Rell: 5.:'t12llCt Fill:!!. Roll: 7i1i':!0()7 l.ast Sale!Transfer Sai;s'pj;:";:-'-"'- $0 Sill'llnfonnBllol'l: Site NUtrdntr: 1 Water SUPply: @) CGitlnVpub~ ~&nt~!>>IIP4mg..lr.r9.tmmp.JJ; Slt& Number. 1 Year aula: Year Rllmacl.: 1983 o NtJ. I(rtchllM-; 1 No, FI,IIl~h&: 1 ~nlralA!t; Heal Type; t( f f). 2,'l- t,iv ,L~I.t'J'L c . '{ Page 1 of2 lS A.J.~I- 33 Ld r ...(.:......:::.~::~:~::,1:~~~~~~x(J))):a:~)J~:.;.;;;:..~~~:k::.;r.(f~~~r:~(:~~~~~~~~:::::::::;:::' laRririt p,'-Q!::-."J Land V$c Clas&: l\gti. Olst.: School Ofslrict (21 ~ ftfll>i!fsnliat; One FalT'~ly Year-Rocr4 R'l~oe (0) (135eOl) Wappmger Fall!; Cenlr.il School t);'$friCf County TllXib!e: 5.312500 T(>~'m TSl'a$\u; U125"..o Schoo.l Texllbls; 5312500 Vitflllg& Ta'~b!fl: $312500 Uniform %:: 100 full Matl<e:! Va!ua: $ 31;!SOO Valualilm: 7i1.i2006 S;i!le Dais' o Sal. Contliilon: No. Parcels: o . ~ed 8ook: 1857 oe~ Page: 0$51 o S~r Tv~; (3) Ctln-.rro'pub!lc Oemhl!:t'/: (2) T~fi>::al ZOnLW<Q Cbde: R11,$ UsAld. As: () Bul~II\Q .Slyle: (01) Rench No. Stooos: Oillrall Corel.: (4) Goad . Sflll; 10M No; Half Bali-oS: o N;:J.Bndrcoril$' 2. ffu.Fire'PIaces: o iia$8tMm Tyll&: (4) Full FuelT\tplI: SllOOM $IQl)': Ad(R Slcry: F'ls1 StillY; http~/!geoaccess.co.dutehess.ny. usfparcelaccess/pfopertyCard.asp?swis= 13560 1&parcelgrid=1356... 5/1912007 Reassess.org - Reassessment of Property Values . Reksess. or"Ji ... .. Co,,~,,~.'hl.~~...~ Ct'Lth'lr~ ( I \,.- K\r'c\fz...v / t..4~i';rtt,....~t ,....,~. . '''~>..1ty .!....~, l:Je.-.s-.wJ:> . s........,.. '" t.S'DZIi ,~l.,~ _.~ :\ ;L(~ 0 c, L~ .32.5'(< $o-\LLW A<l,e_~.~j. .i'"} If" '% .-: . '7), \ \4 t,- ~t.: Page 1 of2 I. HIllP I. CONTACt; t COUnty> AUf ORPS . Fill, AS$es$meob Town Hom~ :oe:x Ahinelnck .N~~1l :'O~~W~~;~nW.pp{nger Pou:~ East LaGr.ngaS-eekmanUtlion\fale- AmenlaFi~~~~lI FishkUl aeacl:m PQ::~: !Maln I I sa~l' &lS8-1"'-470~29.0!)OO OWnerll Ant~nio Dos S.n'o. Switu 13500111 :::: 1~14111 Humber: . . . P~~11210 I I SUffixl1 II ISIte _....>>11".2. "'('l I Site Number/Ill I Topographyll[Levelat Grade I Watenllpubtic I Frontagelllo I land str~llt3240Ae42 I Fencing,1 Wood Stockade I Treesl!ll to 3 trees I Scenic View,I!None I RIlljroad1lf Commerclah 10 Building I Prol.=11~67 ISUitding style:11Riln<:!\ I StDrI~~ll Ext.a:e~::: IAluminum II Yor BllUt:1119S7 II I<Jtc:he"':lll I Baths;lIll kdroom&: 13 1/ firepJ~.:J10 I Heating Type:lIHot W.tertSteam I Fuel TVDet 10il II Central AlriJlNoftll IBase;~llfUU I CQ==: I~!rf~t~~~> II OVerall Gntdculleconomy M:== ~~~,:,ctural I Open porch:lln Ilcovered Porch:llo Enclosed 10" · '1.' fif'$tAF~rlt '.1~....'....6'...'..'."",.,.,',....'. '<11 Second Floorilo Porch: r . . . . """9. .' ..:.:.. :.>Area:l . Addition. at 10 I Hal' SWl'\IIo 13/4 $torvF.loor E. Ploor Ar_:. , . Floor Areal . . Are>>t Tot~~~:: I~AA~<< ... >11 Fam~*:=~: 10 I Gara;e SF: l64 ... . . "::.:111:........ < . ..<<..:.:....:.<........1111 Finished AttiCJI~ :.:;:: It.8.\lilt in 1 BallHllmeny,..... .........<\ UnAsslgne.d: ~ GaraGe: 0 Section:1I0Q6 "'~r70 SlTeet Namttll US!; Rd School I Dlsufch 135601 N.l~=~1615a14 . II $l;Ib~ontll1sa II Sub Lot:U429 II Street Tvpe:ItPubllc II ZOnlnlJ:IIR1ZJi I. $ewer:,If'llbut: II Depth;Ho II NeI~~::llsubutblln r Orillewav;IIASPhalt 1I Wilt.r Vilnv~Ut4one U RiverView!l I Traffic: I I Othsr Influence . Code; lISlaewalk TvPetflfl~ne II Utliitl"es:U4 II land 1'ype~1I01 II Aaeaoe:llo,303'59 I ~Sirabl:;~fI2 II . . .IITvPiutto t.and~pln9~ NeJgllbomoad n "Water Front:IINlme lIPond:11 II Industriahl http://w'.vw,reassess. oIg/Display .asp?txtLookupKey=6158-14470429~OOOO Sfl9!2007 '. .................~.. ';';":;:;~;';':';"';';';';';';~:~:':';"'~"":'" . .;.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.;.;::.;.::;.;-;.;.;.;-;;~;.;.;.;;;;;;;;;';;;:;;;:~:':':";"""'" :,':':':':'~':':':;:"";:A:;:A=-=-~~~~"~:;;;:;;;~:':";;":':A:"~,,.~~~;;;:.:::;:.;;,:.;.;.;.:.....~.~.....;...,;~.;.;..-.:<<-,. -: :.-, '-'-'-'~;:O:;:':':':':'.'~ .;.;:;-;. ; ;;; ;.; ; ; ; ; ;.; : : . . . . . . . .. ::; "::;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;:;;:.:;:;:,:;:;. ;.;..;;.;~;.;~:~>>>>>>>:; RP..SlS (1191) * . New YOtk Statl: Beard of'RealPr~S~ NonCE OF DETERMINATION OF BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW For (Cit)'. Town. V11Iase()rCounty) I;,/: II ~~!dJ>1-i.4- .511 7) )iJ:,:j~~,.t.,. a~.AL I J/-/ /} Y /26~() ~ Name and address of Complainant The tentative assessed value of $ ..?~.~)< i-;I{) for this pr()pett}r: a.D has been reduced to an assessed value of Land S Total $ b.Jf!f has not been redticed.. Your eomplain.t was based' upon a contention that your assessment -should be changed because ofthefoUoWing: CJ Assessed Valuation CJ ciassification CJ Exemption 0. Other ---,u " .. I . & IS;? II-I """ .i/~?2/IZ5 Ta."'{ map sectiow'bloc.k/lot# Location ofpropeny if different than~ss of Complainant The Board of Assessment Review has madetJUs determination'forreasons setfQrib below: Assessed VallI3tion L The current full "tnarket valueo,f yourpropmy was derermih~ to 'be $ o (1) The-proof ofvalu~yollPresented was adequate. ;~~ (2)" The proor' of value you presented was inadequate because: rsr i. the supporting data. was insufficient 1:j i1.. sales were not comparable to your property Cl ill. 'P1e 'Written appraisal was incomplete Cl iv. the income an<i ~nse Statement was incomplete (mcomeproducingproperty) CI v. the construction coSt details wCf$'-incomplete. b. The UDiformpercentaiE: or value applicable 'in this assessing unit is Cl (1) The proof of assessment ratio that you presented was adequate. Cl (2) The proof of assessment ratio that you presented was inadeqUaIe because: . CJ i. insufficient data was used in calculating an assessment ratio CJ ii. sufficient evidence was presented by the assessor to refute the residential assessment ratio (RAR)or the State equalization rare CJ ...~ .. b" lll. the State ratlos are inapplica . Ie due to a revaluation Cl iv. the ratio that you presen~ was not the correct resid~ntialassessme~1t ratio (1t.-\R) Cl v. the rate that )'ou presented was not the COIre(:t State equalization,rate. : ,,;. c. The physical characteristics and inventory of your property were determined t:Q be: CJ (1) correct c:J (2) inconect.. cont. RP-S25 (191) Vab.iation (~ont.) The correctinventoty should ~ the folIc:>wing: ~ ........ Exemption The taxable assessed value was determined to be S CJ (1) Your request for exemption has been granted in the amQunt of$ CJ (2) Your request for an exemption was deniedbec.ause you do not qualify for that. exemption. Classification a. The property cla~s de.slgnation was detennined to-be: CJ(l)correct CJ (2) incorrect because: CJ i. the class designation should be homestead t:l ii. the class des.igDa.Lion shoUld be non:;'homesreadH H b. The pto~erty class aIloc~on was determined to be: CJ (1) conect o (2)inconect because: the class designation should be allocated homestead in the amounto! $ and non-homestead in the amount oiS . . . ... Additional Factors FactOrs in addition toOl' other than those listtd that affectedtbe determination were: ... If you. are dissarisfied.withthe. detemrlnarlon .of tbe .Bc3tdof Assessment Review. You. mayse.ek judicial review of your assessment pwsuant to Article 7 of the Real Property Tax Law (.RP11..). . If you are the owner of a one. two or three familyresidentialSttUctule. and reside at such residence. . or, if you are the ov,.ller ofunimproved property which is not of sufficient size as. determined by your assessing unit to contain a one, two or three family residen1ial structUre. you may. seeksmal1 claims assessmenueview pursuant to Title i-A of Anicle 1 of the RPIl..Petitioris for judicialrevie\\' MUSt be tiled ~ithinthirty (30) days of the last date allowed by law for the fillngoftbe final assessment roll for your assessing unit, or the published notice or such filing, whicheveris1ater. PetitiOn forms for Small ClairnsAssess11Wlt Review may be obtained from the County Clerk's Office. Vote on complaint .t:1Y'All c.oQcur -0 All Concur except: name. o .against D abst..mn o absent D absent tl~/1 I . ~ ~ o against Oabstain I 1-/ . < /7 .Q/...h{,~-'k-'J~~./ /' ChaiIperson ignarure) " Board of Assessment Review Data for 58 No Mesier Ave. over Time Dates Sa. Footal!e Action Taken Results Pre Revaluation from This is historic information before 2000 into 2006 1724 None Includes 2002 Confirmed on Town Assessor's Card evaluation Attached Notified Town said to work with MJW to MJW Consulting correct. March 26, 2007 2,390 And I worked with MJW Chris Harkens & Town Assessor Gwen to correct this error. Linda of error called and said 1710 would be new MJW double entered room number MJW again told me that 2390 would Waited & continued to recall MJW & May 2, 2007 2,390 be corrected, this time to 1718. I told Town, Finally called back by MJW & them that that was close enough to told fix was being made 1724, so I was OK Told MJW that SF was Told to wait updates were still being May 14, 2007 1,388 too low in ReAssess.Org made & correction would be completed ASAP bv 5/15 Told MJW that SF was back up (in Submitted RP-524 and confirmed that May 19, 2007 2,084 Parcel Access) to 2084. MJW said too Town assessor had correct late. I would have to deal with Town information in their data card, in my Assessor - Told to submit RP-524 file. This showed original (pre 2000) values and updates throum 2007 Between 5/19 & 8/1 databases were August 8&9, 2007 2,222 again updated & synchronized Parcel Submitted RPTL -730 8/10 Access & ReAssess.org were now both wronl! and at 2222 instead of 1724 ,~...,_........_~~';<#AI>:. f~~~J ml;,UlllIlltll ~~I mR1VIH,'l m bAKE.HllAlll't (~~ Wf.I~Glp,;:$ !!!t~!J,UWltl O. ~.;<: I.'i~ Ntlflfl tli~'O<nt ~~~ tlllim( 1~1ffl: ..' rs~ litlfllH Itt I fISomn'l LS~ 1\{l{t\'flllUX!HV !Ilfi'iltl!lt ~:ARm IlIf6711i" fl~1Ili. m I m1ll'l M1R~ ffi17 ?t~~ RlI~ ~ ~(I~ I ll~ SHiRY ~M~l I\llb m.lJlIl lIOO~ I . F~J ~ iIOllV!i{,fBl Ill!\' 1I1l08 AlI~!lll I STRUC CD KC nIMHtSlON1' DUtENSIOl20NTF I&R CD rfAR JUT fUNe OBSVALOE ~_.2? .. ~~~; tl~~~~l: 6t:~ t~fJf1i. j, J;:'C I ~ p.2 I 1:;.,;;.. i (.; '7tfJ .. I -y 6/:') m ~ STIlI<fI:!J1 1~'2 Cll~l~\:C (.,. F C' '" "1 "i L) r C. :.i-;, . {,~"l () ..... ! r~',. f't'li:r IWJ !Wl!Hj{j> " L,'(,: e: 3 ';;1 If I ",:>.:;: (lOCi *\ 1 f:I,I;~OS~ir llr'~ rWCl.r.\;f D ..: . :~. o. \ .~. -==t. n!~tnt~!if:I)lI~ m l!l'f'fr:llf~U v · t~ r . :. ::J..I* ! c.. '.1. <./t.)-'..... ; .i<<:.j..~.,i~i:liilr Ill'h :J:~I'!:~ t,U'IHEll \. 'l;.l~P4'J ? ~.:.o f p '5 J (r'lr. ''.;: ........_--.... ril<2liRI:f~WnS[ l!i'?~""n ~,~r.t~t r . J ~ ~ 1,;: tal/;Hnlll~~ IW~ I;tP[Utlt;L~SlD ?-.pl ~ .:l. r.. i. c...:;;> tq'S~ i "U~fi~\~~~~"HArtU:6.ir'---'''''~...... . ~--1 ~~_'lU1!lt~ 'L..- t-t ~.,:..t;..~....O.~...!.J'.^..:Rf.. f:...~.R: .5., ..f..;-.~. RJ.'.-.. ~.~-.- .._.,~ ~:'::'~'~"....'. .....:..:::.=-....._... _.. ,~.n.~.~.AA.. ..r..IW tt 1.l1f.'.II;;'.lfll~S..~..'.; :U. .r.... t "~'(~ I.M .s. -- -. ._,,~.L -~..-J... .. ____ UNfiNISHED FULLWJ1JRJ1!JJ '.' ~.......ww..n....,._.J,~ n"mm I'C-lltlli ': OYiU f:(l)li r~lwl!l'J~ l.......l......................,....~.....l......................._.. .......~_..........:.....Ir.....................-....tl..:-...... =E:"'---- _ f--- FlfilSHEO OVfRJ1\M~L..,,_~_.__._.,.. ......q.. .~.w.:t( 9i~('~,',,~:!~ 1^.1'1 " '":"=1',1 , of:,". ,. ,:,:;"." "II . ...... . .... ._00 00 - - . _ - ~.-._-- T9fl SUA"}"" .~.. '1'" 11"Z .,".. J'. . ,n. I. . ".~' .. .. .,..... I. .[ [ I 7! .. --. --.... ,.:...._~t1 ......~_~ ..._...'...~....~. ...'..._...... .......~...... ..;.. ." .t_._........._............__,,_.w.~.........................L:::::x.............._.,.;......:..........................1.._........_..........+1'.........-. '-' -t--_. .---.. ._____m f----',-- J/6) - I ~"i/ :L C. C) (>v tt> r.:: (~ ~ R ~ ~v.'T (~I '2.LX> '?) -r;;w tv.. . S:.s.()'Ssc.''K. FIt. ti' '11'l3 EC l 1 POOR 4 6UItDUiG STYLE 61 RAItCfI 02 RAISEtlRAtiCH 03 SPLIT LEVEl 04 CAPE COD OS COLONIAL 06 CO~TE"PORARV 07 MANSION 08 OLD STYLE .. ......WOt 1/1 llIIW 11 1111\ tAU. 12 OOPlE c) L 1.> ,. ...~ {t.' L;" t .{. ... i~. !to" ,~ t<... ./ (..-. /l/' i: tt..,..' .:::l} , i;:~:~::.ti~:;.:~~:~-'-'.;, ! "';r ....:: .., ~.~~r<",.~~;:;.;.;.;v:.~~~-. h. (1/ (C rmrs . . : _ _ ;,f~;':~~~'~?"" , . /",,-:<; {, pt "/iT"" , _ r '.,' . ..... 1: . ."..~...~: ~. 1-/ .,;.., \>1 .~'.. '--../ ..... " ..<{,~~.:!:\ ,,\' . 11.";:- \. (,....-1- .,. ....':, "..- . .' . I ,./(.rt. I . \~" '!l i~.. '-) ,./ .: ~>.;......~~:::~~,.r.... r .': ,.$,".1 .,: "..;' :.~- . (' ((:-'().(.J .. ..,..",.>)., ~~::_:~. l -Ll"F/ -~"! /:..1' ?;,J:': 1'/''''' -0-r.t.. r r'.<.t ....(~. i' IJ i":. .'t., {:' . n "."",. ,~:,...~-~ - ~~':"'" : ..1.0.<... (1~\ I !JI /" c: :' . i.. V::;F::/~ >. j'<, .~ ,. -'. ~ ,,/} .P. (. () f~'~,; n:'}.;.:.:/' " ....: "if "",-... f "3,. t.,,~~ :-' j/),(. i . , . . / (.(; .;.-)'s' . .'! r-.-.'......^... .,">;;::;:.. 1 r (.f . .,..... : (.~.~! --~..._,.....- i 1;.;~~",~;,:T (.:.., i I:.. -;.. "?:'.f~:t:, 'L. ::>.:;;'. . J'-'#';;-r-;-~ ,.".. Iq I ':;(~"4i i i: '7" '-<,(.';':!. I (?:2.'~) f ~ 14(~);' -- Jl I 4. ~_. !.~f.~_._ \"J .'.Ir.el . ........ .(:s~) ,~..j;J . _o;,~ " s ~. - - . I'. . Fi'rsl F7J(:,t;? l1r-i/i ; . .!J,'J.r: //'..:' If ( V c. . '::;:;. t)....f {j ,'1(;''' .,,,,' . I .;.:<.tj /-li ~(;l ,- ,. f-jrt~;.-..-7]'...........,... l} ''''''' . r;.:-;-~ rLJr E~ rr~~n . U:~:~.l ." ~ '",. ~'" ;! .;., :/,.. ~ I:".. J LAIlD CODES lAND TYPES YA1Ef(FRONT TYPE 01 rrllMIW 07 W'CODLAND t P!H'4D C RIVER 3 LAKE l'lISC nEMPTIONS Q2 SECOliMRV oe WilSTElAND 4 CAnA!. .5 OCEAN 6 BAY CllI'Il'IHflENT lEIm COPE MIlJUtll 03 UN9EYEUlPEIl {1.1f HUO; SOIL RIITHlIi COItl1ITftEtlT CQUE ~4 RfSlliUAL to IjAlERPHOt~r P POOR HIS} 01-10 OWERSHl? CODE 05 TttLADlE 11 lIliCtIMn IfHORl1AL (0&1 01-Hj EASE"ENTCODE 00 PAS TUftE l~ ft~AR GGOOD (v1) Qt-Q4 R ((flIt ClUl!; la \/lHEVMn 14 Wt:TlANIU5 (EASED IMI Oh04 SIGNATURE QilTE iNFLUENCE CflPES I (tn c)l-{l'1 (;[IlLHIUII IlfHE.: lfl1UDVY ITIPlE IArrllVITY I Et/1RV I StJURCE I TllflllGllllPHY 4 RtSTR. llSE ml OHI) I, c Loc~nON 5 VJ(.t4 SAlES INfOCOf>ES lIlN~S(CnOtl 3 SHAfE b llU"ES}- SAlE T'm! fl\liNI OErnl IERES SGtlARE SOlI. I'll! Hlf INfLU- ? ormli 1 t.Aim ONlY 3 UNO nIl FEET RTNG lYr JL ENCE~ _ E&l)G Ofi.V (,.aLDtl .-- (~{1f.~__'h_'''~''-'''''- ----- ---.- i\IJDlTCONHlOl CODES -.-. - _~.~~'St~=t==.'...".__ ==-~~-~ '- -=- ~~:t~:,;..n L'.~ll~...tl',"l', EI!TRV "..E~.==:=. n-r...rri, -:;., i nm:RlUR rttsr: -=~'-~.' .~~~~_... 'F! -....- --=.:,::.~~t- - -=~==- ....--.'1--.:: -- H"lEA!llREA ul!l.Y ~ lRIUllHl!ffU! " H.1TAt fif;JUSAl ~._._:--t-....~==::::.:.:.::~:.~~.~. '~~~~~~~'~:=:_::-4.::::.::.~::.;~~~,.~.~~:" :.~~::;:~..~.:::::::::=~........-... .,.^.'~~~;:::~:..~- . ~;:.=~.~.:_. ':~..' . u~_. 1 .....::, ~.._.....:' "'-"1 1.:J,g~~c" -,,- .....~~. o. ' . . ,-,., v /1. J "'.'7 ~ ~- -,'''''" //:;./')'F;..";J . I!~ 4'"V 1"-::r;-~"'P.l.l'..Jc:)'/J: ..................&~..._- ~#O.... 7..r:......"A"............. ~.. ...;.'Y" ~. _....:.. _-..:"___..... .. Rf.SIDEtlTlAtl!MtI" VACAfH LmiD PROPERlY fiECOF:DCAAn 6BID NUtlBER: (1 f ...:-; </. .l:~t .' ./Y> . .... " , UWRtR LAND ( :',..~..: ;! :j, 1(<:\) !...!/H:.', (ISE ,J ,'/I...... DEED REf ."I)..V);... ,', ~'.-".l"X) nrrll OATE SA!.E PRICE YlAR AAR ASSESS~NT RECORD AJH AtI1 L.AJID INCREASE ~ECRtASE ...... . .:.FI/X: () .~,{i')('\:v.~ j~'1 . .... ,.. "7;":. ., :": .,....,.... .... ." 'J "Md nlPR T OTAt. :. ""-., <,.,;;,.Iu..... Jt~.(3~ (;':':~ ", Y;:~O(..t~. '~/j)/.!J1: ", '::,;:.. .--) ...j. I -SCIC. ~~ .~'{11.1 .1.) J"'}"'/ .. . ,"-. .t...-.... ; :.... " ~ .~_:(/ ,:.... ". . ,/~,>. Z()tl/ ,'" i "';lfL, ,ll u tJ !,(~ ~1.0 <. :j:< In ,....... ......,. - .~.-:.....,.,. ..... J.)/' I',i ..). .. ,(. r:ifik' ":.J{,,' .'\... .~ :-",':"1 p:,,/ <: . AM P1HHVSICItl DECREASE PI ~PI1VSlCAL INtREASE EtH:QUAUZllrrON DECREASE EI-EQUAlIZATlON INCREASE ~UDIT CONTRUL SECTION mIN.ITY CONTROL RF.VlfNER DATE REJECT CODE ASSISTANCE CODE 5l!iIlATUfiE $flON DOES MDt tIEIlN t:otlTENT$VERI~ltnt ONlY THAT DATA WAS CIlllECTED IN YOl/fl PP.ESEllCE lllNlI 1\'I>E ..R..L J.1.:.j UltAlIfJt.I "~~Yd hi !.. .'h'.., SUE INFOR"ATlON ~[CTJUN SITE Nod) I , r.nm::" 20tHtIG CODE If:lf:l,'ATlIIII I IfW j InH .~ IH'U Il^TF~ I Ham: P l>JHlIAI[.'::l '" II" I Sf:~fr; 1 NRNf P. f~IVI\Tr ::J If' UTtLIlltS t NONE c liAS 3 ELECTRIC Ij tWliEur SITE DESlf,EM'illlTY 1 UlHRIOR 11 fmnlJ:i ~~.w Ii I El.l I nnllUlf:iJlAt i' tVPlrAI ::II" I rillllTHlf; ~n. !CARI) NO. I PAflr:- f'lllt;~ 'ar I '.,'U q Nt'? " (' ;"1, ~), lOT SrZE: ACCDUNT TYPE: SPLIT TOUM~ A ;:;.) ~~) ~rH1lffi DIm- STnFfl r:nm:. (.~."'/(::,I.(...,'.: SPECIAL DlSTflICTS CODE AHOUNt NOTES: J N j 0.' I 1 V /,n , f \ J -' V "AU >> Q"I NYAlm '",\lAUD SOUllCE I OlINER Sk (I A Ii 2 RfLAT I VE Ii AliSrsSf.lll 3 TENANT ~ OTHER r let;; ........ .~.5 Reassess,org - Reassessment of Property Values ReAssess.org ORPS . Fair Auessments S8l:ff6156~ 14-476413-0000 Ownllr:flPasQual~ An C$rdenll!l SWIs:/l135601 II $ectfonTIloo5 8fock:ItOO14 II Lot:1l478 Hu:'~:IIS8 1/ Stteet Name:flN Mnier Av pr~~11210 I' D~~~~~:IBS60:t SUff"D</1 II N.~~=~1I615814 DeserlptiontlO.53 At (C) Site Site Numbenlll II I Topography:l Levol at Grade II Weter.1 Publit: II ~7 Frontqe:llo JI i;'~~"11V.(;~ < iLYt{fySV.A < I land 5fZ'~ 12!03:i.73S11 .~::l ~~~..~. . . _.~t,t.v .-1. ~. . , .~h1 . ~.~~'; I F.N:,ng:l~onel ~:;('s:'?'ifjE_.:::=--=:.~. . L . .. ).;.---'" ./! r T~:jU. to 3 tr&es If l cf8.f 1 Sconlc V!ew:IINone . I[ I? f J'1f! 1 I ""~EJ.. . I './-'.', \ .., .~~ Commerdal: 0 t)., i: ~ Building ~. .,": r lju.r~;:::;.:....YV ," . :!J -;1 t <../_, .' ...-i:\..:...." , . <.:.,::::p .~.(.....' }J; ;:n ~ t.- J>:i -:-:. j . ;.), "~:.:;/'. .r..'/ r..:';' " ",,' .':....:.... -,.... !Main f f I I I I \;. 1> ;.~. ;. af( I G) /it/;xIIAJITll/4."... 3/2.~ /0 ~ (:cttmty > Am Pagelof3 l.H!l.p I CONTACT I Town Red Rh be of Town Town ~fw'. . City Home Hook . jn~ ck North af RyeWBSblngton. appmfiElrpt>Ughk East ... .' I..JlGrillllg.ea_kman Ontonvafe AmeniaFl~b.~t..'.'1 FiShkill Seacon Towl .... Pougbk Sub hellon: lSS Sub Lob 413 Street Type:lfPublic Zon,ng:UR12.5 Sowe,:UPublic Oepth;llo Neighbor l.subUrban Tvpe: . Pr~: 1966 Butldlng style; ISPlit Exterior Wall Vinyl Siding [ Year Bunt.111955. Materlef: .. _ . . . Baths: 11. If BedlQoms:iI3. r Hating Type:UHot WeterlSt-eollmj Fuel Type; Oil [ ~;;:::JfcraWI I Con~:~~: Normal forAge M::::'n:, ~~~~~~aUri31 ! Open porch:llo [- EncIO*13'>O J'Je.I..:~ II First Fksor (1"''''' .:. .:. , ....... __ Porch:." ';..f'elft ~( . . Area: . ./?OO ::: ,:.; .f.':': I Additiomtijlol. Half StOI'1' 10 c Roor Aru:J1 . Fl"oor kClI: .' ,:,,< f.Tat.. SquarelG'3S0 I ~asement l61i':' -0 t -.........Foatag.;JL famdv Room: .._ '. : I Half .atb!ll JI"fllilfllod Attlello . .~~ ,~~.)t:.:.:: I ":::,~~II~!1.>""::"" .. II UnA$si;ned:11 .... :::. ~: .:;'.::: : .. ..... ' , . ::i. II" '^' ~ ~"..;;: ,':~:c r ::;:~:)..::' .,.. l<~l.:f .~. .-. f '.' "; If . ~ '....<r~~v,~;:. . .. ;'~ .':.... - .':: .' http://w\\,\lj,reassess.OrgfDisplay .asp?txtLookupKey=6158-14-4784 13-0000 i'. . "~.,:~ t.t::. II Stories:l! II Kit~bens:lfl . I, Fireplac:e:UO ] <:enttaIAlr:Uuone I c=~:l-"~" .. ISecondI=~E.. 1"4 st.,y::: 0 I Garage SF: \0 II Garao. Tv~:lIDeta(;hed 2 I Ffn.n:=~llo "':Del,f :'.:::':::",::' ..: f:~~.; :' :;::\'f:" 3/26/2007 '~;.. ...~~-.---'-""""'.'.'.'.'''''.'''''''"'.'''.''''''''''''.'.......................................-...,.,.;. . OAP <.- "- ,....(.1. .,,!.oJ 1./ . ..v .. .~., . ../. ~ /.~, .A U J r - ,J.......,.-......~;ii. ~~ .4u..fflt;~~~ ....v.~. ........ _'~~~'.. . . . .....".. ~ ... . '. l.lilf,;P JOONTAOt't b7r?j,e. f JU .S."f7 .. . ~ .. . . NG]/6}l.- (C;/(1:"', (;-::..,"'"'!rb ~ eountV > Asst T~ Red .. of Town.. ToWnGf ..... City ~~ ..... ~.~~..bt~t Nortlt otftV~WasM.nWappktQ6tpouohk ll...~.){ Z31t,.</~ east La6:.i~otSt.kmii't U~l>n\lale Amema FI~=1I R~iIJBe&cj)npoJor: ;,. ..., , .. N /\' '-. . ..Rey~ss~s~~. 0" .. (1) 1 \\.... \~~ If,) V bttp:IJW\\w.reassess.or2/D.isplay .asp?tnLookupKey=(S I 58-1441841 3..0000 ..~"'fjl' f); <:7:,/.~;, :'." " ".... .::-4:" ~"-wA,.~,/'J';, ..>;J. \:.c;,;:'f zft ,:;(V '(.;".' . '.' A._ < \'.\1,/".'1 1.." \" -,,~,. .,;~'\, ;,.J.,Ao.... /"':... ..,....,',/'...~.. J'~;.,..- \ :l/r;,'~ f:) .) \ /' .,.. ?r~5J.~.:;.. / , . )r" ... ". . \ .~.~ 8~.t/ ~~, V \. ').~.,,/ ~ ~ "j . . ~~\.,. /" 11)/ ~~/ ^y(..GZ '~.1Y"'1'::-- . ., l;f. ,.... ,.... ",." ~ . " :' l ..,......y , ",." i.,. /" \ .,~ " ",""'''' '/7 ......''\.., /1"'- ~l ..., \ )'-'~....; 'b.. "0" .. . . .. / ,$/~. p ~~ ..>/to V7' ~.v '''?l \ / ./,1" ..~~ V 'C S .. F.it A$5eS$nllmll 1AY L~- 2~<Q Main ,. - sau 61sa.14--4'!4U.O~~J -1'-1::;;" 'A.~(} .JI"j;;:.~.',~ As .v Own.rl PU<2uil. An CBnienia ....J(...~'" .f't,I" I f ~.,'_,....., N' ... Swlll US{iOl I ftcUOIU 1006 $u'-S4efloiu .158 ""'.......... ~.u...,~!o~lft '.n 0014 Loti ;,~18 Sublet: ~i3 Str4&1 sa Sf,.t wanMI~ :N M2~U Ay Numbor. ~ Properly 210 Schoal 1 CIII$5: Dfltrkb j135601 C---SUffi1 , , N4i~:::~II~HSS t4 o..cr.ptf-on! IO.S3 k (C) - -;.: ..-..'- :.-----.... 'Tr Site fi:.>_...~._- .......'.'.....~.....~-~;." Sit. Number.:: Stra~ TV04~ Fub~, . Skfewitlk l'YPfltIlNont Tor:tOluallhv.: Lavatht G~~ Zoning; R12,S Utll~~ Wator; p.~pn~ .~...~.. C....,.. _~CVUltl t~lbUe I Labd 1'\ 01 'ral\t~~ 0' Oetlth~ /; Act.UNI 1o.5281u t<!elgbbo, , Ijt. ~. Land $l%e 2$0$3.1.357 . TVj).: ~Suburilan c.ireb!lItvt F.oMinl: I Grav-et l.a"-cI$'Q ping t rVPiUhl) NonQ Drw.w,*v; Ntioltiorhoed ".~""""",,,,,,,,,',o - "te.u~ 1 to 3 trees WlltilU'Vicwl !-4011ll \Veta" "I'QQ~ Non. S-n<<: VlOwt Rivervtcw ~nct~ .- RaltrD041 'baffit:: tJulQA~ ........... r'- ......4..a....'" f ot-h~ Comrncrctab 0 J~fluotl;c: "! COde;! Building ~..~...;. ..~..'.........- --. .....'.-. PropertY 1966 BuildJtl9 Styll.t:: Split Stoll-.:: 1 C"a~ htertor Wall Vinyl Siding LVcal" Buill: I 1955 If Kltl;1*81"nl 1 M~ttl,blb ~ .at~l[- .....-.'.- '-FIfulace: JO Bedroo"'~J 3 Heatina Tv-De~ Hot WaterISt."m , Fuel type: Oil C.tttt.' Alr: t-b'1e "aemul I I .--J Overall Norml! for ,Agll OV.t~dl C!tedes, &oA#mY Tn#l Cra+i'I Co ncll.ttont . Roofing ~~~:an~l ~!.~~~rCDt 0 Cov~nect: POlefll 0 M-aled.'. ..~".- enclosed 330 flrat floo~ 14$9 ). heoltdFtoot 0 Poreb~ A~ ' . Areal ..- AdditIonal 0 Haff$t~fV n 3/4S",ty Floof 0 Acor ~raa: P~r Aru: I _~!I ..- ~:~:J./71~ '<f - T~al squa,! 8-1lsemont 672 - G8ta;~ SFl 0 foa~. Famnv lt~~ll Half a.tft 1 .!t.si$bed Attie l) 1. Gar.Ts: I Da\ach.d .2 ~ ...-.................. ,_h.. -',r~fuW Cvc~ linlslted lSS4 ~e.~~}\.-"~ UM'Sl9ltOUt 0 Ba'e1'n.n~ L_.u....... if Qar-.u..: 5J212007 Reassess,org . Reassessment ofPropeny Values t'-" j." ".,./. l ...... . .'., . ..,.." ". I "I.{/>.:;L . ;~~... ~-~.~. ~~. . '\' ,,-.. ,." Page 10f2 ...!.........u....~...._..M'N,..;.:.~..~...~:--....~~ ReAssess. or!!} f'{It'I{ I 'l 2 ecr;; I.HELD I CONTACT I COunty> Assc ORPS . Fair Assessments Town Red R of Town Town of . City Hom~ HOOk hineber,:k North of Rye WaShingtonWapping<<s, Pougb.k East r . . .. ca$t Towl -Gr4ngeSaellmanUmonvale AmenTa Fishkill FishklU Beacon Pougl'lk ,~ ... --';1 i:.;:;.):,~":.: Main t: SBl~16158~ 14c.41S413-0000 Owner: . PUQuile An Cardenia I Swfs:! 135601 II secuon:JlOO6 I Sub Section: 1158 [ BJock:/I0014 II Lot:l418 Sub Lot: /413 I str..tlls8 II Street Name:) N ~.1Q$ier Av NUmMt: l Propettv~210 , Sc:hooJ 1~5501 Class: District: Sufruc I JI No~:::~'f515814 o.crfPtlon lQ:S3Ae (C) Site L SlteNumbef~l' ff seHM- 'T-YDe:!1PobliCl I.SidewlUk- TVPGlllNOnQ L Topography:llLevef fit Grade 11 Zon'no:l!R12.S If U1Jlities:J/4 r Waterij[PubliC lr SewenUPublic I Land Tv.,.: 101 I Frontage:llo II u.""'E;:j _'0..",., l LandSialf23033,73S'7 I Neighbor . . . SUe 12 Type: Suburban Desir.btUtv: f ,0nclng:1I None II ori"oway:IIGCiWll! I[ (.nd$QtPfng:1 N~f~h~o%ood r Tr.":lt1 to J trees II Water View:jlNona If Water FronbUNena Scenic: View:lINone J/ Rlver VleWlI ]I Pond:!l I Ibililtoad:lI II TAlffk::1l ]1 %ndWlltiar: II I ..m....~'~ I O"et I . Infl~ !BUilding ......: I . II slories:111 r Ptol.::}(1966 I Building Style: (SPilt II fxterior wai:I[VinYl Siding /I Y_r aUilblft9ss II KltChens:llt Mat.rllllf: . r Bath_:l/1 JI hdroolM;{ 3 I Fireplacel!1o I Heating Typ~fHot :WaterlStilam JI fuel Type~l Oil I . Central Atrll1Nona [ Basementllcr wi II ovora1:1 Norml!!1 fer AOli " ov...._ rmy . Tvpe; a Condition: Roofing Architectural L openPor':h:l~o 1leovered porC:h:lo Materi.'. Grade I Incloqdllo J First :~::~p;;-' ~ $4=c~llct~=:~ to Porch: t AdditJonal~o i ... ...~ 8"4...~ -<~ Floor Ar..: Floor Area: Area: Total Square 11 388 I Basement 0 I Gal1lDesf:llo Footage: · FamllvRoom: I It.at BattlJll J Finished Attlilo . = Jl G.rage TVP4t:UOetilchec :2 FJnlsh.d 1684 /[. unAssigned:]1 I. Fin$sn.J Over 0 Basement Garage:.. r , ; ..:.:....f- .,,;,. .. ....... . ~. ;;......~- ...;', " tJ~)::? -J.-. / ," .(', i ~...." . . ~. '~} . ;~1; t-{ in!( 0--.... :.., ,...... ~ '..~ '3 :5" Lf r1.).~~:.. .,' "c." . '~Y~)~?:.~.'t.-. y."",,,,,,~,,;,_,,,''''''''_''''''':''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''," .....0'\..... http:lb.vww.reassess.org/Display .asp?txtLookupKey=6158~ 14-478413..0000 5114/2007 ........~....~.......~....-.........""..........-...-...'....................'.....................-...........................-...............-.-".,.,..._:0:0:0:.;~~~...."i>;o;...x.........O';...............;..................~ -}>>>M,.Hhutchess County, NY Property Record . PfJr(elACCtrs~"f UV~>C:"H ~::.t:t. t>.'\' - ..~-:.. _~:j~;-....t:'.:;*~X~~l~)~~~~~~\~. TENTATIVE Roll - May 1 , 2001 ~.IdElntilbdbllf!: 13sa01~1~14-478413~O P~t.ooaIlQ!I '~r...:~tA~.. Y~#.f.~iilil~lJltrFsE$ ..................... .. .... ...... .... ...... ~.,nfO(/'lU\ll;!!! \"ifAA!IIil!'; i<udqoaitn\n"IP)' "" Caroenki . Vl'Uitlia Ilene tA) Plirna.... IPI Q~ner Mall AtW'm N sa Maller Ave Wapplrig'ni FIll:& NY 12S900000 .f!..rceI 0ai9l1$ Size (8cres)~ File Msp. Fife Lot #: Split Ter....o 0.53 Ao (e} AGe~nllnlonnaliQn land: rOl&l: $6~ $$4000 T.iiX Code: H: Horne.slId Tent. ReS: S.i1i2005 Lau Sa!.tTramfet Saltl5 Prioe: $0 S&.II1TOrmil!:;m; Sile NllInbs~ 1 Water SIlPI*1~ (3) Comlt\ipub~ Ro3 SKu:)n: Final, Roll: 7/1i2oo7 ~~.!nfOlmatlo:n: Slte Nln11beI: 1 Year 8ulll: li55 No. Kitchens: 1 Contral J>Jr: Year Remtld".= o NQ, Fu~ Balhll: 1 Heat Typa: Page 1 of2 .,~~'1;~'*-~~~~:!(!!f.:r..!!!i!!!!M~~,'l'>"\;;;;.I".;~~11i~~,~~~~:~:::;;;;;;;:;::::: . LJ?.(I~t~~Q~01 land Uu Clas,: (210) Re~Menfial: One Fam;i{ Yaar-RO;llld RfJ_llle.'loe Agli- Oisl.: (0) ~cI1O\)I~lli~: (135801) WsppmlJllf falls Clllnlral School Oi$i.!'.cl Counly Texaole~ S3~1lOO Ta.'m Tay.abl&: S35400ll SchOQl Ta~lIbIB: $354ooQ ~i1.T~tlll: $354000 Uniform %: Futl MMe.. Vfllll~; S 354000 100 Valuation: 7:1>'2006 Sale OllIe: o D!I&d Book: 2200$ SSIIl Ccndllion: () D&ed p~: G5340 NIL Parcels: o Sewer Ty~: (3) Ccmmi~b~c. D<is%ab$lly: ~) T'l'PQI Zoning Coda; Rf25 U$ed As.: o Bllilding Stile: Nll. Storieli. SP.a: OTerali Ctlllcl,: (03) Spillaoal 1 2Cl84 (3) Normal 1)"0. Half 8atm: No. BSltrCQms: Nil. Fife P/';ces: BlI$OIMnfType: t 3 0 (3)Paltlal Fuel Type; Firsl Slory: Seeon:r~IDrY: AddL $IOIY: http://geoaccess,co.dutchess.ny .1lsfparcelaccesslpropertyC ard.asp?swis;13560 1 &parcelgrid=1356... 5/19/2007 ...J;2lltdless County, l'i"Y Property Record Page 1 of2 PtJ,.ceLA<<e,s.~"'--"""""'-"-,' :-."~w~~,.;.,."",:." ...!.~I:~:~:=!;..~~'.. .' FiflalRon - ..July 1 . 2007 ~r~l Grid khml![lillJj.qt\:!; 135601-(H5I44.4714 f 3-0000 ~ll.:o.~h1! N 58 Moaifr Ave Village of ~ppil"\get Falls ~!H.'nformallon Cardenla . Pafiqllilt. An (PI Cardonia . Virginia Ire Ile fA) PrllT'oB"" lPl OMIer MaJJ.A~1:Q.fl.!! N 58 Mesler Ave Wappingers F1lrll; NY J259COOOO ~rcel Details sa. (acru): FlleMep: File Lot #: Split Town 0.53 Ac {C} A$.eS$ment!!mL~ Land: Total: $87903 $.'W90f.<O Tax Code: H: HOlM$tollG Roll SeCllon: 1 Tent. R.on: 511/2006 Fin$l. Roll: 71JJ2007 ~.!!.!'?~tefTran:;,rQt Sak$ Ptlee: ~ .$tJttforrnatlon' sae Number: 1 Wa~r Supply: (3) Col"llm'"pubrlC Residential.Buildinn Information' SUe Nllrr~r; 1 YeilrBuik: Voltr Romeo.: 1955 0 No. Kitchens: 1 NO.l"uB Ba1hs: 1 Contral Air: HoalType: Lane! Use C!ne~ (210) Rui<tential: One FemUr Y~lJr.RolJnct Resld~"CXJ A;ri.Oillt.: (O} SenoGI Oistt\ct.: (135&01) ~P1>ln;llr Falla Central School O~triet County Taxable; 5340000 Town TlIXiI.ble: $340000 &:11<<11 TlIli'lIble: $349000 ViUage Taxable: $349COO Unifo~m%~ 100 Full tMrket Value: $~OO Valu;1tfon: 7W20CS Sals Dale: o Sislc Com/ilion: o t~o. Paronl50: {) Ol!edBook: 2200t Ql,~ Page: 05'40 SovmrTyptl; (3} Comm'P\lbli" t)esirabnity. (2) Typical Zoning Co~; ~12.5 lJntS As: o Building Style: (Q3)Split leva I No. SID"": GC' SIlf:'),. 2222 .' -~",,,,..,. OvIttsll Cond,: (3) Normal No. Half Balhs: 1 No. ~droolM: 3 No. FirePlace.: o Basement Tyll'il: (3) Partial Fuel Type: Finl Story: Socond Story: Adli!. Story: http://geoaccess.co.dutchess.ny .usfparcelaccess/propertyCard.asp?swis= 13 560 1 & parcelgrid== 13 560.,. 8/9/2007 IMain I 58L:n~SS'1'HI18413'OOOO I owner.li;.SQual~ An Cardeniiil j SWbl:1I13S601 II I Block: 1100 14 II I Nu~.::IIS8 I Strod Name: N Mesler Av I ptoCIl210 II l . SUffixll II I DescriptionlJ(Es3 Ac (C) jSite ~ I Site NUfDbet':1I1 I TOpogTaphy:lILevel at Grade I Water.llPubflC I frontave:lIo I Lands~eI1230J3.73S7 I Fcnc:i"il=IINon8 I TreeIi:llt to 3 trees; I Scenic ViewillNOIle I aailfoad~1I I --....+ iBuitding I ~c::=111966 rbter.:::.w::~IIVinyf Siding f Baths:lJl I ~ing ,.ype:IIHot Water/Steam I. Rcassess.org - Reasse$Smeut of Property Values .............O;~("~:- l{J!r\sse..~s ~ () I'YJ "'" ORPS . Fait A$Sessments H~ fled Hook Rhinebeck L8Grange BeetaMn Soctlon~lI006 Lot:141B .::::::11135601 H~:::~~1S814.1S II street Typo;lIP\1blic II zo".I1tJ:.IIR1~.S II sewer: lIPtJblic II ~:lIo II N;=llsUbUrban II Dtivewa\'tIIGrave' II water View=I[Ncine lIRWcl' vieW!1 /I ......ffk:ll I 1anS: I IlSfdtdlniJ S~]J$Pllt II Yeer BUiU:1119S5 ]I 1k'ldrooms:1l3 If Fud Type:I!Oll hUp:llreassess. (,uglDispl ay .asp'rtxlLookupKey~'61 58..14-478413-0000 Unionv.afe Town of Town oUlye Town of North E;ast . W8Shingion Aml!nla east Fishkitf Fishkill II Sub Sedion;1I1S8 II SLtb 1..ot;1I413 II Sidewalk Type:lINone II Utilltios:U4 n La" Type:l 01 If Acreage:lo.528782 11 Dalrabif~~112 1.1 t.aftdlt,qping:ltrvPlcal to Nolqhborhood . II Water front:lINone 1I Pond=u II l"dQ$h",1:11 ~ Stor*=IF II K~heM:lll II fireplaee:llo II cent'.lAir:l1~o,..e Page 1 of~ ~ "ELf' I CONl'ACT us County '> Assessw . Citr of W.pmger Pough1leepsle Town of --- Beacon Pougb1leepsit I I ..~ I (~ .()I~a 4L,22- SF ~.'."'" ,.. -.-. ., .51f.?J G/. <- (? () G ,~ 1'7-2'-/ {o ~. ry,.J CJ;rtNU~~'1 j ...,;, fr<.. . 6V~ .. .::l .r>Mb . J. -rr.. '. '. . ~.J4-t.,;v~.~} . :7...10 t ~'''''l $- . e.. ..e, M.P-",>-C-, ./" ~W~ ~A.. ~,~ ~~.a.d-AJI2.A 8/912007 J:;S,org. Reassessment of Property Values ..tr1'(~ Hage 2 or2.... .P'(g~dY.t~. Free Property Tax info Find what you're looking for! www.thb-lalt-site.com NY.PfQ~rtY V~.Iu~ Get Recent Sales Data For 1 ,OODs of Commercial Properties Nationwide, www.LoopNul.wmlComp{ Q.".~g~..~~~. find Garage Plan Here. Visit our Garage Plan Guide, AbOut-Gaf1lg~Pla".lnfc er.~P.'(Jy..I~ Cmu..~~~ The Largest PrQperty Tax Services Orgnaization In the US, www,Ooloilto,corrVuz I Ba;1IPertial II OYero~1 II Over.1I Grt":Io:Ileeonomv I Condit.m Normal for age I Roofingllfreh~edU~1 Open Porch~ 10 I eov.,ted Por<:h:lo ...ter.... Grade I encloud"330 I FlrstFIoor 11368 I Sec:Ohd Roer 10 Porch: At_: Ar..: AdctitiomI:llo II F=::.~lo IfS/4 Story =~If fJoOt At'U: I Tot-;:112.222 II f.:::::~S04 II GarllQDSF:I/S16 I I Half s.tblll II Finished 4ukllo II "'...go Type:!I0etached2 I I u::=16S4 II unAuig....:i II fjnls~=1I0 I Photos ~ ~ fE] L'JC' (?1 lliJ 2rl . http;//reas~ss.orgf()isplay .asp?txtLookupKey~6158.14~4 7841)...0000 8/9/2007 I do not understand how my assessment was only reduced by 1.5% or 55,000 (from 5354,000 to 5349,(00); even though the town assessors card clearly shows that the house has not changed since before 2000; and the total SF should still be 1724 and not 2222. This is a decrease of 22% in SF. I would have thought the assessment reduction (excluding land) would have been more in line with the reduction in house square footage, back to 1724. I my opinion, I believe that the revaluation was forced fit into happening There was plenty of data to show that MJW had done a poor job but since the town had to go to 100% assessment to gain certain benefits, I can understand that this was pushed through. I do not understand why MJW could not fix the database for months and then tell me it's too late and I have to deal with town assessor. I don't know why the reduction was only 1.5% when the error was 22%. I suspect, but have no proof, that the review board may have been overwhelmed; and rumor has it that unless there was an "official external assessment" that RP 524 was rejected. I tried to find out some facts by a FOIL, to see the minutes of the review; in order to determine what the overall data was. I did not expect to see what my detail was but I did expect I could see some general information & attendance. This information, could have included the number of submissions and the overall results. Example of the 1000 (or what ever the real number was) RP524 submitted: 50% were rejected with no changes, 20% had decreases of 1 - 10%, 20% had a decrease of 11 - 20% and 10% were decreased by over 20%. I was told that there were no minutes submitted to Town clerk (see attached sheet that shows requirements for minutes). I would like to know who was there to do reviews, was it all the members, were there any substitutes, etc. This would give a good indication on how much time they had (on overage) to due reasonable "due diligence" on each package. I called Dutchess county clerk office and spoke to person who does training for the people doing this review. I was given 5 names and have generated an a single sheet affidavit and am asking the Town clerk to ask the people to rea and sign. This simple attests that the basic & assumed facts were covered. (Added sheet to be read & sign attached) Attached is: . Single sheet for reviewers to read & sign that they were present & trained; and that they read & understood my package & had no questions. . e-mail from Wappingers Town clerk (no minutes), etc. . Sheet from Dutchess county training package (entire power point presentation was requested & given to Wappingers Town clerk). · 2 FOILs 1, th~undeMgned, do rtate that indMdually I ba\-c re,iewed and understood the infol1Jllthlnin tbe patk4gesahnutted; and had 110 additional qucmon regarding the RP-524 Complaint of real propert)' assessment for 2007, whhrderente to- propt:rt)' identified as 6158 14 418413. (58 North Meiier An.) I, also did see & understood all of the foUowing: 1, That homeowner stated he was &'\l'ay (on pre-scheduled business in Kansas City MO 5/22 ..5/24),. but 8nilable to meet with re\1ew board anytime staring the evening of 5/24 and the remainder of May . O\\-ner told 2123 or nothing. 2. The September 2002 Wappingers Assessor and Dutchess County hearlngoffic.er (finding of John H Thomas kEsq.) settlement sho\\ing that the assessment was $83,700 (based on Fair Market Value of 5146,800 @57% - the unifonn pcrrent in use at that time), along with. the corresponding Trav~letS lnsura.rwepolicy for S14O.00. a. That the Dew assessment of $349,OO~represented a $138% increase in FMVfrom September of2002to Assessment date of July 1006 t.Tbis l\-'eraged over 60% per ,'enr ri~in FMV. t. The total of 1124 (not 2222) sq. fft:t livable sqllare footage has not changed since 2002. This.is dlKUtDented in the IsseJimcnt agreement (enteml into b~' bome O\\ller. Town assessor and Dutchess country hearing offiC{lr) 3. MJW Consulting and town assessor were notified and re-notified of SF error; both said they would take care of error. It appears that To-wn updated theirpapuwork but database used (or ass~SD1ent wftsnever changed and is stiUincorredwhen matched to both town assessor's file cad and owner. a. The information on town assessor's flle (since 2002) agrees \~ith and shows the same total 1724 sq. feet not the 2222 sq. reetlbat \Vas inputted into database ~. tvuw Consulting. b. The Town assessor's office recogniud the error but. only adjusted (lowered)lbe asses.smcntby S5K (S3'4K to 349K) even though Uie error was 498 SF difference in living area e. This repretents lI.reducnoD is .assessment of lesstban 1.5% while the Ih.ingSF was..reducedbyo.,'el" Z2%. 4. The (Travelers) insurance pl')licy for referenced property for the period April 2006 to April 2007; sho\\lngthe d",-eUinQ &; structures were insured for SI93,600.lfland value isinduded the total mv. approximates 260,000. 5. The compatibles (Comp) sheets showing that both square footage and land values for a sampling or 15 properties, in my immediate area, llppearedto be erratic: and unequall)' assessed. Moreexam,plcs could h<: made available ifueeded. a. Square footage as8eSsmentswinging from S56 - .328 pex square foot often deviating drasticaUyfor identical home model & condition. . b.Exaet samemode.l home showing livable square footage from 993 SF tGover I2QOSF. Co Similar land (acreage) values ~,,\.inging from $76,060 (S5 Mesier Ave. - .S3acres 011 Wapplngers Lake =: S91.11<lper acre) to S137K1peracre (South Mesier AYe.) d. Commereialland (onl)') adjacent ~ a~tQ!ls from my propet1~' is as~essed at less than homestead land (~umples cited 1701 route 9. S79.3KJacre & 1769-1115 Route 9 . S100Klacre) 6. All members have succes.sfully completed the RPTL sec. 523 mandated training for BQ8Id of assessment Re\ie\v members and iran Initial appoilltee(s) and/or re-appointee(s) have attend the training session given by County Director; as required. Bridget Ganon-Tyuszczak date of class(es) KeIUletll Brown date of class(<:$) Robert Siefennann date o.f c1ass(es) . Joe Perillo dale of dass(es) . Eugene Parlin date of class(cs) The ablWe signed, do i\\"ear that the following statemen1B are tNt, complete and correct (as amended ormoolfied) below &, I or O\'el', as requirtd. page Lof 1 Pat Cardenia ~"".",,\,\..;..,,\,.,' ',.':' .,...... ~" .... . .. .. u _._ "," ._._.._.._,.._,....................'\,. ,.....,.,":...". ........... .... .,..h.... ~.....;. ,;, .:. ...:.;.......:.....,..u,..,.__._..........................;.......:. .......~.._. "'''.' '," .H. ......:........_._.............-.~.. .;........,.. ,..... .....- ,',.. '-,' ...____.__...n.........._._..........'.............. From: Chris Masterson [cmasterson@townofWappinger.usl Sent: Wednesday, August 08,20077:33 PM ~ ~~~a ') SUbject: RE: Board of Assessment Training module , . ., . , .. '." .~~:::f O~.~<-~. · . (p.}\.l<~J(.~ "~.()L ,^'lL('L {~~A.o~ i.4~.\ft~ Mr.Camsnla, >.I . . .' As lexpe.cted,the home phone numbers of those Board Members are to be withheld in the caseote FOfLrequest. This is in accordance with Section 87 (2)(b) of the Freedom of Information law. SectionS7(3)(b} teUs you Jnformatlonthat would be maintained by the Town and $ubJectto FOIL, buUhese Items do not satisfy WhlityOU are looking fOf. As of this moment, there are no Minutes for the Meeting that you are inquiring about. I. hav~seen what has been prepared for these meetings in the past and will make sure this years set is filed with me when they are done. You will need to check. back periodically to see ifthey are complete so thatwe can process a FOIL for you. If you'd like, I can send you copies ofthe advisory opinions that! researched, Give me a call if you have questions. Chris Masterson, Town Clerk Town of Wappinger 20 Middtebush Road Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 845..297..5771 Office 845-298..1478 Fax . _..hOriginal Nessage-h-- From: cardenia [mailto:wecand04u3@aol.coml Sent: WednesdaYJ August 08, 2007 3:39 PM To: Chris Masterson Gc: wecand04u3@netscape.net Subject~ Board of Assessment Training module Chris, I appreciate YOUf help In trying to reply to my FOIL requests. Here is internet address forthepresentatian that I got from county clerk's office & told you t would send you. http://www.co.dutchess.ny.us/CountyGOv/Departments/ReaIPropertyTaxJ8596.htm 1 etsoattachedpower point (.ppt) presentation. As I mentioned. what I need is some record of who (was it 1 or all 5), when (date(s))& how many packages (total number of packages including mine) were reviewed by these people. I requestedaddr&$sesso I could see if anyone, familiarwlth village properties, was on the board and toiee how their houses were assessed .for comparison. I wanted to see what period oHime or how much time was allotted to each package, InClodlngmlne. andfinalty who looked at my package (was it village. knowledge able person? Did everyone look at every package? I thought they look at them as teams of 2 & 3 and if needed consulted on them. I can only go by the comments of asse"or's office {Loretta told me) that "they had abOut a 1000 packages8and this raises a strong concem that the review team may haVe wanted to do a good job but had insufflcienltime and therefore did an incomplete review . 1 also wanted to see if meeting minutes addressed what type of evidence these people wefe tookingfor, so I could provide it, if I can not get this information. I'll add a request in the package I fil~ with country clerk (RPTL 730) Friday 8/1012007 Pat Cardenla 8/912007 Heating testirnony and taking pl"oof Persooqlappearances not necessal"Y BO'ltd may requite a personal appea.rancc. Complainant no-I: entitleq to any te.. quction i .Uful neglect ot refusal to supply tequesteq infotmation (qismissaD Tl525 (2)) BAR Membetmust file if he has any interest in q property comIng befote the boarq an~ sboulq abstGlil1 from the c\iscussion (tecusql Minutes Minutes of theptoceediogs must be taken and filed with tH clerk Disclosure or intet~est (RP523-dcl) TO"~ OF V\!..\.PPL,{ G.ER 2{lMI.DDLEBUSH RD. W.APP1"JGERS FJ..lLS,NY 125~)(l TO\"lN ctERK. OFFICE: 84;-297.5771 - FA.X: 845-297-4558 t APPLICATION FOR. .PUBLIC ACCESS TO RECORDS ! 1~''''I..r1 ! Date Request Received: 1r trv I I 1 Recorded = C1Y1~.'. .i"1.as~" .son~ T { ;vn Clerk . ....... t" '{ .~ :,"if From: ):YJ.' . v,:- I Clerk "i~?DI:-' . l,f. Print Name:. ? - . . i\il.. ~ lOW I ,~ . Agency or Fmn: u. eJ. I Address: sF> ,(. Q v t-\ ....c.A_~... ~~AC i Tel. iI: f/'f s-. 217- "177'3 Fax #: FOIL # ;J /q ,,;\! I 1 .' I ! l 1 hereby app1~' 10: inspect the following record andJor ! receive a con" l'a~ .25 ce-.nt~ /page if av~i1a1Jle: to the nub1ic ! i t"", ~ . ,.- ..t"'. j Description of record requested: tt/(l--yr&.;I. ClfU(,~"""~ (t,"L .'. . .1 I' . t',. \ I': ..4 L~l --., I I' ., < C.$."~/t;L'.~v"'-' C';..1-f!..u.~'/J.<'l...~) ~. '{j r-, 1<.. >.,;..yLt:i....,~...~<..L"t....;;j.I.. , 1 I l: . ! ;\.. I ! I l , ~ :: t. ": i~ \... i\.PPRQ"VED/DENlED REVIE\VED BY: RECEIVEj) BY: DA TE RECEIVED: Open C In Review 0 Closed U Denied U A.PPOINT!\.1ENT SET: Depanrnent Head DATE FILED: .............................--..............-.......................................... TO'VN OF \V.AJ>}>INGER 2{) tvilDDLEBUSB :P.D. 'WA...Ppn~GERS FALLS, NY 12590 TO\"-lN C:'PItK OFFICE: S45~297-577j -FAX: 845~197-4558 I ....\PPLICA'ITON FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO RECOF.DS I Dat.e Request Receive& J?~.1. FOIL # . ~/? I. Recorde~.: /t Clu1E 1.1asteJS. on, To\vn Clerk I From:~ttt l }11./.a..f! I ZJ ! .. .... C~t Si[71ahlrp. -; ! Prim Naule: Pf PrR'b C:-lV \ A j I Agency or Firm: S 44.. P . I Address: 58 fl)~ ~S/67Z. tJE ,i I Tel.#: . 'i5~ 29?- -'11''73 Fad: ' ~ J here'by app}y to: mspect the following record andior . . ... 1 ~ rec~'h"e~ CODV (@ .25 cents inage ifavailabie tCl the Dub1icl I Desc.ription of record requested: .. ~' . ~ .' I 1 ~d - (kt,. ' ~ef l.~,;o i j' a) i I .A~ ~ 1 7fC'&:R#,1 ; .APPROVED/DENIED I I REv1E\\'""ED BY: 'l \ RECEIVE]) BY: DATE .RECEIVED: O>yen 0 In Review 0 Closed C Denied 0 APPOTh'"Th'iENT SET: Deoartnlenl Head ... .. DATE FlLED: ... fS; ARRIVING AT FULL MARKET VALUE BASED ON RECENTLY SOLD PROPERTY Property Selected = 2 Liss Road I personally went to Town Assessor's Office & examined their Book of Sales For 2006 (period I was told to use), I found 5 properties that sold in my area { Mesier & Liss. These included: 2 Liss Road Sale Price $325K reassessed at $281K 26 & 47Liss Road Sale Price $ 00 according to book 18 No Mesier Sale price $ 279K 29 Mesier Sale price $ 266K Many of these properties have apparent errors in their data 2 Liss road sold in Feb. 2006 for $325K, it was reassessed to $281K 14% reduction? 18 N Mesier Ave sold in May 2006 for 279K, it was reassessed at $392K 40% increase? Our property was reassessed in 9/2002 a $146.8K (including land) and with out any building improvements had its SF raised to 2222 We believe that if the current assessment was reduced as follows: Land reduced from $67903 to $53000 based on a FMV of 100K/acres This value is higher than the adjacent commercial property is currently assessed at Home was reduced from 281K (349K-land) to 218K based on same $/SF but changing erroneous 2222 SF to correct 1724 SF The total would be $271 K - close to our estimate of $294.6K The total would be $294.3K - if we 140/sf I attempted to use the calculated $/sq foot for a sampling of home including Kenneth Brown 11 Plaza Rd 3848 sf house (1960) assessed at 347K Eugene Parlin 25 Martin Drive 2144sf house (1972) assessed at $376K $821per slf $1421per slf These properties along with other properties identified in original RP524 have an avg. $140 slf As a sanity check I looked at 22 Peter Dr. - A high end luxury house built & sold 2002 with 4443 sf . The 1 acre of land was assessed at only 68K & total of 758K? this makes the cost $155 slf in line with the numbers I used for a 1955 house I requested average data from Assessor, even if he gave me copy of database, I could calculate average for all & have more & better evidence The MJW data failed to take into account the fact that WF uses Chloramines This may prove to be a questionable water quality issue (see sheet on Chloramines) for all homes in Wappingers. Especially for Senor Citizens !: 'll".v.,.'UII. PU\f\.S'I.k1~ Pm!) OWII Miltli CI:m~ emic Code) Grid IJ SUI loc~,i1tm Ac~res De.~t1 P(~je II of PCfl'WI!~ f)t:tl<J Book 2 iiI 135601 Gl51.()6.;liJHl5 H)OO<) 21i:~ 4 Sl)lJth Av~ O.?3 2>!CJOB 9tlt 1 JIm 13!iOO1 G153-10.46Z5OtrOOtlO 26 Liss Hd {};:}4 Z;ilf)U1l 126U 1 210 . 1:J560't fi15S.JO-400fi56.otlllQ '17- Uss ~..,: t200G 1:152 1 ;e;q;;ll~ J{ Rd U.22 210 1.15tlO1 lH58.14.-4704~9.{JOOO 2. U~;& Fl.d 0.2:9 22006 1665 1 210 1361m'! 111!'~ 1 fl<l8:J070-000U 51 Rctln$cn AliI} 0.22 22006 1<tail 1 2t(l 13560') o 15l.J..1JJ-!){lUtl71,.Q(J(J1l 48 W~llls.s Tl:lf n.07 . 2200f; '1(i[16 1 1.10 135601 G15B-19-51110fJi'.()QUl) 20 Slt~~rt Ave Ci,1 .22tlO6 '1114 1 2Hl f:lM01 G15/l-19-S461.IIHU1OO 11 Wcnlh.~$ 'H'f' 0,06 22Q06 1~~O 1 2Jtl 1:15601 (1151l-1 lJ-547100.QU(.lf) " mIJ3rt Ave 0.06 nOOG 1383 I .. 210 1:m601 G158-'1 ~.550111:}'()O{)f) II Wcmlis$ HI' D,O!) ?~OOG 1323 '1 2Hl 135601 6151HJ041"'J17-t.)l.lllO n f>tl!)gi Tm' 0,1"1 220M t1m~ 1 I!Hl 1:lSGOl 6158.:!IO.4G80(.}1..(XlOO 20 fmmnra Illvd 0.11 ~2fJU6 1262 1 2W 13SGO'1 {HM-1B-3l'1151-()OOO 29 Mi::SleT ....... ^'il~ n,11 220(}6 144:~ 1 4(:)2 13!.mOI f..tl rill-' !}4l232()IHlOOO 1570 HO\.lh;l 9 lUG 22000 "I<'IUi! .~ t 9 .-<"l...t.ll'i.-d s ,. <~ :: . '0 P3~ 31 of:m S:?lll~ PI'Ir.tl :uJ5(lOO Q o 32tii'KlO 221,lO{lO 18WJO '183510 1fH500 ~~05600 194fl{lO o 1(l.~()(JO 266000 o OWtl~t NmnEj f~bIJr;Cl,Atldm;~ Tilll!~l>.l)~l'It1i$ Hnynos.Larry 1.. Sf Trust Qo$SSlIlo3, Mtunlt) M(;GilitlEl*i!i.. M[c::l"tael Mar.r.By..Clmryl l)~<:k. .lohnH. HI.lnt.ar. Ntlil P~tlI.N!d101mi Hunter, Neil $i~I1tt:"fM10. PC1ula Q,$t~lItZ(), TIIOfl'las ll11ilnr. $teptlet1. J. H[} DevelOpment of Md me, .....Ut.\dl~l>> ""vuu~Y. l'i 1 rlVVeHY 1\.~~Oru ./ / Final RolI- July 1 ,2007 ~~~ 2..~.~. 2<<J 6 .page 1 ot 2 '~ " . .. " , . . .. "~"",,<<<~')')~JM.U,,!!l!JlI!!!l!llllllfl!lllllllllil!llllm!!!!nlrl(~"':::::;:i:::": '~.' , 1- ~ 0/6 %~ I~t..' 1,f-:;UI1,.f}..'~",-., . ~'. -,. if "2/11 I -~lr% ~ l~ 2Js:P~ge 1 flualgM ldentif!Clltl~ 13580.!:!U!5.!-14-4282So.<lOQO .,~.r" ........................ ...../~.!.1.~!1 ,._.,...:.~..... ..' N 18 Mesier Ave \ l. Village of IN.1Pi>lnger F8h..)_"...,,~., -...--.........-...,...'........,........._~.::.::.:..........- ~rlnt LJu . AnIOn {F'} ..... .~re~~ 18 Lyman Sf Port Jotv/$ t~y 12771 ??oo 2 LISS'- 3Z Fit .... ~rl Jl Parcel P.blila sa. (uc;relt): Ale M.p: file l.ot,: Spit Town so. X 200 ll.s..htnllrn Informatlo-n Land: To~.l: $47578 $3$2500 ValllatJon: 71112006 . ..-,. />d1 .L... ,...".~_._'--......;'".............._. ,............. <;. -'''''':..ex.. .r-- . " .-..~.-...'.-.".......-..... . .,.~...:~..;. . .~. ',; /' ~~--:- ~~2:"'''PM ')'fi.~7 :;:....' \,~.;____._ov~:~_.y.."_.w...,_.......~,,....~w...,...._..7..-~...m.. ...."..... .'. c----_..... __......? ~.ll'lfOrmetiol); &uI NUmber: 1 WItter SUpply; (3) Corntl\ipublic Tax CoCfa: H: fWmesload Tent Roll 5/112008 Roll Seetion: 1 Fir.a!. Ron: 7/t12OO7 Retildenlilll ~~JmJ Infonr.aliol).; Site ~~umbet: t Year &lilt: Year Remod.: 1900 0 ~~ o Cenllal Air: Heal Type: '-i'-' "-~'l~: '.' . ~ ..-,;:. land Vile Cf8~: (220) Re$lder.r!a,\~.;;~~.~e~;~;~,;;;:;;~--.l ~"T:3 92 ~c t'" '/' 0 dC' , AQII. D/st.: (0) ;~ '--'~"L.--;-:-_.." School Dislrlct: {135e01} Wappinger Fallf; Central Schoof Dl$'trict ~,.. ~"1..1..>3 5 0 ~ ,..:.' .,...,.~ '1 ~ (IJ . l~T.~' --. !f.,.~. I~ $3S2SOO .,-,..' $3$25CO / jr--f ( . ' ---.' . / t.___ _._____ ./ ~ ./ .' "" . ,;-,../'" --.-----,..-,,' Cllunty Taxable: $392500 To\'<T1 Texable: $3&2500 Unlfonn%: 100 Fun Melket Vatue: $' 392500 j:!$.A '7' v..... \() ............. Sale Conaalon: (J) ng.P4l~lic; 1 Sewer Type: (3) COmm:p~bli~ o.sitabll!ty: (2) Typical Zoninll Codo: RY.5 UMd As: {} Buildfn; Sty~: (08) Old styie t'lo. Stories: 2 r"'-~~ lj 2068' \. ............~........................... :0:"";'-'- OvoraU Cond.: (3) Notmal No. Half-Saths: o No_ Bodtooms: 3 t~o, Fir. Plaeas: o 8a5omeot Type: (4) Full Fllel Typo: FirslSto1Y: St~Stosy: Addt Story: http~lfgeoaccess.co.dutchess.ny .us/parcelaccess/propertyCard.asp?swis"" 13 560 1 &parcelgrid= 13 560... 8/8/2007 .......~..."'..,.:.~........;.:.'<I'o UUt\iUC~~ ,-,vwn.y" r"i I rlupeny KeC.Ofa Ja~ ",~~'1Z-e " '*'f~~-f;; 1>.... 'll...... n.'. ..(i. '.'e. iAcms '... . . _""n""_--""fl""'_'~"fl"""'I'J,lflf.fl"_"""'H... ,,:,~~':i::~t/!::l~~~I' {~rint Page Final Roll - July 1 . 2007 Parcel OM 1cI&IltltiaI~!l~ 135801-6158-14-418413-0000 ~~ N 58 Mesier Ave VI/faga .of VVappinllllr Fais 9'.vner InfOlll)atio..n Carden Ii . PaSquale M (P) Cardenla . Virginia IIeno (A] ~irooary{PJ OYml!tMt.1! A<ldrallli N 58 Mesler AVf4 ~\lapplng.r& Falla NY 125900000 Pareel ~~illl SiZo (8(:1'~): file Map: FIle Lelt #: Split Town 0.53 Ae (0) ........~ Intolm.a~ /'" Lat\4: ': Total: C S87iO~L/ $349000 -~~. Talt Code: H: Ho~lIt..d Tent Roll: 5.'112006 \ , wt s.leffran5lor Saln Prn:e: SO Site Intolm.atkl(l; Site Numbar: 1 Wallr Supply. (3) Commfpublic Roll Section: 1 Final. Roll: 7/1i20Cfl ~enlJal BullsJilJ9Jnf~ Site Number: 1 VoarSuilt 1955 No. KItchens: 1 CenlJ8l AJr: VO'ar Remo<l.: o No, Full Baths: 1 Hilt Type: Page lot 2 .A ir6,. ~V U5ed A$: () . . r..) A . ~'"'... .-.J;. 'l."t ~ \-, . n.n. ..~' ~ . -. tllJ... ,-;,;..."'-...-. ~ /~<'. 0;' ", . \ . 22V L.Ilru:l Usa Clus: (210) fte$:dontlel: Ono Family Year.Rol;nd Residence Awn.Oi&t.: (0) &:hoof Oi$ttl;t; {13S$01} Wapfl!nger Fans Central School Olslrlct County iaxable: . $349000 ~~.; SchOOl Ta...:able: $:J.lSOOO Vllhlge Taxable: $349000 No. Pa~3: o Overall Cond.; (3) Normal SasementT~: (3) Pllri!af http://geoaccess.co.dutchess.ny .uslparcela.ccess/propertyCard.asp?swis= 13 560 1 &parcelgrid= 13560.,. 8/8/2007 Add!. Story: Uniform,%: 100 Full Marker Valutl: $349000 Vatuafuln: 711J20C5 Sale Dete: o 0..0 Book: 22001 Olred Page: 05346 ~Ill Con<li1ion: n Sewer Type: (3) CGJ'Iltnfpublic: OUlt.bUily; (2) Typt'Clll Zoning CvdlJ: R12.S euikiing Style: (03) Spfitl&vel No. $tOIls: No. Half Baths: 1 No. BGdtoom&: 3 N~. Fila Pi4!:eS: o Fuel Type; First StoJY: &lXlMStOry: iJutcness LOunty, NY Property Record I"i',.:.;....~;.:.;.~.~.;...,.,. Page 1 of3 . P~JA.ms~ ....;~':."..".."-"..::--"'. 1'....,,"".....,,__..... ~". ltMdl~!S~l~N~. IV ./~ . ,>...~.'ii"@;'{-t~~i$i.~:~~.~~~<W.($ . ~~r'1'1'; t--- Final Roll - July 1. 2007 ~J3rid IdentlflCation.l; 135689-6257.o1.328&84..(l()OO fmtl~ 11 P~Z11 Rd Town afV>klppinger ~or'nforrnalion BrO'h'ne . Kenneth P tP) t:lrowne ,Craig PtA} PrilJJJ.lY..{Pi Ownor Mail,64ofU' 11 Plaza Rd ~ppir.ger Falls NY 12590??oo Parco J DotsIil& Slze (acrea): File Map: File Lot_; SI:I~ Town .34 lor. 1653 Land u~ Class: Agn. 0I$t.: School Oislrict (210) Rnidenllal: One Family Year.Round ResldCn~e (0) (135&)1) Wappinger Fa. central School DiStrict 6 ~S$mant I"forma~~ Land: Total: $59144 $347000 Tax Cod.: H: Harr~stead renL RoU; 5.'112005 Last Salolfranskfr 6;110$ Pri~8: $0 ,.............~...~..............,.. ~(9~!l; Sito Humber. 1 \/Valer 8upply; (3) Comm'PUbl'.c RoU Section: Final. Roll: 7/112001 8~llld8nlit.. ~i1R>>m Information: Site Number: 1 Y~ar &Jjlt: ~~..,.......... No. Kitchens: 1 Centtal Air. Veer Ramo.d.: o No. Full SlIl\s: 2 Heat Typo: County Tllxatxe: $347000 Town Taxable: $347000 $cnaOI Tax_ble: "'f$'J4'7~ --- ~. L,t 7.. oat ..-~ . j >>~'l~ (:(4 t t:.. 1 I ... ,J i.J ::;:!g'7ffiff I ..." :3 &:);~l {;}'" , ~:~; r'< t .r+ t. .,.:.:.:.,:".:.:.,,,<;,m;.:...,,,,<.>.,...,,<>-/...,._,<>,,*~ g. """"") .. ~."" I .... .' · 1/.". .... . 8 .:: . ~< -, -. . , ,'" i ..~..~ Vlllageraub!$~ so No. Par<<::allo: o UtedAa: () OYersll CoM.: (3) Normal B.asement T~: (3) PaIUI http://geoaccess.co.dutchess.ny.us/parcelaccess/propertyCard.asp?swis=13 5689&parcelgrid=13568... 8/8/2007 Addl.~ry: Uniform 'l(,: 100 Fill! Market V;ilue: $ 347000 Valuation: 7/112006 Sale [)QIll: o Deed Boolt: 1952 Deed Page: ~8 Sale Condition; o Sewer Type: (3) Cof'lll1\lpublic Desirability: (2) Typical Zoning COde: R20 Bui!4lng Style: (01) Ranel1 No. Storie=.: Sfb: L~] t:o. Half Bath5: o No. BedroOI\'l$: 3 No. F'we P1a.ces: 1 Fuel Type; First Story: Second Stery: UUl~Ht:1)l; \,.,QUmy,l'l I rropeny KeCOra ~. t ,. \ ,. l . .~....'.{J:.. .f1;. .'Cl~:~ iAt'GlI.S '-9"~.;~. :'((.:~! \I(!<!.!~:U . ~OCh\.~. C...<<.....J. .. NY /. ~ ) ~~ (4 - . # _ ~ .":':'::::>>':""'W",,""'<':,,"'.'Wl~w.<i:H<'j~iigl.j'J.l . r'" Jt ~.' i ., ~t ! ..............=~ #. I . ~..._~;.,./~:"l"."........:;"'" ..r~!.!l~M.1U.:<#k........ ... [ PdntPage) Final Roll - July 1 I 2007 I:lJJ;OI Grid Iden~t~f.l..f; 135689-6358-01 -01-4890.0000 Parcel l~~n 25 Martin Or Town of Wappinger O..~r/"forlr<iltion Parlin , Eu~ne (PI Parlin, Ol.ln& (A) E!imilri.fPJ..~cr Mail Addrllss 2:) Mart!n Or 'h'lsppingcrll Falis NY 125&00000 .I "Po E(}:JiE(liJu.c:ltr.,f!!l ~~~---. .~,. O~~l~~,~L"""""",.,::~"",) LlInd Ute CIU$: mO) Reslderni!/: One FalrJIy Year.Round Reside/1l;8- ./'......... File Map:. Agri.OiSI.: (0) i Fila lot'; 831 S<:hoof Dl$tr.ct: (13560'1) \/\lapping"r F'altaCenl1alScflool Ohifrlct .' j l' l ..;' i-::.;~ /\ ~litTown '~l..~sment Intonnatlon l8niE....."1 Total: t10253 ;: $378000 ~ Tax Code: H: Homutead RaU $1lcl.lon: Tent. Roll: 501i2006 Final. Roll: 7/11'2007 ~t S2ilttlTransfet Safe~ Price: $0 ilt~ Information: Site Number: 1 lNalllr Supply: (3) ColM'Vpubtic BluiAAllJ}~1 ~uilding Informati9Jt Slto Numt>er:1 YUf Built: Vllar Rel"l'.od.: 1972 o t{o. Kitdlcn$; No. Fu:f Baths: 2 1 Centrel Ail: Hll4tiVP6 : ~. -. County Taxable: $37$)00 Town l' axable: $376000 Sebool Taxable: $316000 ~~ TUBble: $0 Page 1 ot 'J. --. .-, /) i",/..i <.:~ ,~: b i JL...:--....:..:.. ...,/ ~, : 'J .".~ 7r\ ^} 5"3 T(-{) '~;d~'H'H .;. .;;........... .'.......... <<0:';- .................. ~" "~' ~:::iiX:).,5....d ~7..7 /" ;""'7 i" .e^.l'~..l ;:->;...:,...;.... .. "';';'0' ".. 1/.. , ')t i~ If)" " ""} I /~1./ ! ~<<l:"" ~ ' : .<<-:-...... / ....;x ,...... l , http://geoaccess.co.dutchess.ny .uslparcelaccess/propertyCard.asp?swis= 13 5689&parcelgrid= 13568.. _ 8/9/2007 Uniform "k 100 Full Miln<itl Value: $ 376000 Valuat~n: 711:2006 &ale 01110: o ~ea Beak: 1350 Sele Condi'tlon: o Coed Page: 0765 No. Parcels: o &\\'8r T~pa. (3) Cornm'puh~e Deslrablllty: {2l TVpl~1 Zoning Code: R40 Used As: () Bui!ding 81y'.e; (02) Raised ranch No. $lMlllS: ~r"llll Cond.; (2) Fflr Sfla: ~.v....,....a."._"""""".l "\ 2144 f \ .,;.........,,-~~ tlo. F1r&Pie~5: o tlo .liaif Bathi: o No.. Bllcjroo.ms: SalOenlent Type: (4) Full A .. Fuel iyp&; Fil$t Story: Second Sto/'Y' Adell. Story: ......1.n\'Ou\i~::i ,",VUIU.y ~ 1'1 J. r 1 VjJIClL Y aCl,;UIU ./ ./" l.' ~ : j . ! .. \,. f , ../ ../., '\fj"< fl fyf jJ /~/ ....,.:.~} Ji2ld.0':L.. rf5.'l:\ l.('d.~::>"".:"''''. "t.t: . ::{ Is. .... .' " /. ^' . v "''<f '. ,,~:..;. {...:,.,;. f! .../. "f,:li /' ParttlACGISS J.)"'li.hf:t.~ (~~J:' N\' ....;;,;~,~~('~.:;1:~~.".;:;.;.t'... '." ,".-, /" ::J ., /. .1EV ~ rY" IV' f l:"age 1 OIJ Print Page J J ": ! L1;CAJL... t ^ .~ 'J r l' N'~' Ji ~~-.-'~ I" /. . /) ^ '. i (.-l'~ "vv- . C,., v v f (~ I.......-S-_..~...~ ~- ..~... L 1<. .'" oJ.' / ,..., l- I !tier ~ s,"'7i:!-:.! l....--.---."....;.L~...:.^ http://geoaccess.co.dutchess. ny .us/parcelaccess/propenyCard.asp?swi s= 13 5689&parcelgrid;: 11568,. . 8/8/2007 ...... ". .... -.-...-.-'-'.-.. ........-.. ........:i......... ~ 1 ::' Final Roll - July 1 ,2007 ~ Identification ,. 135669-6151..Q.4-972219.oooo &(~I Lceeliotl 22 Plaler Or Town of Wapplngar "'o,vner lilformlt~ Detlillllleovi . UnO. (p) ':.. P1lmelY CP~r Mail Addren 22 Peter Dr ..' WaP9inger Fells NY 12S900000..../ "\. .......... "',,- ...,.... ...............~...-. ,.' Pafco!.P.Gfliif5 Sb:e (aefei): FUe Map: Fila Lot'; Spilt Town 1,00 Ac(s} !389 6 Assessmantl!l~ Land: Total: $88819 $758000 Tax Codti: H: HOI'niI$fead Roll Section: 1 Tent. Roll: 511/2006 Finlll. Roll: 7/112001 Lnt SelelTrll.nllf!! Sakll:i PriGa: $13000 Silo Info~Nn; SIte Number: 1 Wiler Supply: (3) CommfpUbllc ~UJt Bu/ldlno Inform~lt9.n;. Site Number: 1 Year Built: Year Remocf.: 2002 0 No.~n$: 1 No.FuU Bath$; 4 Central AIr: Heat TylXt: ~ j"i'~ . ~ } -~ .~ c.r(.~~' I ....u/ . I' C- t:i dCJ:.s ) { =' JI' ._......_..,......... .. r~.~. .c,;;.~'.'Z.Z ...- -. 17! i)~ r~ ..J/ "1.'1./'1 ..( / t:) (j , .I .} ---' I .' gp : -- ......'" ;.:...;-...... ",./ /".,~~ [. Lsncf U,e Cla$S: (21Q) Rni<fenUal: Oftu Fam.'ly Year-Round Rnidem:;a Agli. Oisl.: (O) Se/lQ-oI 0ls1rict: (135&01) Wapplltg&t FallllCAntlal Sellool OilllriQ County TaKable: $75eooo Town Taxable: $758000 Sehool Tuabl&: $753000 VllJage Taxable: $0 Uniform 'IIi: 100 Full Market Value: $ 7S8000 Valualion: 71112()C~ .~::::;;;'"'~- Sala Dato: 7J26i2001 Deed &olt: 22001 Sale Condition: (J) Da.d Page: 06148 No,PafCOl/i: 1 Sewer Type: (2) Private Oeslnibility: (2) typical Zoning Code; R40 U5edAs: () Suikllng Style: (05) COlonial No. Slories: 2 r-'-~'-! .. I ;__...J No. Fire Place~ 1 Ballement Type: I.3.l Pal'lial Overall Cond.: (3). NoTtnill No. Hilt Baths: o ~lo. BflClrcoms: 5 Fuel Type: First Stoly: SeOJnd Slory: Add\. &wry Using chloramine to disinfect drinking water is becoming a common standard practice among drinking water utilities. A number of utilities have made this switch from chlorine to chloramines. Background information on chloramines · Chloramines are produced by combining chlorine and ammonia. While obviously toxic at high levels, neither has proven to pose health concerns to humans at the levels currently used for drinking water disinfection. · Chloramines are weaker disinfectants than chlorine, but are more stable, thus extending disinfectant benefits throughout a water utility's distribution system. They are not used as the primary disinfectant for your water. Chloramines are used for maintaining a disinfectant residual in the distribution system so that disinfected drinking water is kept safe. · Chloramines produce disinfection byproducts in the distribution system. Some disinfection byproducts, such as the trihalomethanes (THMs) and haloacetic acids (HAAs), may have adverse health effects at high levels. · These disinfection byproducts are closely regulated by EPA. EPA recently reduced the allowable Maximum Contaminant Levels for total THMs to 80 ug/L and now limit HAAs to 60 ug/L. Chlorine and chloramines is also regulated by the EPA. Other concerns with Chloramines: http://chloramine.org/chloraminefacts.htm#effectsofchloramine · Chloramines, like chlorine, are toxic to fish and amphibians at levels used for drinking water. Unlike chlorine, chloramines do not rapidly dissipate on standing. Neither do they dissipate by boiling. Fish owners must neutralize or remove chloramines from water used in aquariums or ponds. Treatment products are readily available at aquarium supply stores. · Chloramines react with certain types of rubber hoses and gaskets, such as those on washing machines and hot water heaters. Black or greasy particles may appear as these materials degrade. Replacement materials are commonly available at hardware and plumber supply stores.. · Chloramine cannot kill the pathogens in the water as well as chlorine. As a result, people with suppressed immune systems must have their water boiled over TEN minutes BEFORE use to kill pathogens, or they risk becoming ill. Those at risk include children under 6 months of age, the elderly, those on or who have had chemotherapy, people with HW or AIDS, organ transplant patients, and others with a weakened immune system. · Chloramine can cause and/or aggravate respiratory problems. Chloramine fumes can cause an individual to become congested and cause sneezing, sinus congestion, coughing, choking, wheezing, shortness of breath, and asthma (see the Hazardous Substances Fact Sheet for Chloramine, PDF, 98 KB), by the New Jersey Department of Health and Senior Services). An increase in asthma due to exposure from chloramine was shown in a study from the Catholic University. · Chloraminated vapor from showers, baths, hot tubs, dishwashers, and other household appliances contains volatilized chemicals that can be inhaled and cause irritation to the respiratory tract. Chloramine damages mucous membranes. The lung damage in those exposed to chloramine, in indoor pool air, is similar to that seen in regular smokers (see Health24 News article). Inhaled chloraminated vapor can enter the bloodstream directly through the lungs. It bypasses the digestive tract where the SFPUC says it is broken down and excreted. The SFPUC says that, "if mono chloramine enters the bloodstream directly, it combines with hemoglobin (red blood cells) so it can no longer carry oxygen" · An individual can experience long term effects from repeated exposures to a chemical Oike chloramine) at levels not high enough to make them immediately sick (see the Hazardous Substances Fact Sheet for Chloramine). The likelihood of becoming sick from a chemical increases with exposure time and concentration. · In a study by Zierler, et al (PDF, 821 KB), it was found that there was an increase in deaths from influenza and pneumonia in the communities that used chloramine. (Communities in Massachusetts that used chlorine for disinfection were compared to those that used chloramine). Chloramine exposure damages lung mucosa, making the lungs more susceptible to allergens and infections. Chloramine is a less effective disinfectant and therefore people are exposed to more pathogens. · Chloramine tap water can cause severe skin reactions: rashing, dry skin, itching, flaking, welting, blistering, chapping, burning sensation, 'cracking, scarring, bleeding and pigmentation. Chloramine can aggravate other skin conditions such as eczema and psoriasis. Chloramine can cause bleeding lips, dry mouth and dry throat. Chloramine can cause burning, red, and dry eyes. · Skin exposure to ammonia "breaks down cell structural proteins, extracts water from the cells and initiates an inflammatory response, which further damages the surrounding tissues." · Chloramine damages digestive mucosa and can aggravate digestive disorders. It is suggested that monochloramlne is responsible for gastric cancer. (Journal of Gastroenterology, 1997, "Enhancement by Monochloramine of the Development of Gastric Cancers in Rats; a possible mechanism of Helicobacter, pylori-associated gastric carcinogenesis. · Persons with liver or kidney disease and those with hereditary urea cycle disorders are at increased risk for ammonia toxicity from the consumption of chloraminated water. Chloramine can diffuse through the reverse osmosis membrane filters utilized by some hemo-dialysis machines, and patients undergoing kidney dialysis could be adversely affected. To prevent this dialysis equipment MUST be adjusted to remove chloramine and the treated water MUST be monitored to measure the final chloramine concentration. Dialysis facilities must review their dialysis treatment equipment to determine its continued safe operation. Unot it may cause hemolytic anemia.